Like any other year, not everyone agrees with the nominations given by the Academy, and several experts have weighed in in an effort to show them the error of their ways. I looked at the NPR blog and also the slideshow blog by The Hollywood Reporter. I agreed with many of their assessments, and also had a few of my own.
Best Director: Christopher Nolan for Inception.
It was only recently that I watched Inception and agree with The Hollywood Reporter that this was worthy of an Oscar nod. They mention that the Nolan won a best director award from The Director's Guild. The film was complex, dealing with the balance between the real world and the dream world.
Best Supporting Actress: Barbara Hershey in The Black Swan and Keira Knightly in Never Let Me Go.
While some others have suggested that the true snub in this category is Mila Kunis in The Black Swan, I think Hershey's and Knightly's performances stood out. While Kunis' performance was good, despite being very enthralled in the film, my mind kept referring to her role as Jackie in "That 70's Show." I hadn't looked closely at the cast before seeing The Black Swan and I had to go back and confirm both Hershey's role as Oscar-nominated Natalie Portman's mother and Winona Ryder's role as the dancer scorned. Ryder did not have enough of a presence in the movie to warrant a nomination, although she did a great job as well, and Hershey showed amazing range as an actress.
Knightly truly surprised me. I'm not a big Keira Knightly fan; frankly, I normally find her quite annoying. However, she shined in Never Let Me Go, showing her ability to hold onto a character consumed by jealousy and facing her own mortality.
Best Actor: Ryan Gosling in Blue Valentine
What can I say? I love Ryan Gosling, and happen to think he is one of the most versatile actors in the business; he was exceptional in Blue Valentine. Perhaps the Academy felt the need to pick one of the stars of the movie to give an Oscar nod to. While Michelle Williams did fine in the movie, I felt Gosling performance was much better, and his character more complex than Williams'.
There were many more excellent performances and films in 2010, and choosing the best of the best must be a daunting task no matter how long you've been at it. There will always be those who feel snubbed, and those who don't agree. Still, the 83rd Academy Awards still promises to be an exciting event. The nominees should all be proud.
Published by Gretchen Lee Bourquin
I am the mother of two college students living outside Minneapolis, MN. I write fiction, poetry, informational articles and commentary pieces on various topics. My work has appeared in various places onl... View profile
- Predicted Oscar Winners for the 83rd Academy AwardsThe nominees for the 83rd Academy Awards were announced Tuesday morning by Tom Sherak, the President of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.
- 83rd Academy Awards Celebrity Presenters List Keeps Adding StarsWho will present the gold statuettes for the 83rd Academy Awards on February 27th? Here's the roster to-date of Oscar's presenters for 2011, a virtual thespian veteran's day salute. The list includes Academy Awards no...
83rd Academy Awards: Best Actor Nominations & PredictionsOscar is rolling out the red carpet February 27, 2011 for the Academy Awards Ceremony. Here's a little teaser of the Best Actor nominations with my own attempt at a prediction.- Hathaway to Co-Host 83rd Academy AwardsUp and comer, Anne Hathaway is certainly coming into her own. With a nod from the powers that be, Hathaway is closing 2010 with an Oscar nomination for 'Love and Other Drugs' and will be co-hosting the 83rd Acad...
- 2011 Oscar Nominations: "The King's Speech" Dominates 83rd Academy AwardsThe 83rd Academy Awards features a lot of first-time nominees.
- Michelle WIlliams and Ryan Gosling Premiere "Blue Valentine" at the Museum of Mode...
- Natalie Portman's "Black Swan" Early Oscar Buzz
- Squelching the "Oscar Snubs"
- Snubbed Oscar Nominees 2010
- 2008 Oscar Awards: Nomination Predictions
- Actor and Actress Oscar Snubs for 2010
- Sundance Film Festival Favorites Grab Nominations for 83rd Academy Awards





1 Comments
Post a CommentIn a world of total consensus there is probably only one person :-}