A Murder Charge for a Victim of Vandalism and Battery?

Manda Spring
I wanted to share a point of view derived from a hot news topic in California. If you talk to anyone from this state chances are that it is on their minds a lot, some for the public 'manhunt' and others very much against it. It is because there are such deep feelings involved in this subject that I know there will, undoubtedly, be much debate and perhaps some strong emotions that may surface because of this article. I urge everyone to apply self control when voicing their opinions and respect for those on the opposite side of the board.

The Background

A car full of 'popular' teen girls were driving through neighborhoods and throwing eggs at people, houses and cars for fun. As we all know when eggs stay on items that are painted and dry over night they often do a lot of damage and take the paint off of the objects. So as far as cost, this is a very expensive and damaging act. Not to mention, to be hit with eggs while a car is speeding can be quite painful and often times feel like glass has shattered on your skin. In all, this is not only a very dangerous form of vandalism and battery but completely senseless as well.

These girls had been drinking and driving as they plowed through street after street throwing these eggs at anything and everything they could when they struck a person and their property who had been standing outside. This unknown person got into his car and chased the girls. Now, this unknown person had no clue that these girls were drunk, they were teens, or even the fact that they were female... only that they had assaulted him.

While in pursuit of the teens they had panicked and lost control of the car, due to the fact they had been drinking and now had been caught breaking the law. As a result there were some deaths and injuries to the teen girls. The mystery person turned around and left the scene.

Justice?

The survivor of the crash is treated like a victim of a horrible and senseless crime. The mystery pursuer is now the subject of a manhunt and those involved in this investigation are announcing that the person is to be charged with vehicular manslaughter among an array of charges. No charges have been filed against the survivor of the accident and the media along with the police are turning their backs on the crimes that these girls had committed and their part in this tragedy.

Where do you stand? Should this person be charged with the murder of these drunk drivers? Should the teens be held up as innocents in this matter? Should we be sending the message that their acts were okay and not worthy to be punished? Or, should the mystery person be charged with a lesser crime of not reporting an accident that he played an equal part in? Should these teens be made an example of to the rest of the youth in our society and face justice for their role? What do you think?

Published by Manda Spring

Manda Spring is a published author of books, screenplays, advertisements, and articles (in print magazines and online).  View profile

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jason Guilla11/1/2007

    I think its all about an 'example' for other people who leave the scene. It's not right but unfortunately they have to bring someone down to keep people off their backs.

  • Anne G.11/1/2007

    I know this case... I agree with the writer which is probably why no one will give up any info on the 'suspect'. We have our suspicions and think there are people who know of the person but they refuse to say anything cause no one wants to get them into trouble that they clearly didnt deserve.

  • ALBAN MEHLING11/1/2007

    Interesting. Thank You fer sharin'. ;-}}>

  • Manda Spring10/29/2007

    I agree with that stance myself Carol. I think that treating these girls as innocent parties is a foolish thing and sends the wrong message to other youth that may think this type of thing is 'funny'. It just goes to show how these simple acts are actually very dangerous. As far as the survivor being punished I would say, yes, she learned her lesson and no 'charges' be filed - but, I think that the vandalism and battery should go on her record as a reminder simply for the fact that anyone else would have the same thing on their permanent record and she is no different. I think that this manhunt is a joke and the 'witness' shouldn't pay for the teen's crimes.

  • Carol Bengle Gilbert10/29/2007

    There is no basis for a murder charge, legally or morally. Whether s/he should be charged with leaving the scene of an accident depends on what local law requires. It does not appear that s/he was in an accident but rather witnessed one. Whether the chase aspect changes that is a matter of local law. Morally, he should have checked to see if they needed assistance and called for help when he realized how serious the accident was. I think the girls should be treated as having paid for their misconduct by the circumstances that unfolded. However, they should not be portrayed as innocents, just girls who did a foolish thing and learned the hard way.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.