2010 Olympics: Plushenko Takes Silver, Complains He was Robbed. Hey, Geni, Lysacek Don't Need No Steekin' Quad! He Can Skate!
One Jump Should Not Decide a Competition
Evgeni Plushenko is mewling to everyone who will listen that he was robbed because Evan Lysacek won the gold without doing a quad, claiming "You can't be considered a true men's champion without a quad." He then insinuated that if you don't do a quad, you are not a "man," stating "Without the quadruple, I'm sorry, but it's not men." (Give me a break. And what kind of name is "Evgeni" anyway?)
The live chats on the Official Olympic site, two days later, were still debating Lysacek's win. All of Russia is up in arms, feeling unjustly cheated. Even Prime Minister Vladimir Putin entered the fray, publicly stating that Plushenko deserved gold. So convinced that the quad is everything, even Russian legendary Russian coach Alexei Mishin said. "Twenty years ago, we needed quad to win. And now we don't need to do quad?" He then noted the Olympic motto of "Faster, higher, stronger," and added, "The rule will be changed."
Evan Lysacek's response to Plushenko's whining and Russia' outrage was, "I spent the last year perfecting 4 minutes, 40 seconds. If the medal was for your best jump, they would give you 10 seconds and no music."
"Without quad," Plushenko said, "it is not figure skating. It is dancing." News flash, Geni, it's called "ice skating," not "ice jumping." If only jumps, which are just 50% of the score, were considered, we might as well have an ice skating competition and an ice jumping competition. And Lysacek did more jumps, including more triple axels, in the second half of his program, where a 10% bonus is awarded. Whether you like it or not, fluidity and mastery of the elements between the jumps and spins, and going the distance when you're tired, count. Plushenko did all his hard jumps in the beginning of his program.
Plushenko is being a real ass about this, don't you think? While Lysacek did not attempt a quad, he excelled in artistry and footwork. And he landed his jumps cleanly. The truth be told, Plushenko's performance was sloppy, most of his jumps were not landed cleanly, and his positions in the air were crooked and awkward. His spins were slow and his footwork, while engaging, was not as good as Lysacek's. If you go to this site, and click on the "+" next to the skater's name, you can see the breakdown that clearly shows Lysasek's technical marks were higher than Plushenko's.
Shall we talk about being robbed of gold medals? Let's travel back to 1994, when even Nancy Kerrigan's almost blind mother could see that Ukranian Oksana Baiul made significant mistakes in a less technical program, landing only four jumps, none of them combos, while Kerrigan did five clean triple jumps, two in combination. And yet Baiul was awarded the gold.
Or shall we bring up the 2002 Olympics where, in a deal with the Russians, a Canadian judge was "pressured" to favor the Russian figure skating team over the Canadians in return for the Russians favoring a French ice dancing team?
And shall we go into the suspicion that Russian track and field gold medallists in the 1960s, Tamara and Irina Press, were really men. When mandatory chromosome testing was introduced in 1966, the "sisters" withdrew from the European Championships and vanished from the public eye.
I could go on, but the point is that Russian athletes have taken home quite a few gold medals that they didn't deserve (all breathing a sigh of relief that they would not be sent to the Gulag or their parents evicted from their government apartments). Furthermore, Plushenko's statement that he returned because he "missed competition" was refuted when it was revealed that he only came out of retirement because the Russian Federation "approached" him. He's probably lucky there isn't a "gulag" anymore.
The Eastern Europeans and Russians always favored their own, most particularly in the ice dancing and figure skating. Now that we have a fair scoring system, they can't stand it. They also can't stand that they're being massacred in the total medal count in Vancouver, and had counted on Plushenko's gold.
Boohoo, the Russians think they were dissed. Too bad, Lysacek was better. We got the gold legitimately and without cheating. We're keeping it. Take your quad and shove it.
