AG Eric Holder Admits He Hasn't Read Arizona's Immigration Law

Attorney General Joined Others in Criticizing AZ Law Based Only on Hearsay

Kim Linton
In a meeting with the House Judiciary Committee, Attorney General Eric Holder admitted he has not read Arizona's controversial immigration law - which happens to be only 10 pages long. Not only has the attorney general not read the document, he said he came to the conclusion Arizona's immigration law was probably unconstitutional based on what he had seen on television or read in newspapers.

Eric Holder obviously did not advise President Obama on the AZ law

When news of Arizona's illegal immigration crackdown first broke, President Obama, Eric Holder and other members of the administration were quick to condemn the law because they believe it has the potential to lead to racial profiling. Interestingly, at the time these statements were made, the most important legal voice in the White House had not even read Arizona's immigration law.

During the House Judiciary Committee hearing, Rep.Ted Poe (R-TX) asked Attorney General Holder whether he had read Arizona's new law cracking down on illegal immigrants. Holder told the committee, "I have not had a chance to. I've glanced at it."

Arizona's immigration law reinforces existing federal laws

Proponents of the Arizona law argue the measures taken simply enforce what federal law already allows. The AZ law basically gives police the right to question people while carrying out their official duties, including questioning those suspected of being in the United States illegally.

For example, police officers have the right to ask for identification during a routine traffic stop, or when arresting someone for breaking the law. They also have the right to ask for identification if they believe a business or group has hired illegal immigrant laborers or is knowingly transporting them.

Using immigration reform as a political tool

Unfortunately for the Obama administration, their quick unfavorable response to Arizona's cry for help does not look good. Now, we learn that our attorney general all but declared the law unconstitutional before he had even read it. Political expediency? Who knows. What we do know is Arizona and other border states have been asking the federal government to help for a very long time.

The age old political ploy to pit one group of people against another will not work anymore. Whether Democrat or Republican, if politicians from the top down think stirring up a race war to gain votes will get them re-elected, they should think again.

Illegal immigration is too serious an issue to allow emotions, ideology and political maneuvering to dictate the fate of our nation. I urge voters to watch their elected officials carefully as the immigration debate heats up. If it becomes obvious any politician or group is using immigration reform for political reasons or to "expand" their voter base, hold them accountable.

Know the facts before you speak

For the past year we've heard about multiple bills that were not read by members of Congress before they voted on the measure. Whether President Obama, Eric Holder or even a city council member, drawing a conclusion about a piece of legislation you've never read it is no longer acceptable.

Watch the Poe-Holder exchange on YouTube

Sources:
Holder Hasn't Read Arizona Law He Criticized, The Washington Times
What Does Arizona's Immigration Law Do?, CNN Politics

Published by Kim Linton

Kim Linton began her writing career in 2001 as a contributor for Ministrymaker Magazine. Kim's work has since been published on a variety of websites including Woman's Day and Intel, and featured on several...  View profile

  • Attorney General Eric Holder admited he has not read Arizona's immigration law.
  • Holder announced the AZ immigration law was unconstitutional before he read it.
  • Opponents of the Arizona law believe it will lead to racial profiling.
The AZ law gives police the right to question people while carrying out their regular duties, including those suspected of being in the United States illegally.

55 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Sheryl Young6/24/2010

    It appears they don't read much up on the Hill -- not even the Constitution.

  • Patricia Sicilia6/2/2010

    Perfect, just perfect! What a ditz. (Holder, not you.)

  • Kelly Woodcox5/27/2010

    I'm going to promote your articles. They are very well written and easy to understand. I can see why you get so many page views. It helps people understand politics and what is going on. Like I said on one of the comments I left. My mind usually wanders when I read or hear of politics, but you kept my attention. Thanks for taking your time to write these great pieces!

  • David Hudson5/26/2010

    I just finished reading the bill myself, and while I won't claim that I understood every single line (I had to look up quite a few words and phrases in the online dictionaries), I think it was very clear that the bill does NOT allow police to just "walk up to a latino and ask for their papers". Oh, and by the way, the bill was 16 pages, 17 if you count the cover page. Still a HELL of a lot shorter than that monstrosity of a health care bill that was passed. Holder, Obama, Napolatano and company have NO excuses for not reading it themselves. If a high school graduate lime myself can understand most of it, so can they.

  • Wiley Vaughn5/26/2010

    Of course he hasn't read the law. His boss tells him what to think and say!

  • Nita Mukherjee5/24/2010

    Gives me an interesting glimpse of another world!

  • Heather Tooley5/22/2010

    Great job on this, Kim. You do such good work in political coverage!

  • Walton S. Tissot5/22/2010

    says it all in a nutshell

  • Snidely Whiplash5/21/2010

    Lorraine's comment was hilarious. Not sure he actually finished Dick and Jane though . . . .

  • Lisa Riggs5/20/2010

    Thanks for this report Kim. Stellar job as usual!

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.