If your first experience with American Idol is a 'results show', you'll more than likely be disappointed. The majority of the program is spent on the drama of who will end up with the least amount of viewer votes. The lights are dimmed and a trio of threatening stools awaits the victims. The bottom three contestants are then treated to a little more agony before one of them is deemed safe.
The drama unfolded...
Siobhan Magnus was told very quickly that she was in the American Idol top ten, and rightfully so. Ryan questioned her about her trademark 'screams'. Siobhan's retort was that she felt this week held great importance so she used the screams one more time to be sure she would survive.
Lee Dewyze and Casey James were asked to stand up in a pair. Usually when that happens, one stays and one goes. I would have been surprised if either Lee or Casey ended up in American Idol's bottom three this week. They deserved to move forward.
The next pair of American Idols to receive the news was Tim Urban and Paige Miles. They were both sent to the stools. Tim said he wouldn't do anything differently if he had it to do over. Paige just said that she'd 'had a blast'.
Aaron Kelly, Didi Benami, Michael Lynche and Crystal Bowersox were told one at a time that they were safe. Of course we knew Crystal would be in the top ten. The others deserve to join the tour as well.
Katie Stevens and Andrew Garcia received their verdict in a pair. One was staying and one was in the bottom three. I thought for sure Andrew would be making the trip to the stools, but he survived. He needs to think about his direction on the show or he'll be gone quickly.
Protocol dictates that the departing American Idol sings one last time and the judges decide whether or not they'll use their one 'save' of the season to keep the person on the show. Paige was told upfront that she had no chance. She was fighting back tears, but handled it well. She's had laryngitis and, unfortunately, wasn't in top shape this season. She really gave it her all on the last song...she went out with a bang.
On Tuesday, March 30th, the top ten American Idols will perform R&B and soul with Usher as their mentor...should be interesting.
Idols Sing for a Spot in the Top Ten on Tuesday, March 23rd
For more information visit the American Idol website.
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.
Published by Karen LoBello - Featured Contributor in Lifestyle
Based in Nevada, Karen taught middle school math and English, computer education and elementary school. She has been involved in various facets of the education field. Additionally, she performed and toured... View profile
- Paige Miles Performs "Against All Odds," Increasing Odds of Her Exit on "American...A look at Tuesday, March 23, 2010, "American Idol" program, with criticism.
- Katie Stevens, Katelyn Epperly, and Paige Miles in Danger on American Idol Top 8 G...Katie Stevens, Katelyn Epperly, and Paige Miles underwhelmed the audience and judges last night on American Idol Top 8 Girls.
- American Idol Top 11 Recap Pans Tim Urban and Paige Miles as so Bad They Both Shou...The American Idol Top 11 took to the stage Tuesday evening with results of their work on the assignment of choosing a Billboard Hot 100 #1 single to sing. Interestingly enough most of the Top 11 chose songs that were...
- American Idol 2010 Siobhan Magnus Hit Girls' Bases-Loaded Home Run on Rolling Sto...Top 12 sing. Siobhan Magnus, with bases loaded, hit the ball out of the ballpark big time. Katie Stevens, Paige Miles, & Crystal Bowersox trailed her around the bases. Of the guys, Aaron Kelly was best. Big Mike Lynch...
- Crystal Bowersox Sings Tracy Chapman; Rocks American Idol Top 8 GirlsSomewhere between Katie Stevens and Paige Miles, the boring factor rose on American Idol Tuesday evening to the level where new age soundscapes were looking more exciting. What to do do? Put Crystal Bowersox on the...
- American Idol Season 9 Review
- "American Idol" March 23: Miley Cyrus Mentors, Paige Miles Fails, Crystal Bowerso...
- American Idol Top Ten Guys Night like Watching a Train Wreck
- American Idol Top Ten Ladies Night Shows Some Real Talent
- Who is American Idol Finalist Tim Urban?
- Big Mike Benches Over 500 Pounds, Alex Overcomes Stage Fright, and Jermaine "Rocks...
- Hot Tween-Appeal Tim Urban- Check Out His Abs- He Doesn't Need American Idol


20 Comments
Post a CommentInteresting. Thanks for sharing.
- Kent
Thanks for this info, very well done
thanks for the review!
Well done once again. Thanks for the review.
Good review. I'm looking forward to it starting again in the UK. :)
I thought Paige sounded better last night than Tuesday night...but it was time for her to go! Good recap :)
Great review of the show
Sounds like the drama really did unfold!
Perfect recap. I don't know if you saw it or not, but when Paige was performing Kara held her arms up with palms facing the ceiling as if to say: "If you would have sang this way last week you wouldn't be going home."
The theme song of American Idol should be "New York, New York:" "If I can make it there, I'll make it anywhere ...."