American Idol Top 5: Kris Allen

Evaluation and Battle Plan

Ali Canary
Rating: Bringing up a strong third

Strengths: The David Archuleta factor, musical talent on guitar and knowing how to arrange songs to suit his style

Weaknesses: Weakest vocal ability of the remaining contestants

Objective: Unseat Danny Gokey for second place

Biggest Threat: Allison Iraheta

Battle Plan: Kris has impressed me by improving greatly in his ability over the course of the competition, but he still has the least vocal strength of the remaining contestants. He has overcome this disadvantage so far with his winsomeness and talent for knowing how to arrange songs to suit his style. He hasn't been seriously considered as a frontrunner so far, but Danny Gokey seems to be getting too relaxed, and I think Kris could make a play and find himself in the finale.

To do this, however, he not only has to hope Danny doesn't get a second wind but also that Allison Iraheta doesn't pull a showstopper out of her hat, because although Allison is polling lower, she still has the pipes to beat Kris soundly, if she can figure out the best way to put them to work (see my advice for Allison here). Kris should concentrate on his strength of creating new arrangements to suit his particular folky style, and within those arrangements he should make provisions to avoid power notes at the top of his range, where he is weakest. He already has the likeability factor, which is a strong card, so if he doesn't give too much away in singing errors, he should make a good showing.

Published by Ali Canary

Trying to inform, but not trying to be too formal.  View profile

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Lori Piper5/4/2009

    he is the dark horse....

  • J. Paul Norton4/29/2009

    He's definitely a dark horse. I wouldn't be surprised to see him in the Top 3 though.

  • Charles Odom4/27/2009

    Good critique!

  • Maria Roth4/27/2009

    I love how you gave him that funny crooked mouth! Kris is a cutie, but not one of my favorites.

  • Allene Newberg Bilodeau4/26/2009

    Adorable drawing, Bat! ; )

  • saul relative4/26/2009

    Excellent critique. I don't know if he's the weakest. I personally think Danny Gokey is the weakest singer. But I think you're dead on in all other respects. I think he has the potential to go the distance, but come up short either 3rd or 2nd. Matt has the ability to choose the wrong songs. Allison just doesn't seem that popular. But as more go down, new voters go toward those remaining, so...

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.