Well, it seems the Canadian judicial system finally screwed its head on right. Two US Army deserters were denied their application to stay in Canada as refugees. They, and their lawyer, feel that if they are prosecuted, they are also being persecuted. I can see the difference between the two, can you? When someone is prosecuted for robbing the local Mac's Milk and sent away for it, he/she is not persecuted by society hounding him daily upon release, reminding him of his misdeeds.
These cowards, sorry, soldiers, say they ran away to protest an illegal war. Justice Anne Mactavish said that high-level policy makers could argue the war violates international law. Soldiers are not allowed to do the same. Plain logic dictates that soldiers follow policy not make it. I would hate to think what would happen if any soldier could pick and choose which battles he/she wanted to fight. We'd all be speaking Farsi in a hurry.
Jeffry House said his clients are disappointed the court questions whether mere foot soldiers have the right to argue the war in Iraq is illegal, and took issue with the suggestion that it is acceptable to jail soldiers who do not want to participate in an illegal war. "It would mean soldiers that don't want to participate in illegal wars will be either required to do so or jailed, and that makes the idea of illegal war trivial." Sorry, I find it more than acceptable to jail deserters. Unfortunately, we can't shoot them as we once did. No war, legal or otherwise, is trivial. That's why these cowards, sorry, soldiers, should go to jail. Apparently they can't follow orders, as they knew they would have to when they signed up, so jail them for making a comrade stay in a war zone longer than required because they chose not to show up, and then turf them out of the army with a dishonourable discharge.
Mactavish expressed sympathy for both Jeremy Hinzman and Brandon Hughey, but "sympathy alone doesn't provide a foundation for finding that there is an internationally recognized right to object to a particular war, the denial of which results in persecution. The reality is states, including Canada, can and do punish their citizens for acting in accordance with their sincerely held moral, political and religious views when those individuals break laws of general application."
These two idiots and all their cowardly deserter friends deserve nothing less than our scorn for what they have done. It is just too bad that they have obviously found sympathizers here in Canada who gave them jobs so they could stay here. Not only are we recognized for allowing terrorists easy access, but we also add yellow-bellies to the list. These guys are no better than the Christian Peaceniks who cause so much trouble. (More on them at a later date) In the meantime, get these blood clots out of Canada and let them face the music.
Published by Youranter
I'm just a working stiff with opinions who would like to share them. View profile
- After 6 Years in Iraq: How the War in Iraq Really Affects Our FamiliesWhether one supports the war in Iraq or not, all would agree that the price of war is high- but it's important to remember that casualties don't always come in the form of death or physical injury.
Hitler Slept Late: Blunders that Cost Him the WarSimply put, the assertion has been made by some historians that Hitler lost the war for himself as a result of tactical blunders, silly mistakes and sheer negligence.- The Growth of the War Film Genre as Examined Through Apocalypse Now, Platoon and t...This paper is a thorough examination of the War Film genre and how it has changed post World War II. The examination demonstrates that changes in history are directly reflected through the media.
- How Racial Profiling Undermines the War on TerrorA recent Cornell University survey found that almost half of all Americans believe that the U.S. government should restrict the civil liberties of Muslim Americans. This bigoted, racist attitude is quite simply appall...
- The War on Drugs Part 1: Monetary Effects
- How the Baghdad Security Plan is Frightening the Anti-War Crowd
- The War on Halloween
- Code Pink's Anti-War Antics
- Letter from Cindy Sheehan to Organize Anti-War Rally
- Let Military People Make Military Decisions on the War in Iraq - Not the Politicians!
- 2007: Update on The War on Drugs

4 Comments
Post a CommentJeff, any soldier 'brave' enough to refuse a direct order (can you say "Go to Iraq and fight"?) should be brave enough to face the music for his/her actions.
Any soldier brave enough to say they won't be forced to be a part of this macabre mess is to be commended...I don't know the particulars of why these individuals joined, but I would advise anyone younger than 30 to pay very close attention to the plight of those who resist the war, we are just one more debacle (can you say Iran?) away from a draft...
Manda, Thanks for reading. I hope I can keep you entertained.
Youranter
good article.... i am looking forward to seeing more of your work....