You don't need a weather man to know which way the wind blows
As I've been spending some time on the pavement thinking about the government and the election, the one thing that I keep hearing from numerous sources is how the election is tightening here in the final week.
It's not.
I love to be the one to say that the emperor is wearing no clothes. Look, there is no chance that John McCain wins this election. None, zero, zip, nada. People can say that the polls are tightening but just because they say it, doesn't mean that it's true in any meaningful way.
For the Presidential election on Tuesday, there are a few things worth monitoring but the final outcome is not one of them. The only doubt is the final score. How many of the battleground states will Barack Obama win? Will Obama double up on McCain in the electoral college? By how many points will Obama win the popular vote?
According to the great election site FiveThirtyEight.com, these are the states firmly in each camp as of the Sunday before the election:
John McCain - Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, West Virginia, Wyoming.
Barack Obama - California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Washington D.C., Wisconsin.
Leaning McCain - Indiana, Missouri, North Dakota
Leaning Obama - Florida, North Carolina, Nevada, Ohio
No pollster is 100 percent accurate but if we believe these numbers, then McCain has 160 electoral votes in the bag. Add in the three states that are leaning McCain and he has 25 more to bring his total up to 185. You can even give him the ones that are leaning Obama and that wouldn't do it. Those four states have 67 votes which would give McCain 252.
So, in order for McCain to win, he has to keep every state that is currently in his camp, win every state that is leaning his direction, capture all of the states that have an Obama lean and capture two states that are firmly in the Obama camp. Call me crazy, but I do not see that happening.
Now, I'm sure there are those of you out there who think that Virginia should not be firmly in Obama's camp, but even if you give those 13 votes to McCain, he still has 265 votes in the most rose-colored, optimistic scenario that you could paint. Where are the remaining votes going to come from to push McCain to the Presidency? Pennsylvania? In the numerous polls represented at FiveThirtyEight, none show McCain in the lead in the Keystone State, four have the margin within six points and there are at least 10 that show it a double-digit lead for Obama. That's a blue state.
On the flip side, Obama has 286 votes firmly in his camp. If he captures the four states leaning his way, he has 353 votes. FiveThirtyEight has three states leaning McCain but I think there are two states that are firmly in the McCain camp that are still not certain victories for the Republicans. I believe that Georgia and even Arizona are still somewhat available for Obama.
So, when taking the rose-colored approach for the Obama side, he has a non-zero chance of cracking 400 electoral votes. If he carries all of the states firmly in his camp, the seven swing states, Georgia and Arizona he would wind up with 403 electoral votes. That would be the most by a Democrat since Lyndon Johnson won 486 votes in the 1964 election.
I would be shocked if Obama won that many electoral votes, but I think Bill Clinton's total of 379 from the 1996 election is within reach for the Democrats. Certainly, he should top Jimmy Carter's 297 votes.
Hopefully, you have already participated in early voting if it is allowed in your state. If not, make sure you get to the polls on Tuesday. And sit back and enjoy the election coverage. At least this year we will not have to sit up past midnight to see how Florida and Ohio and others shake out to determine our next President.
Published by Brian Joura
Freelance writer for hire. References available upon request. View profile
Barack Obama Outraises John McCain in JuneDemocratic Candidate for President Barack Obama outraised John McCain in June and has, as of the end of May 2008, even outraised the Republican candidate for President in tradit...- Why We Should Keep the Electoral CollegeWe need to keep the electoral college. Read inside
- (Electoral) College Math An examination of the relative disparities in the distribution of popular vote by the Electoral College system.
- Electoral CollegeThe assignment was to discuss the electoral college, what it is, and whether or not it is necessary. We were also to discuss the impact it has on the President's time in office.
- Understanding the Electoral College, the Primaries and the DelegatesCreated during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, the Electoral College was created as an alternative to allowing one of two groups - the legislature or the people - sole access to the power of choosing which indi...
- Louis McLane: Early Supporter of the Electoral College
- Should We Abolish the Electoral College in Presidential Elections?
- Electoral College: Should it Be Abolished for the 2008 Election?
- How a Third Party Candidacy Could Cause the Electoral College to Revolutionize
- What the Electoral College Means in Modern-Day America
- Electoral College System Good for Less Populated States
- What the Electoral College is and How it Works




8 Comments
Post a CommentWell, I guess I will need something to watch now that baseball season is over and I don't have great cable.
We can only hope that everything is legit at the polls in Florida. We don't want another Gore, Bush fiasco and allow a person to become president illegitimately. Look what that did for us.
Yeah. I'd really be ashamed of something like that. Heaven forbid. Why?
Another informative article Brian, well done...
I will be ashamed of living in NC if Obama takes this state.
Great article! Enjoyed! Thanks for the political info! :-)
Good analysis. I follow www.realclearpolitics.com, and I see the same results there. Be prepared for 4 years of Jimmy Carter, with rationed energy, and, this time, rationed health care. Obama is not another Bill Clinton. This is not going to be pretty.
Your reasoning is on the mark, but I think many folks are distrustful after the Florida debacle a few years back.