American Teen Wins Back Right to Display American Flag... in America

School Officials Fear Not Being Politically Correct

Sheryl Young
On Veterans Day, an American boy at an American school was told to take the American flag off his bicycle because it was offending immigrant students.

Thirteen-year-old Cody Alicea's bike bears the flag regularly, but on Veterans Day he was told it had to come off or he couldn't bring the bike on school property.

Attorneys from Liberty Counsel sent Denair Middle School a letter stating the school was in violation of Alicea's First Amendment rights, via the U.S. Supreme Court decision Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District. The school apologized, and told Alicea he could put the flag back. By then, Veterans Day was over.

This is what we're facing in this country. American citizens being restrained from expressing American freedoms, because of the very people who are coming here to take advantage of what America offers. Public school officials don't take the time to educate themselves about actual First Amendment wording, because they're so afraid of being politically incorrect that they exhibit these knee-jerk reactions.

Not an isolated American flag incident at public schools:

-On Cinco de Mayo, May 5, 2010, five American students at Live Oak High School in California's Bay area weren't allowed to stay in school because their American flag T-shirts were offensive to Mexican-American students (who were wearing green, red and white for the Mexican flag).

The five friends were told to turn their American flag shirts inside out, or go home. They had figured, since the Mexican-American kids were wearing their flag or colors, there was no harm wearing depictions of the American flag. According to a local newspaper, the Morgan Hill Observer, they disobeyed school authorities by refusing to turn the American flag shirts inside out, and were sent home.

-In March of 2006, when the federal immigration bill was being discussed in California, Mexican students at Montebello High near Los Angeles turned the school's American flag upside down, lowered it, and raised the Mexican flag above it. They were not reprimanded.

The majority of politically correct "acceptable" mainstream media (i.e., not Fox News) did not retain this incident on their websites for long. A photo and synopsis can be seen at columnist Michelle Malkin's website. Since Malkin is well-known for a conservative viewpoint, skeptics can confirm this at snopes.com or truthorfiction.com.

Is this evidence that immigrant parents aren't encouraging their children to assimilate into their new country?

Let's see if we've got this straight...immigrants are bringing their families to America, or giving birth to children here in America, in order for their children to have the freedoms and opportunities America offers. Then, they're not going to tell their children to respect the American flag?

At the Morgan Hill Observer article, there's a 5/13/10 comment by someone with the pseudonym "legal immigrant," who worked hard to become a naturalized citizen. "Legal immigrant" states it's outrageous for people who come to America for American freedoms to find the American flag "offensive." He/she describes the honor of taking the U.S. Oath of Allegiance, and says that after one takes it, they should consider themselves -- first and foremost -- an American.

Additional details and perspective about the Veterans Day incident are available at Yahoo!/Associated Content contributor Jay Braun.

Sources:

-Veterans Day bicycle incident: Liberty Counsel Press releases: Nov 12 and Nov 15.

-Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District (393 U.S. 513, 509, 1969), decision as found at Cornell University Law School.

-"Morgan Hill Becomes Center of Flag Controversy," Jessica Fromm, Morgan Hill Observer 5/9/10.

-"Students Kicked Off Campus for Wearing American Flag Tees," George Kiriyama, NBC Bay Area News, 5/6/10.

-2006 immigration case: "The American Flag Comes Second," Michelle Malkin, michellemalkin.com, 3/29/06; and Snopes.com or Truthorfiction.com.

Published by Sheryl Young - Featured Contributor in Politics

Freelance writer since 1997; Featured Political Contributor for Yahoo!; Tampa Tribune Community Columnist/Blogger; Chicken Soup for the Soul; Amy Foundation National Writing Award; happy wife, proud step-mom...  View profile

72 Comments

Post a Comment
  • blue82104/24/2012

    What the American flag stands for:

    Literally, the thirteen stripes on the flag represent the thirteen original colonies. The fifty stars represent the fifty current states.

    Figuratively, the flag stands for freedom and democracy. It represents the unity of America, our common cause, and the hope for a better tomorrow.

    How can this be offensive to others. If it is offensive to others then they should leave America and by force!

  • Lori Gunn3/7/2011

    excellent writing - thanks for sharing ♥

  • NANCY CZERWINSKI3/4/2011

    I meant to type mad! I was so mad I typed it wrong! LOL

  • NANCY CZERWINSKI3/4/2011

    I'm a big believer in the right to have the flag, show flag, carry the flag or whatever it makes me so made when something or someone interferes with our rights. 5*

  • Lori Gunn2/14/2011

    Happy Valentine's Day ♥

  • better body/Pat Anthony2/8/2011

    This still puzzles me. I have also heard of neighborhoods where flags can't be on individual homes. One flag on the community flag pole is all that is allowed.

  • Teresa Mahieu1/18/2011

    Wow, I had no idea our school systems were hiring such ignorant teachers/prinicples. But then I shouldn't be surprised as the politically correct individuals seem to have more say than not in this country. The individuals that sent the kids home should have been sent home without pay.

  • Angela W. La Fon1/15/2011

    This makes me want to scream but you've handled it so well I'll just e-mail this to everyone instead.

  • Valerie David1/8/2011

    Wow. I'm a fairly liberal person, but this PC stuff is out of hand. We live in America. There's no way a kid in America should ever be banned from displaying the American flag. When I was in school, we actually had a flag in each classroom and we stood to do the Pledge of Allegiance every day. I really don't see how this was a bad thing. It's not like I can't have an opinion about our government or celebrate my Lithuanian and Polish heritage and be patriotic at the same time. These things can all be in harmony.

  • Sherrylou571/7/2011

    Good for that young man, the immigrants need to get a life and go back where they came from. This is the United States, That is our flag. People have died and fought for our Country, the immigrants surely did not, nor did I, but my Grandfather did, my father did and my brother did. This is our Country, and our flag, This is not Mexico, and they are sneaking into our Country.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.