Are Chinese Gymnasts Underage?

Records Say They Are; Chinese Deny Allegations

Gary Davis
Day by day, the wheels seem to be falling off the Beijing Olympics. Now, in addition to the admission that the "firecracker steps" through Beijing to the Olympic stadium were pre-recorded and digitally enhanced, and that a nine-year-old girl, Lin Miaoke, didn't really sing at the opening of the Olympic Games, comes word that the female Chinese gymnastics team may be underage.

In an article by Liu Zhen of Reuters, which was reported in the National Post as well as other sources, accusations are being made that the Chinese gymnasts are underage. The International Gymnastics Federation (FIG) rules indicate that athletes must be 16 or turning 16 during the Olympic year.

According to the Reuters story, investigations by the United States media show online registration records that say Yang Yilin was 14. This is on the heels of two teammates, He Kexin and Jiang Yuyuan, being accused of being underage as well.

Bela Karolyi, the U.S. Women's Gymnastics coach, is furious, indicating what China has done is to slap the world in the face.

It really isn't surprising what China has done since their logic is pretty much "the ends justify the means." What is amazing are their responses. Even though state-run China Central Television (CCTV) said Yang Yilin was 14, when queried, China just said the television report was wrong.

However, for true backwards thinking, consider this statement by an unnamed Chinese official, according to Reuters: "(Yang's age) is not an issue at all since the gymnastics team is already staying in the Olympic Village. That indicates all our gymnasts are eligible." That is like saying because you're sitting in a car, you have a drivers' license.

In 1986, the Olympic Committee decided professional athletes could enter the Games in an effort to get the very best athletes from around the world. Prior to 1986, only amateur athletes could vie for medals. It was during this period there were constant accusations with respect to athletes being "pro" and it was particularly difficult because being pro usually meant something different in each country.

I recall that most often it was in the areas of boxing and basketball.

I think it is important to remember that both countries and individuals with a strong competitive drive sometimes do not think.

I was saddened to read that back in 2002 Olga Korbut, the darling of the 1972 Olympics was arrested for shoplifting; her personal life had not gone well, so she made some bad decisions.

What started as a wonderful show of beauty and creativity by China has started to completely deteriorate.

At this point I'm guessing they just want them to be over.

References:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olga_corbit
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/949613/cute_lin_miaoke_didnt_sing_hymn_to.html?cat=14
http://www.inentertainment.co.uk/20080813/womens-chinese-gymnasts-team-underage-is-it-true/
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/When_were_professional_athletes_allowed_to_compete_in_the_olympics
http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=716188

Published by Gary Davis

Retired Insurance CEO. Trained in medicine and medicines. Trained in mental health particularly manic depression as well as most illnesses (from medical underwriting. Business owner, business, marketing,...   View profile

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • greg 8/24/2008

    d m u are stupid, chinese girls mlook much younger than american girls, just shut up, chinese girls are naturally much smaller than american girls, it's only natural they would be smaller for olympics

  • d m 8/21/2008

    the Chinese people are so stup*d for doing what they do, they try to look the best by unfair stuff...y'all suck just live with it that yall suck....

  • Angie Mohr 8/13/2008

    Great analysis as always, Gary!

  • jcorn 8/13/2008

    Listening to Karolyi has been fascinating because there are videos easily available online where Nadia Comanechi notes that he told her to lie about the amount of training she did. However, it is not illegal to train more than one states one trains (as far as I know) and still be in the Olympics. He has had no hesitation in coming out against various systems and is on record stating that he came to the US to escape the expectations in Romania from the system. The whole birth certificate issue is intriguing and I wonder how it will play out.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.