Americanization for Immigrants: Bad for Business

G. Keith Evans
Some hubub has recently arisen concerning the necessity of americanization. It seems as though the right-wing extremists are adament that you shouldn't be in the United States if you can't- at the very least- speak fluent English. In their ongoing quest to bring everything on the liberal left, though, they have overlooked the fact that today's tolerance for foreign tongue is being fueled by their very own business interests.

By definition, americanization is assimilation into American culture. It could mean adopting American practices (such as driving on the right side of the road or asking for ice in your drink at a restaraunt), respecting American cultures (such as the right to go to the church of your choosing if and when you please) or speaking the English language (which, though not the official American language, is spoken by the majority of the population). Certainly, early immigrants in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries put forth their best effort at learning the language and made great progress toward doing so, even if there are still pockets of Polish speakers in Chicago and German speakers in Pennsylvania.

Some changes have occurred since those times, though. For starters, winning the Spanish-American war of 1898 and annexing Puerto Rico meant that an entire island of American citizens grew up with Spanish as their native language. Lax immigration policies with Spanish-speaking nations in close proximity, such as Cuba and Mexico, also led to an influx of native Spanish speakers.

Why didn't these speakers of another language switch over to the English language like their predecesors, though? The answer to this question lies not (as in olden days) in the difficulty of the English language or the "can't teach an old dog new tricks" syndrome, but more accurately in the simple fact that they didn't *HAVE* to learn the language.

Early immigrants had only two choices: either learn English and communicate, or do without the goods and services which couldn't be obtained without communication. Because critical physiological needs (like obtaining food) and social needs required interaction with others, the only choice was to learn to communicate. Today's immigrants, however, face an entirely different culture: one driven by corporate governance and the attitude that profit is important above all else.

There is little doubt that profit has become the driving force behind the actions of every business and nearly every citizen in today's United States. With entire generations of American citizens growing up with Spanish as their native language (thanks to the Spanish-American war and other policies mentioned above), an increasingly larger portion of shoppers in American stores prefer to speak a language other than English. Daring not to miss out on the dollars offered up by these foreign speakers, businesses are scrambling to accomodate them. After all, today's culture would frown on missing an opportunity to profit from their spending.

As more and more businesses accomodate the Spanish-speaking customers (it is now possible to order fast food, shop at a grocery store and buy clothes exclusively in Spanish), the need to assimilate into the English-speaking majority fades away. This process erodes the role that speaking a common language plays in the process of Americanization, much to the dismay of those resistant to change.

Many of these conservatives are spending precious time pondering what can be done about the perceived assault on our established culture. In reality, there are only two ways to address this issue: either sacrifice the profit garnered by accomodating Spanish speakers or put up a sign that reads, "Se habla Espanol."

Published by G. Keith Evans

Born in the mountains of East Tennessee, G. Keith Evans now pursues the ideals of Responsible Liberal Journalism from his office outside of Orlando, FL. His book, Appearances: The Art of Class, can be purcha...  View profile

2 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Christina Wright12/5/2007

    I dont think that language is a big issue, but that the arbitrary way these immigrants obtain American rights.(The American Dream) People in the U.S. are concerned because it is not only unfair that citizens have to pay taxes and go through processes like everyone else, but in fact, 8 0f 10 richest people are not Americans. This is thier(illegal immigrants)way of defeating the law.

  • Dewey R Mason II10/25/2007

    While I don't like the idea that the ability of long term immigrants, legal or not, to speak nothing but Spanish and still get by fine is caused by a trend towards profits over patriots, I can't say your wrong. That said, perhaps the assessment that Melissa makes is also far too true.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.