1. Michael Keaton. He is best known for his comic roles such as that in Multiplicity and Mr. Mom. The closest to a dramatic role most audience members recognize him from is Batman. But Keaton is really an excellent actor. True comedic timing takes some pretty good acting skill, and his dramatic side is evident if you watch Clean and Sober or Pacific Heights. Clean and Sober has one of those roles of a lifetime that is a truly dynamic character played with just the right mix by Keaton. His character in Pacific Heights is a psychopath, and the character Keaton creates is one of the creepiest to ever appear on screen.
2. Leonardo DiCaprio. His problem, like so many others, is that he is too good looking. Many in Hollywood won't take him seriously because of his features. He's had some good roles in some good movies and in one of the biggest, Titanic, but two roles in particular should have garnered him an Oscar. His portrayal of Howard Hughes in The Last Aviator was an amazing performance. This is one of those roles of a lifetime, a character that really requires skill to portray, a character that displays a variety of emotions and times of life. To be fair, he was nominated for an Oscar for Aviator, losing to Jamie Foxx amid tough competition. But he should have already won an Oscar for playing the developmentally disabled Arnie in What's Eating Gilbert Grape, one of his first half dozen or so films.
Johnny Depp should have an Oscar for Gilbert, as well.
3. Viggo Mortensen. Yes, Aragorn. I've mentioned before that I haven't seen anything that I thought Mortensen didn't do well in, but Eastern Promises and The Indian Runner are two standouts. He cuts a chilling figure in Promises and creates a disturbed young man rebelling against everything his brother holds dear in Indian Runner. His amazing performances are stunningly real.
4. Matthew Broderick. Again, here is an actor who has made choices that some might question, and he has also turned in some performances that might be a bit below par. But this list is for those who have turned in stellar performances, and Broderick did that in spades in Glory. The movie is filled with great roles and great acting jobs, and Broderick is one of the standouts. He begins a flawed character who grows and yet remains quite human, filled with mistakes but also determination. You can see these qualities in his eyes, in his jaw, in his pace. This role was made for Matthew Broderick, and he turned in one stellar performance that deserved an Oscar.
Choosing just one performer to give the Best Actor Oscar to can certainly be difficult. And certainly, these men still may receive the award. But they are called "a role of a lifetime" for a reason. It is sad to think that such excellent character creations go unrewarded. We must hope, I suppose, that viewers appreciate their amazing performances, since that is what most of them are really looking for, anyway.
Published by Kristie Sweet
Kristie has worked in higher education for over 20 years as a teacher in various subjects, tutor and tutor trainer, and assessment director. She has also been a business owner and freelance writer. View profile
- 2009 American Music Awards Red Carpet: Amazing Red Hot Red Carpet Event for 2009 AMAsThe 2009 American Music Awards Red Carpet event is red hot for fashion enthusiasts. What will the 2009 AMA nominees wear to tonight's big event? Who will be the best and worst dressed on the red carpet? The
Top Ten Soul Music Performances Available on YouTubeTen YouTube selections of my favorite soul music performers, including James Brown and Aretha Franklin. - 21: Stellar Cast Makes Vegas-Gambling Movie A Winner"21" the movie gets 5 stars with an exceptional cast and solid storyline.
- Christian, Latin Actor Eduardo Verastegui Stars in Movie that Fights Abortion, Pro...Latin actor Eduardo Verastegui is no longer concerned with fame and fortune, but rather reflecting his Christian values through is career. His film, Bella, fights abortion by promoting adoption.
- The 2007 Academy Awards Part 3: Best Actor HopefulsHere are my top 10 candidates for Best Actor for 2006:
- More Tabloid Trouble: Matthew Broderick Caught Cheating?
- Deck the Halls Christmas Movie DVD Starring Danny Devito and Matthew Broderick is...
- The Tale of Despereaux with Matthew Broderick Arrives on DVD and BluRay on April 7
- 80's Movie Review: WarGames Starring Matthew Broderick
- A List of the Five Greatest Performances in Super Bowl History
- American Idol's Greatest Performances
- Broderick and Snow Search for Happiness in an Offbeat Amanda




