Casey James
The Idols picked their own songs for the first segment. During the last half of the program, the numbers were chosen for them by the judges. Unfortunately for Casey, Randy and Kara's pick, "Daughters" by John Mayer, didn't do him justice. He sounded good on the vocals. His performance was sensitive and vulnerable, and that's what they were looking for when they opted for this song. Nonetheless, the song wasn't in the same league as the showcase tunes chosen for Crystal and Lee, so Casey was at a disadvantage. His first song was Eric Hutchinson's "Ok, It's Alright With Me". I think he was right in his element. Casey will end up with a solid career due to his time on American Idol, but I think this may have been his last week as a contestant.
Crystal Bowersox
Crystal started off with Melissa Etheridge's "Come to My Window". I enjoyed her fluctuations in tone from soft and sultry to hard-driving. She did have a slight bit of trouble hitting a couple of the high notes on this one. Ellen chose Paul McCartney's "Maybe I'm Amazed" for her second tune, and it was a great decision. Crystal took risks tonight by leaving her instruments behind and heading right out into the audience. If American Idol viewers thought she was "hiding behind her guitar", she proved them wrong tonight. She was great, as always. Crystal has been consistent all season. She's a star already in my book.
Lee DeWyze
Lee's personal song choice was Lynard Skynard's "Simple Man". It was a solid performance once again, and the judges thought Lee "crushed the competition". I didn't think so. He was very good, but just on a par with the others. His second song, however, was a different story. Once again, the song choice made the difference. This one was Simon's decision, and he picked Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah". This was Lee's best performance to date on American Idol and may have been enough for him to be the one standing under the confetti when it's all said and done.
May 11th Top 4 Idols Perform
May 12th American Idol Results' Show
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.
Published by Karen LoBello - Featured Contributor in Lifestyle
Based in Nevada, Karen taught middle school math and English, computer education and elementary school. She has been involved in various facets of the education field. Additionally, she performed and toured... View profile
- American Idol April 14 Elimination Sends Two HomeThe American Idol April 14 elimination show sent two singers packing.
- The Remaining Eight Guys Perform on American Idol 2010 for a Spot in the Final Tw...The remaining eight guys took to the American Idol stage for performances that started off a little dull but ended with a phenomenal performance by Mike Lynche. Read on to find out which guys I feel will be heading h...
- American Idol 2010 - Predictions and Advice for the Final ThreeAmerican Idol is down to the final three. What does each contestant need to do in order to win. Who has the best chance of winning? Who has the least? And who can get something better than the title of American Idol?
- American Idol: The Final Three Sing 2 Songs; Theirs and the Judge's! Who Won Each...Crystal Bowersox, Lee Dewyze, and Casey James; the final three in this year's American Idol. Who will the final two be? Will Casey go home tomorrow on the results show? My take here...
- American Idol Final Six Add Shimmer to Shania Twain SongsShania Twain lends her heart, her ear, her songs, and impeccable savvy to this week's final six, and they all deliver something special!
- American Idol Top 9 Results (Again) -- Adam Lambert & Brooke White Perform
- Adam Lambert as American Idol 2010 Mentor, but is Lambert a Mentor or a Ratings Draw?
- Lee DeWyze Performs Hallelujah on American Idol May 18 (VIDEO)
- 'American Idol' Top 3 Revealed on American Idol May 12 Results Show
- American Idol 2010 May 18, Top 3 Casey James, Lee DeWyze, Crystal Bowersox Sing Ju...
- Casey James - was it His Final Performance on American Idol Tonight in the Top Th...
- American Idol Final Five: May 4th and 5th 2010




22 Comments
Post a CommentGr8 reporting!
Yep, I agree with everything you said about the songs choices...you are right on the money!
Lee all the way!!!
not really a watcher, but well deserved PL your way!
Lee all the way. Great write-up, as always. :)
So help me, next year I am NOT going to sign up for a class on Tuesday nights!!
We'll see how it goes as things move along. If Lee can keep up the momentum, though, he has a real chance. I think Harry Connick, Jr. taught him a few things ;)
I'm for Crystal.
can't wait to see the end!
Great article. I think it will be Crystal and Lee also. But anything can happen.