More by this writer: Lysacek Takes Gold in Men's Figure Skating
Sources: Lysacek gold fails to silence quad debate; Men's Free Program results; Baiul Wins Gold Medal; Tamara and Irina Press; 2002 Olympic Judging Scandal
Published by Patricia Sicilia - Featured Contributor in Travel
A Domestic Travel Featured Contributor, Patricia Sicilia's wordsmithing began at age 9 when, after reading a book way too old for her, she told her mother "I'm retiring to my boudoir." Freelancing for over... View profile
- Will Evan Lysacek Shave for Dancing with the Stars?Why doesn't Evan Lysacek shave for his figure skating performances? Better question is will he shave for Dancing with the Stars?
Evan Lysacek Has Second Place in 2010 Olympics Men's Figure SkatingEvan Lysacek had a great night in men's figure skating after a clean performance in the men's short program on Tuesday night.
Does Evan Lysacek Offer the U.S. A Gold Medal Hope in the 2010 Vancouver...Evan Lysacek, the 2009 World Men's Figure Skating Champion, will be representing the United States in the 2010 Vancouver Winter Olympics. Will Lysacek post a medal winning perfo...
USA's Evan Lysacek Battled it Out for the Gold In Men's Free Skate in Fi...By less than a point coming in it was fierce competition between Japan's Takahashi, USA's Lysacek, and the 2006 Olympic Gold Medalist from Russia, Plushenko. In the end, Lysace...- Nastia Liukin and Evan Lysacek: Are They Dating or Not?Nastia Liukin says she and Evan Lysacek are dating. Lysacek says they're friends. Who's lying?
- Russian Skater Evgeni Plushenko Leads 2010 Men's Olympic Skating After Short Progr...
- Evan Lysacek Wins Men's Figure Skating Olympic Gold, Plushenko Takes Silver
- Evgeni Plushenko, Evan Lysacek Lead After Men's Figure Skating Short Program in Va...
- Evgeni Plushenko is a Sore Loser, Evan Lysacek Won Olympic Gold Fair and Square!
- 2010 Men's Olympic Figure Skating Preview: Evgeni Plushenko, Evan Lysacek, Stephan...
- Men's Figure Skating Preview - Evgeni Plushenko, Evan Lysacek, Daisuke Takahashi F...
- Olympic Men's Figure Skating: Controversy Rages on for Plushenko, Lysacek


21 Comments
Post a Commentsigh... ;)
How you say "Boo Hoo" in Rusky?
Is this for real? Why blatantly lie to suit your own agenda. Smirk on his face... he had no expression until he got the silver spot.
This is a nasty, mean little diatribe. What sort of name is Evgeni... are you for real? Even his name is a problem?
And he's right. Take the jumps out it IS ice dancing. Take the quad out, it IS women's standard. He's not wrong.
He has every right to be angry with the judging. All this stuff about Evan did this and did that, I perfected, blah blah. His skate was ugly, soulless flapping. Yes, forget the quad. No way he deserved component marks up with Lambiel's and Takahashi's. Evan's coach admitted Lysacek isn't the most talented. Indeed, he's not. But it's gold medals for "most improved."
If Evgeni was so awful, and Evan so brilliant... why was it so close?
Well I also missed all of this but the report is interesting.
Lysacek clearly outskated Plushenko...the better skater won the gold, and displayed better sportsmanship to boot.
I totally missed all of this, so I don't have an opinion on it, but I was very entertained by your report!!
Karl, this is a "skating competition," which means you actually have to"skate" in between jumps. EP was given full credit for his quad, but the rest of his program just was sloppy. As I said in the article, it's called Ice Skating, not Ice Jumping. If everyone thought the quad was the end all and be all, then we just should have let EP go out, do his quad and leave. Considering what poor sports and cheats the russians have been over the decades, I find this controversy specious. And now they're threatening to take revenge in 2014 by denying our skaters their just marks. Just like the Russians.
Let;s put our emotions aside, Lysacek did not deserve to win. This is not a dance show and Quad has to be there. Are we going to send Disney-on-ice in the next Olympics???
Someone needs to point out to Pleshenko that he got maximum credit for his quad-triple jump. But the rest of his program didn't generate enough points to take first place. He doesn't get this. His spins were lame. His footwork wasn't nearly what it was four years ago. He just announced he's going for the 2014 Olympics. Well, he better bump up his spins and footwork, because there's a whole new field of younger skaters who are doing quads.
Great article!!!!!!!