A Filmmaker's Reason for Choosing Film Over a Prosumer Video Camera
I could not afford to buy a $4,000 semi-professional video camera. Therefore, I spent a few hundred dollars on a regular Sony Hi-8 Handycam camcorder. It isn't the cream of the crop. However, could hold me over until I was able to either maker enough money to buy a more expensive one or won a better one from a film festival. I have been interested in purchasing the Canon XL1, a $2,000 mini-dv camcorder that produces a really good video image. When the Canon GL1 and XL1 camcorders were released a few years ago, they were very popular among independent producers. In recent years, newer video cameras have been released, including the Canon XL2 and the Sony VX2100.
While I have yet to purchase a new video camera, I have been considering moving up to a more professional camcorder such as the Sony VX2100. However, I still need to be able to afford the $3,000 camera. I have read so many articles and books that tell independent filmmakers to make their movies using whatever they have. This includes consumer grade videos cameras, super 8 film cameras and even still cameras. I have adopted that mindset for some time. Now, I am looking to increase the quality of my movies with the use of better cameras. It has been said that a good independent film will overcome its visual imperfections. That can be true. However, I have wanted my short movies to look like an actual movie rather than the home video of the Nintendo 64 kid on Youtube.
Surprisingly, I have recently come to a crossroads regarding what I will use to shoot my movies. Numerous headaches have come out of trying to decide which video camera to purchase. I have been worrisome of what would happen if I bought the Canon XL2. The camera will become ancient the moment that new cameras are put on the market. These realities make it tough to decide on a camera like the Sony VX2100 or another high quality video camera.
The introduction of new HD camcorders makes this decision even tougher. Therefore, I have been considering shooting on film. New film cameras are expensive to obtain. However, used film cameras that are in good shape are pretty easy to find in numerous places. Shooting an processing16mm film stock may not be cheap either, but I may be better off shooting on film for numerous reasons. The selection of camcorders such as the Panasonic AG-HVX200, the Sony VX2100 and the Canon XL2 make it difficult to choose the best camcorder to purchase. They are all good video cameras and they are all expensive. These video cameras are also part of a medium that constantly progresses in little time.
Before you know it, there will be another camera that is more popular and has a higher quality than the Sony VX2100 that is purchased today. What should be done when that happens? I have no interest in spending thousands of dollars every 3 years or so, just to be able to maintain the highest possible level of video quality. Shooting on 16mm film may be the better choice in the long run. New film stock may be introduced frequently, just like semi-professional video cameras. However, film will always look like film. It will have the same quality for lifetimes to come. Video on the other hand, changes so rapidly that the latest high quality video image will look like a cheap home video over time.
I would like to have good looking images for my independent films. While video cameras can offer a less expensive way to make movies, the difficulty of choosing the right camcorder makes the video medium less attractive. After spending thousands of dollars on a camera, every image that is captured should exhibit high quality above and beyond the average episode of Cops or Court TV. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Therefore, I may have to remove my headaches from deciding on a video camera and replace them with thoughts on the best places to buy film stock.
Published by Nicole A. - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment
She has written and produced several short movies. She currently works as a freelance editor while continuing to make independent films. View profile
- Visiting the Berlin Film Museum The Berlin Film Museum guides you through 100 years of film history, with a focus on that golden era when films made in Berlin came close to challenging those of Hollywood.
- Primer: Perhaps the Smartest Sci-Fi Film of All Time Sundance Film Festival Winning Sci-Fi movie tells the story of two engineers who make an incredible discovery which changes their lives for all time.
- The Battle of Austerlitz 200 Years on The Battle of Austerlitz was the peak of glory and heroism for the great French Grande Armée, as well as the crowning victory among the numerous other military successes Napoleon had celebrated up until then.
- 3 Essentials for Choosing the Right Suit Suits can be a tough item of clothing to get right, especially for big and tall men. Follow these 3 essentials whenever choosing a suit, to ensure you get a right fit for your figure.
-
Choosing a Multi-Vitamin
If you've shopped for vitamins lately you know that there are literally dozens of choices out there. Here are my tips for choosing an appropriate multi-vitamin.
- The Independent Film Scene in Eugene, Oregon
- Suspiria- a Film Between Dreamlike Imagery and Exploitative Shock
- Mirrormask: The Illustrated Film Script - Review
- 1,001 Movies You Must See Before You Die a Must-Read for Film Buffs
- The Must See British Independent Film Sixteen Years of Alcohol
- Camera Buffs: Why Are You Still Using Film? Go Digital With Rechargable Batteries
- A Brief History of the Sundance Film Festival
|
|
- The wide selection of semi-professional video camcorders make it difficult to choose the best one to purchase.
- Shooting on film may be the better choice in the long run.
- New video cameras will become ancient the moment that new cameras are put on the market.
4 Comments
Post a CommentThe cameras don't just become obsolete they also become un working. Old film cameras can still be used even after 50 years.
Arse. I was hoping for someone to give me an answer on the same question. In my case film is out of the question since in my country you have to ship it back and fourth to germany and pay a big lot of money. spending a few thousand for each film is a bit much...
Awesome article. I must of read it 5 times because I feel the same way. I have been waiting to purchase a prosumer video camera for 2 years. It seems like all I do is wait. I finally decided on the Panasonic AG-HVX200 but I am now waiting for the P2 media cost to come down. I loved it when you said "I have no interest in spending thousands of dollars every 3 years or so, just to be able to maintain the highest possible level of video quality."
I have over 50 thousand dollars in S-VHS equipment that is now worth next to nothing and I know as soon as I buy the HVX200 a new model will come out.
It really makes me feel better knowing someone feels the same way I do.
Once again great article
I really appreciate this article. It IS very confusing as to what choice to make. In a field where you are trying to get the best quality equipment you can afford, it's so not fair that every 5 minutes a newer, better version comes out. Aaaargh!