Amish origins began in Europe with the Anabaptists in 1525 (A. Hostetler p. III). Anabaptists' rejection of infant baptism became the symbol of the Anabaptist movement (J. Hostetler p. 26). In the Amish view, baptism is unnecessary for babies because they have no knowledge of good versus evil. Amish do not "take oaths, participate in war, or take part in worldly government (J. Hostetler p. 6)."
Amish can also be labeled as sectarians in that they use "various techniques of isolation for maintaining separateness." In that separateness, they are able to maintain their way of life more easily. Amish speak their own language, which is a form of German, but each group has its own dialect. The language can be difficult to understand, even for someone fluent in German. Communication with those outside the community is not meant to be easy, thus maintaining that ideal separateness. They are safe in their little communities, apart from the evil and influence of the world.
I have heard terms like sect and cult used to describe these nonviolent people. "The Amish are not sectarians in the sense that they demand that others conform to their practices. Nor do they claim to base all actions on holy writ. They are not in conflict with the dominant culture in the same way, or with the same intensity, as a number of sects such as the apocalyptic, manipulative or cultic types (J. Hostetler p. 8)." In simple terms, Amish people tolerate other ways of life.
In effect, you will not have Amish men knocking on your door trying to convert or "witness," to you. "Many sectarian societies, including the Amish, make little or no attempt to communicate their message." Amish believe, " a way of living is more important than communicating it in words (J. Hostetler p. 8)."
Amish can also be known as "a folk society," in that they are simple, isolated and primitive. "Shared practical knowledge is more important that science, custom is valued more than critical knowledge and associations are personal and emotional rather than abstract and categoric (J. Hostetler p. 8)." Religion is infused into all aspects of life. "Planting and harvesting are as sacred in their own ways as singing and praying (J. Hostetler p. 9)." It is redundant and apparent that the Amish feel their way of life is their purpose.
"Out of intense religious experience, societal conflict and intimate agrarian experience, a mentality has developed that prefers the old rather than the new (J. Hostetler p. 10)." Amish can more easily pass on customs, tradition and religion when it stays the same.
For centuries, the Amish have struggled to survive. They have gone through many trying times together, but their faith has pulled them through. Similar to other religious groups, the Amish have suffered persecution for their beliefs.
I am fortunate to have my family genealogy book, thanks to my dear Aunt Betsy (still Amish), which traces our family history back to Jacob Hertzler (1703-1786), preacher for the Northkill Amish Settlement. Jacob Hertzler is my great great great great great great great grandfather. Northkill was the first Amish settlement in the "New World." Jacob Hertzler arrived in Philadelphia, Pa., September 9, 1749 on the ship St. Andrew (A. Hostetler p. III).
Hertzler came to the New World looking for religious freedom, as he was being persecuted in Europe by a state church. Born in Switzerland, Hertzler came to America and began a life that would lead to my conception. "Tradition suggests that Jacob Hertzler was a man of almost limitless energy. He labored many hours regularly as a hard working farmer. Then he walked and rode horseback miles weekly to reach his preaching appointments (A. Hostetler p. III).
Hopefully, I have given a clear description of the values of (Old Order) Amish and their original intent: to seek religious freedom. Finally, Amish refer to non-Amish as "English," don't take offense. I must infer that the term "English," comes from precolonial days when everyone around them really was English, in Europe.
"Amish Society," by John A. Hostetler. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993, 4th edition.
"Joseph I Yoder and Franey Yoder and Their Descendants 1848 - 1994," by Aaron J. Hostetler. Printing by Gordonville, Pa. Print Shop, 1995.
Published by Lizzie Yoder
Central Pennsylvania resident, I live in the Susquehanna Valley. Born into the Nebraska Amish Community in Union County, I still live near my birthplace. Family is very important to me. I am a mom first. I'm... View profile
- Things to Consider When Working with Amish FarmersThis article outlines special characteristics of the Amish community that must be known in order to work with them on conservation issues.
Most Memorable Super Bowl Games in NFL HistorySince Super Bowl XLI is right around the corner, I thought this was the perfect time to point out some of the previous memorable games in it's 40 year history.
The Best Replacement Quarterbacks in NFL HistoryLike Steve Young filling the big shoes of Joe Montana, Matt Cassel has to do the almost impossible and step in for Tom Brady. But it can be done, as several other quarterbacks h...- Thoughts on Religious FreedomWe have those who think their religious freedom is being violated if they are not allowed to force their religion down everyone else's throat.
The Next Best Thing: Religious Freedom in AmericaReligious freedom is usually confused with religious tolerance. In America, we have the idea that we have full religious freedom, but we do not. I will compare Karl Marx, Bruno...
- Amish Population Boom and Expansion to 7 New States
- Facts About Amish Clothing, Transportation, Weddings and Cooking
- Down Amish Country Roads, Northern Indiana
- The Amish Can Make Jokes and Friends Too!
- The Amish and Alcohol Within Their Society
- Roger Williams: Founder of Rhode Island, the Baptist Church, and America's Religio...
- Hutterites: The Origin and Practice of Hutterite Beliefs
- Amish origins began with the Anabaptist movement (1525).
- Amish came to America, seeking religious freedom.
- Communication with those outside the community is not supposed to be easy.

7 Comments
Post a CommentThank You so much for the info. it really gave my report what it needed!
When you say "amish kids," what age do you mean specifically? There are different consequences at different ages.Which sect are they leaving- Old Order or New? A child that leaves by force of their leaving parents has no choice in the matter and is (supposedly) not shunned. A child that has joined the church- between the ages of approximately 16-21 years- and then decides to leave (from an old order group, where I am from) will be shunned, until they decide to reconcile with God and the Church. Do you have an email address? We could chat somewhere- I'd like to help, let me know what I can do.
Lizzie Miller
Hi I'm doing a research project on the amish and I was wondering what happens when amish kids leave the sect for good?
Awesome write-up! My knowledge of the Amish has always been quite basic. Thanks for the information.
Interesting and informative, thanks!
This was very interesting Lizzie. Thanks for sharing. :-)
I can see several parallels between the Amish and Jewish. I wasn't born a Jew but felt the calling and fought my way in. We don't proselytize or recruit, we take pride in our heritage and believe in leading by example. Ultimately we believe that we were chosen to be Jews by G*d and he has the power and authority to choose different paths for different people, one is not better than another but all are equal in the grand scheme of things. As you know we have been prosecuted for refusing to bow before anyone or anything other than our one true G*d, we too only want to be left alone, the Hassidic most of all but all Jews to an extent. We group the world a Jew and non-jew (Goyem) I will be one of your subscribers and look to your other writings.
JS