It is time to review the practice and see if it can be upgraded to meet today's new qualifications.
Professionals suggest it is a good idea to explain reasoning and logic to the child. They do not say that in need to be done in the heat of the moment.
Lets take a look at a few situations where "because I said so" may be the very best immediate response.
Angry moments happen in every relationship. During those moments when emotions are running high, it is probably not the time to try and reason and teach a child. The immediate anger needs to cool off and emotions need to settle, but still the behavior needs to change right now. This would be a good time to give a direct instruction and speak about the situation later. So give the direct instruction and if the why question arises the correct answer would be "because I said so".
Another time this may be the best option in a situation is when there is a threat of immediate danger involved. A parent may see a situation that is not evident to a child. Sometimes the child may need to move quickly and avoid some kind of confrontation. They should know that since the phrase is not used too often, the response should be quick and immediate.
Sometimes a child just don't want to give up. Lets take a look at a situation at the market. A child requested candy and the parent replied that the dentist said too much sugar was bad for her teeth, so they would not be able to have any candy today. The parent continued to remind the child they had already had some candy that week and marked it on the chart. The child just wouldn't give up and kept coming back with remarks. Finally the parent said in a very firm tone, "We are not going to talk about this any more because I am the parent, and I said so." Much to the relief of everyone in line the debate ended.
Any parenting tool that is over used, loses it's effect. So make sure the parenting bag is full of good tools and know which one to pull out and use. Really, think of it as a big tool box and see how many different tools can be effective. Don't be afraid to try them all and keep the parenting style working for each child and each adult.
Published by trenna hiler
I have spent half my life wandering and the last half I am spending trying to capture where I wandered. I write and read and perform the basics of life! View profile
Parenting Tips for Getting Children and Teens to ListenCountless parents I've met and helped have struggled to get their children or teenagers to listen. They've tried "everything." They've taken privileges away, grounded them, yell...- Is it Appropriate to Use the Word "Gay" as an Insult?A discussion of the use of "gay" as an insult, and what it means about the cultural climate toward GLBT people.
- Things to Do with the Kids on New Year's Eve: Games, Activities, Party Favors, and...Many adults enjoy ringing in the new year with parties, fun, and games. Children are no different. However, at times the children are left out from this because for whatever reason the adults may not think to include...
- How the Token Economy Works with Children who Have DisabilitiesThe token economy is a system that is implemented to motivate students with disabilities to complete tasks in structured settings.
Duct Tape as a Parenting Tool: Four Parental Uses for Duct TapeDuct tape fixes everything, right? So can duct tape fix an unruly child? The answer is yes!
- Parenting Tips for the New School Year
- Attachment Parenting: A Free Pass for Codependent Parents?
- Parenting Thought of the Day for August 6, 2007
- The Ultimate Guide to Instilling Values in Children
- Manipulation is Not a Sound Parenting Tool
- How to Use Time-Outs Effectively with Your Child
- How to Show Your Children You Love Them Even When Your Not with Them




4 Comments
Post a CommentAnd wouldn't it be a shame if we all felt the same?
I agree with Mr. Reinstein, in my experience "the Because I said so" is the recipe of more dysfunction in the family. It creates resentment. Logical and natural consequences works better. But, that is just my opinion. Great take on this subject.
We might disagree. I feel, both personally and professionally, that the ONLY situation that "Because I said so" is an adequate explanation (and then only temporarily) is in an emergent or dangerous situation. Short of that, it is pretty much categorically, I believe, a poor reason to give to a child.
Interesting. Fortunately, I have never had to use "I said so." If my daughter gets argumentative something is given up. My son wouldn't understand "I said so". LOL