"Captain Underpants"
Some folks had their underwear in a bunch over this children's book series by Dav Pilkey. The "Captain Underpants" series -- about two fourth-graders and their superhero of a principal -- has the distinction of being one of the top 10 most frequently banned and challenged books for 2002, 2004 and 2005. The series were cited as having offensive language, being sexually explicit and being anti-family.
"The Lord of the Rings"
J.R.R Tolkien's beloved book was burned, not in the fires of Mount Doom, but outside of a church in Alamogordo, N.M., in 2001 because it was viewed as "Satanic." How precious, Gollum might say.
"Merriam Webster Collegiate Dictionary"
When it comes to banning books (and knowledge) even the dictionary gets no respect. "The Merriam-Webster Collegiate Dictionary" was pulled from the shelf of a school in Menifee, Calif. The offending term in the dictionary? "Oral sex." The entry references of the dictionary also included cunnilingus and fellatio, which were not cited as the reasons for pulling the dictionary off the shelf. Merriam-Webster has been publishing language reference books for more than 150 years. They were bound to offend someone along the way.
"Fahrenheit 451"
Could a book about censorship really be banned? Absolutely. Enter "Fahrenheit 451" by Ray Bradbury. The book has been banned by the Mississippi School District (1999). It's also number 69 on the American Library Association's list of top banned/challenged books from 2000 to 2009.
Harry Potter series
One of the most surprising banned books sits at the number one spot on the ALA list. It's not even a book. It's the entire Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling. The Harry Potter series is to teens as "Star Wars" was to an entire generation of now-40-somethings. The series has been challenged for occultism, Satanism, violence, being anti-family and having religious viewpoint. The series is number one on the ALA's most challenged book list for 2000 to 2009.
"The Grapes of Wrath"
John Steinbeck's "The Grapes of Wrath" is not just another classic on the list. The book was originally banned in California due to obscenity. However, the catalyst behind the banning was based more in embarrassment. The people in the region did not like how their area and the workers' situation was portrayed in the novel.
"Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?"
Most parents of kids under the age of five have seen Eric Carle's art accompanying the book by Bill Martin. The Texas Board of Education banned the book, in January 2010, because it thought the book was written by the same Bill Martin who penned the non-children's book, "Ethical Marxism: The Categorical Imperative of Liberation." A quick Internet search could have cleared up the apparent confusion.
"James and the Giant Peach"
Author Roald Dahl is no stranger to being banned. His book, "The Witches" is on the ALA's 100 most frequently challenged books for 1990 to 1999 for its depictions of women and witches. But what about James and his peach? Was there witchcraft at work? James was disobedient and there was violence in the book.
"American Heritage Dictionary" (1969)
"The American Heritage Dictionary" of 1969 was also banned in 1978 in an Eldon, Mo., library, because of 39 objectionable words. But the dictionary continued to cause trouble as far away as Alaska, where it was banned by the Anchorage School Board in 1987 for its inclusion of slang words, including "balls."
Grimm's Fairy Tales
Fairy tales have always clung to their precarious place in children's literature. On one side, readers have fairy-tale purists who lament the morals lost in fairy tales that have been too cleaned up. Others object to any violence in fairy tales. A couple of California school districts found a whole new reason to ban "Grimm's Fairy Tales" in 1989: misuse of alcohol. Little Red Riding Hood's basket for her grandmother includes wine. Maybe it wasn't a California red.
Published by Pam Gaulin - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment and Lifestyle
Pam Gaulin is a freelance writer, journalist (B.A., Journalism), new (and next!) media writer and artist. Associated Content named her 2007 Content Producer of the Year. "First for Women" magazine featured... View profile
Celebrate Intellectual Freedom During Banned Books Week Sept. 29 - Oct. 6This year's Banned Books Week will be held September 29 through October 6, and will involve special events and displays at libraries and bookstores across the nation. - Are Books Bad?Banned Book Week 2007 has just passed. How do you feel about books being banned and challenged? I don't think they should be.
Twenty-five Top Banned Books in the United StatesThe American Library Association is celebrating Banned Books Week September 25 - October 2 this year. Following is a list of what I consider to be the top 25, separated by the r...- Banned BooksBanned Books Week encourages Americans to read challenged classics and contemporary stories.
- During Banned Books Week, A Look at Huckleberry FinnA look at the shifting tide of intolerance affecting the availability of a great American novel.
- Banned Books Week: 10 Banned Authors
- Banned Books Week (September 29-October 6) Celebrates the Freedom to Read
- Banned Books Week 2008
- American Library Association Names 100 Most Banned Books
- Celebrate Banned Books Week by Reading
- Banned Books: How Far is Too Far?
- Banned Books Week is September 29 to October 6





20 Comments
Post a CommentThe thing about banning books is that it makes everyone want to know what the hubub is about. Negative publicity is still publicity! I think I've read all the books you listed except for "Brown Bear".
I can't believe how crazy book-banning has gotten! I was completely baffled to see some of these on the list. How ridiculous. Great article, Pam!
Love it. I'm a school librarian and I see challenges of all kinds. Roald Dahl's Revolting Rhymes is a favorite around here. I had never heard of Captain Underpants being banned though!
I know some of these from "assigned reading".
The banning of books is out of control.
I know all these. I still can't believe the mix-up with "Brown Bear, Brown Bear" and how silly it is to ban "Captain Underpants." Of course, I don't think ANY should be banned, but silly nonetheless!
I thnk people tend to be too sensitive. It is literature. I personally like mosst to fht ebooks listed here very much and encourage my children (and always have) to be open minded to different forms of literature and art.
Many of these books are classics. Excellent look at them, Pam.
Very interesting article, Pam!
I enjoyed lots of the books on this list. I am not fond of the Captain Underpants series. One of the kids checked one out from the library once and the language used in them doesn't belong in a children's book.