Are the Harry Potter Movies Too Dark for Children?

A Mother's Look at the First Six Films and the Final Book

Kim Keason
The Harry Potter movies start out fairly mild and get progressively darker as the story continues. As a mom and a fan of both the Harry Potter books and movies I was unsure of when to let my kids finally watch the Harry Potter movies for fear that they were too dark. I introduced the movies slowly and both my kids, ages 6 & 7, have finally seen the first six Harry Potter movies. You need to evaluate each movie individually and I have given you a breakdown of the darker parts of each movie. The movies are classic good vs. evil, it just happens in a magical world.

Evaluate if Your Children are Ready for Harry Potter

You need to know your kids. Do your kids realize the difference between movies and reality? Do they know that magic isn't real? If both these answers are both yes then you need to ask yourself a few more questions: Do my kids get easily scared? How much do my kids understand about good vs. evil?

There are some scary scenes in the Harry Potter movies and some of the movies are darker than others. If you have any doubts about whether or not the Harry Potter movies are too dark for your children then watch the movie first before you decide to let your kids watch it. I saw all the movies several times before I let my kids watch them. I have also read the books and know what my kids can handle and what they can't.

Is Harry Potter and The Sorcerer's Stone Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG

This movie is the least dark of the Harry Potter films. I let my kids watch this one first. There are two scary scenes in the movie. The first one is in the dark forest where Harry meets a ghostlike Voldemort feeding on unicorn blood. The second scene is the final battle between Harry and Professor Quirrell/Voldemort.

Is Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG

The second book and movie in the Harry Potter series is slightly darker than the first. The story revolves around a diary that is controlled by Tom Riddle's (aka Voldemort) soul and how it will draw in any person who writes in it. The scary scenes include one in the dark forest with a giant spider named Aragog who gives her "children" permission to eat Harry and Ron.

The other scary scene is in the chamber of secrets where Harry fights a giant basilisk then destroys Tom Riddle's soul by destroying the diary.

Is Harry Potter and The Prisoner of Azkaban Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG

The Harry Potter books and movies revolve around Harry preventing Voldemort from coming back into power which results in fights and both trying to destroy each other. In the Prisoner of Azkaban the story is about Sirius Black who escapes from prison and is presumably coming after Harry Potter to kill him.

This movie includes a werewolf and flying, hooded creatures called dementors. The dementors are scary because their job is to suck the soul out of anyone who defies them. They are an integral part of the story because they are at Hogwarts to prevent Sirius Black for getting in. However, the lesson in the story is far greater than the darker parts: Don't always believe what you are told and that people aren't always what they appear to be.

Is Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG-13

The Goblet of Fire is the darkest of the Harry Potter movies that have been released. There is some killing in this story and many parts that may be too scary for children. There is a scene in the black lake where merpeople attack that is scary. Then Viktor Krum gets possessed in a maze that can come to life and engulf the contestants.

The scariest scene is in the graveyard, and I still will not let my kids see the scene. In the graveyard, Voldemort gets reunited with a body by accepting body parts and blood from others. It is great for adults but is very scary and creepy.

Is Harry Potter and The Order of The Phoenix Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG-13

This is the movie where Harry and his friends at Hogwarts decide to fight back against both the death eaters and the ministry of magic. They secretly form an organization to defend themselves against the dark magic that Voldemort is controlling.

Harry has visions of Voldemort and some of those are a bit scary. The final battle is spectacular but Voldemort does enter Harry's body and they have a battle in his mind which may also be frightening, but this movie is classic good vs. evil and good always wins.

Is Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince Too Dark for Children?
Rated: PG

I will say that the book is darker than the movie on this one. The book explains a lot more about the resurrection stone and horcruxes than the movie does but the movie does still have some scary parts including the death of Professor Dumbledore.

The scariest scene is in the cave where Harry and Dumbledore try to get a horcrux. Dumbledore drinks a potion that makes him tortured, then when they try to leave, a sea of dead people attempts to stop them.

Will Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows be Too Dark for Children?
Not Yet Rated

This remains to be seen. I am currently reading the final book to my two children. The book's final battle is vicious and several characters who Harry Potter fans have come to love die. But overall the story reveals all the secrets and love that wins out over dark magic. I will watch the final two movies before I let my kids watch them but since they understand that the magical world is not real and good always wins I'm sure that they should be able to handle the scarier scenes. For more information on Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows and the release dates of the movies you can click here.

Someone dies in each Harry Potter movie. Sometimes it is a good person and sometimes it is a bad one. There are battle scenes that are spectacular and scary at the same time. If there is any doubt in your mind that your kids won't be able to handle the Harry Potter movies then don't let them see them.

DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION:
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.

Published by Kim Keason - Featured Contributor in Lifestyle

Full time mom, part time nurse, and part time freelance writer.  View profile

20 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Earl Calapatia7/14/2011

    http://www.movie-list.com/posters/big/zoom/harrypotter.jpg
    http://m.popstar.com/News/Twilight/Daily_Dosage/pottertwilight.jpg

  • Truth Seeker11/20/2010

    You say "I have also read the books and know what my kids can handle and what they can't."

    How do we know how something is going to affect us or anyone else? I know of movies that have affected me years later and I didn't even know it. Can they handle it - Maybe! Should they handle it - probably not! These movies are absolutely evil. Call it innocent entertainment. I call it "messing with the mind".

  • T. Babe11/19/2010

    I think you make a few good points, but I was one of those children who really enjoyed "darker" things, and wasn't frightened by them. I think these sorts of things are more of a case-by-case basis, personally. For instance, I know my 8 year old brother and 11 year old sister are, have been, and will be completely fine with these movies. But, I have a few younger cousins around their ages that might not be able to handle it. Either way, a good read, and thought-provoking!

  • sexy11/8/2010

    harry potter is gay anyway

  • Abby Willow11/6/2010

    The newest one is PG-13, so I would say leave the younger kids at home. Some of them are too scary even for me

  • Ray10/3/2010

    This stuff may be scary for a three year old. but a grown adult being scared of this? not really sure there is some mildly creepy scenes in the last movie (Half Blood Prince), but there really wasn't anything that scared me in the slightest in this series and i started watching it when i was five (in 2000-2001) so i'm 15 waiting for the final movie to come out :) well that and assassins creed brotherhood ^_^

    just my own opinion!

  • J P Whickson7/23/2010

    I'm pretty sure the last movie may be too scary for me! give me a note to tell me which friend died in the last book...I found that I have limited patients for reading Potter but like the concept.

  • Lyn Lomasi7/20/2010

    These movies can be frightening to kids not prepared for those scenes. I think you gave excellent advice! My kids have seen all of them and haven't been scared yet. But I do explain to them often the difference between a movie and real life.

  • Theresa Wiza7/16/2010

    My kids love the thrill of a scary movie. I taught them early about the techniques movies employ to frighten viewers. I wrote an article about how it worked – "How to Teach Children to Be Unafraid of Scary Movies." So are the Harry Potter movies too dark? I don't think so. And I think they help a child's imagination flourish.

  • Linda StCyr7/2/2010

    good thoughts on this... I haven't seen the new one and my kids haven't gotten into the last of the Harry Potter movies. They do like LOTR's though.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.