American Idol: Jason Castro Performs Mariah Carey's I Want to Cry

The American Idol Top 7 Are Mentored by Mariah Carey

Meucci Cameron
Tonight the American Idol Top 7 contestants performed songs from the library of Mariah Carey. I was not sure what to expect, as I am not a big fan of Mariah Carey and know very few of her songs. Sometimes that's better, you don't have anything to compare the American Idol contestants to.

Jason Castro closed the show tonight with his original version of "I Want To Cry". It seemed that Jason's carefree easy attitude pulled Ms. Carey in just as it does most females. Castro has a true musicians personality, and please don't take it as a slam when I say he reminds me of every bass player that I have ever met.

Jason wears a goofy sideways grin every where he goes. You just can't help but like him. That does not make him the winner of American Idol, but it sure goes a long way.

Tonight Jason Castro chose to perform without his usual guitar. He arranged a small acoustic group of musicians and tried his best to remain serious throughout the song. Jason did a great job tonight. He gets pitch-y, but that is just Jason. He will grow out of it with confidence. I really liked his arrangement of the song, and the emotion that he had to show while he sang.

The judging went down like this:

Randy Jackson - "I felt like I was at a weird beach luau... I didn't get it."

Paula Abdul - "I am so proud of you... you have gotten into a groove."

Simon Cowell - "I agree with Paula... not the best vocal, but it was good. The guys definitely won the night!"

Simon is right about that. I don't think that the women stand a chance in getting into the Top 3, but Jason is the problem child. I truly hope that his fan base carries him through, as his vocals tend to be inconsistent.

Good luck, and go vote!

Published by Meucci Cameron - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment and Lifestyle

Meucci is a retired dog groomer and avid television watcher. She is a sucker for talent shows and reality TV competitions. Meucci has worked with animals of almost every shape and size. Her experience inc...  View profile

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • OBJ4/19/2008

    Must congratulate you for being one of those rare breeds who write about who you like without making silly and pointless comments about other contestants. At least you show you have self-respect, that's why you respect others too. Keep up the good work!

  • Tiffany B.4/17/2008

    good job on this

  • Waldorf PC4/16/2008

    five stars for the great work

  • Dee4/16/2008

    If you're asking if he has a big enough fan base to carry him through, the answer is YES
    The DreadHeads and Castronauts combined easily outnumber the other fanbases.

  • Christine Cameron4/16/2008

    You are, of course, correct dh! I apologize for the mistaken song name in the title. Sorry to Mariah Carey and Jason Castro, the song is called "I Don't Wanna Cry"

  • robsmom4/16/2008

    jason did a great job

  • dh9354/16/2008

    Jason did great!..loved it!....and btw, he sang 'I Don't Wanna Cry'.....

  • Sue4/16/2008

    Go Jason ! He did great !

  • Carly Kullman4/15/2008

    Great recap of the performance. We shall see what happens.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.