Batman Arkham Asylum
It's a great game all around. The voice acting is suburb, the graphics are good and the combat is varied. The problem is there's not much else once the campaign is over. I never got into the challenge rooms, which are levels from the campaign were you have different objectives like timed fights and pulling off certain moves. It's good if you want to beat the high score on the leader board or collect more trophies, but I don't see any lasting appeal.
Star Wars Force Unleashed
Once I finished Force Unleashed, I tried to replay but I couldn't get into it. I unlocked the different ending, feeling disappointed that nothing else peaked my interest. The campaign is on the short side at 8 to 10 hours. While that doesn't have to be a bad thing, the game is very linear. There's no need to go back for side missions, items, or exploration. Once you play through a level, you get the feeling you're done and that's it.
Alan Wake
Alan Wake is one of those games that once you get through and know the story and plot twists, there's little reason to replay. There are plenty of items like manuscripts to collect and some of them you can only get in Nightmare mode. That's not enough to replay unless you're obsessed with achievements, especially since most of the collectibles don't give you any new skills or unlockables. Alan Wake is a fun, scary ride that loses its punch once you know what's coming.
The Darkness
The campaign is great and interesting, but isn't long at about 10 hours. There are some side missions where you can choose to act through dialogue or violence, but they aren't enough to keep replaying. What really hurts the Darkness is the tacked on multiplayer. The abilities you learn in the campaign can't be used online and it seems pointless to try to master them. Besides that, the multiplayer is very small with four modes that aren't exciting.
Mortal Kombat Vs. DC
I've been playing Mortal Kombat since the beginning. Even when there was only a handful of characters, the game was usually good for a quick replay. As the series progressed, I enjoyed the story mode and the more "fun" modes like puzzles and racing. But, Mortal Kombat Vs. DC left me wanting more. The story mode is very short and unsatisfying. Sure, you can play as both the DC and MK side but it feels rushed and underdeveloped. The arcade mode suffers from the same thing. There's not much to do in the game and only two characters to unlock. The online play is okay, but nothing special begging to be replayed over and over.
Heavy Rain
I thought replaying Heavy Rain would be fun, but I was wrong. I even wrote about the good replay value in a review while I was making my way through the game for the second time. I thought about all the decisions I made through the game and how interesting it would be to change them. But like with Alan Wake, once you know the story, there really isn't much there and the excitement of replaying wanes. Heavy Rain is an amazing game and only true trophy addicts will make their way through it completely more then once.
While none of these are bad games, there's really no reason to keep them in your collection. Every one of these games leave you with the feeling you seen and done it all after the credits roll. Replay value isn't needed to make a game great, but it's an added component that most players hope for when browsing titles.
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.
Published by Jennifer Amlie - Featured Contributor in Technology
Jennifer has been playing video games since the NES was released. The Legend of Zelda is her favorite series. She also enjoys BioShock, Gears of War, Fallout, and countless others. When she's not gaming, she... View profile
- Is Replay Value in Video Games Overrated?Most video game reviewers want a good story, good characters, good graphics, good sound and good replay value. All those things are usually created pretty equal but is replay value really that important?
- What Children Can Learn from Playing Video GamesThis editorial describes one parent's experience raising a boy who played a lot of video games. She feels video games may have gotten a bad rap. It's possible to incrase skills in literacy, problem-solving and more...
- The Best Video Games for Young KidsChildren's video games sometimes aren't suitable for children after all but this guide will help you choose ones that are.
The Perfect Job: Video Games TesterA video games tester sounds like a neat job, playing video games all day for pay, but it is anything but. See what it takes to be a tester and what the job entails.- Looking at Mortal Kombat Vs. DC UniverseLooking at Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe
- Video Games with No Replay Value: Five Popular One-Trick Ponies
- 5 of the Best Video Games with the Worst Replay Value
- Top 10 Video Games with Exceptional Replay Value
- How Trophies and Achievements Are Replacing Replay Value in Video Games
- Some of the Worst Games for Replay Value
- The Factors that Add Replay Value to Video Games
- Video Games with Great Replay Value




5 Comments
Post a CommentYeah, I can see what Nathaniel is saying. Once you reach the end of the story, you know the plot and ending, so the fun is gone. I'm not a gamer, but I bet many movie-based games would wind up here.
The thing is that most story driven games (which two thirds of your list fall under) tend to not stand up to replay most of time.
I agree with Karen, to spend that amount for a one time deal kinda sucks!
I am suprised about Mortal Kombat- I love Mortal Kombat =)
It is bad when expensive games don't have enough in them to make you want to play them again :(