Are We Becoming Too Politically Correct?

Firoze Hirjikaka
Are we going a bit overboard on this political correctness thing? This thought occurred to me after reading two minor items in the newspapers this week.

The first one was about a company in America warning its male employees not to send Valentine day cards to female co-workers at the office. The company was afraid that some of its female employees may regard this as a form of sexual harassment in the workplace; and the company would, consequently, lay itself open to litigation.

The second news item concerned an Easyjet (a low budget airline in Britain) air passenger being offloaded from her flight because she had two small children with her. She accommodated one on her lap, but the booster seat she had brought along would not fit on her airline seat. The 35 year-old mother, Ann Jordan, was relieved when the lady sitting next to her offered to take the other child on her lap for the duration of the flight. That is when her farcical troubles began. The airline crew forced her and her small kids to deplane; not because of safety concerns, but because of child protection fears. The captain of the aircraft gave the rationale that, because the helpful co-passenger was a stranger, it was possible that she - and the airline - could be sued for abusing the infant.

The above two examples seem ludicrous but, apparently, such incidents happen more often than one would be led to believe. Why do they happen? Probably because - in a society where everyone can sue everyone else over almost anything - people and organizations are not willing to take any risks; even if their actions are patently ridiculous.

Getting a Valentine card is sexual harassment? Come on. If a woman does not relish getting one, she can just tear it up. Standing up for individual liberties is fine, but let's not take it to absurd extremes. At this rate, using pick up line up on a member of the opposite sex, in a bar - or just plain flirting - may soon become a felony. Or, just to be on the safe side, a man will get written permission from the parents before asking a woman out on a date. It sounds absurd, but at a time when frivolous litigation seems to be the norm, very few will want to take chances. Old-fashioned chivalry is already dead: now even other delights, like spontaneity, may have to be put in cold storage. And by the way, you can knock your wife around. As long as you don't cause permanent injury, the police, or the lawyers are not going to come calling.

The incident involving the young mother is just as ludicrous. Is it now a crime to be helpful? Have we become so suspicious of our fellow man, that even a simple act of kindness is viewed with suspicion? Where is it all going to end? Where does common sense take a back seat to paranoia?

Maybe modern society - particularly in the West - is being hyper-legalized. There are too many statutes; even for trifles. Almost anything you can think of constitutes grounds for litigation. We are becoming scared of our own shadows. I'm not advocating that we go back to the days of the Wild West, where most arguments were settled with guns, but what's wrong with the aggrieved parties just sitting down and talking - maybe having a chat across the garden fence? Do we need a lawyer for everything? Let us not fall into the trap of becoming so civilized that we end up shooting ourselves in the foot. Let's get real, folks.

Published by Firoze Hirjikaka

I am a retired Civil Engineer, living in Bombay, India. After retirement, I have taken up freelance writing. I have had several articles published in local newspapers and magazines.   View profile

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  • indrid cold 10/2/2009

    The U.S. suffers from cultural autism, and like real autism, the condition has no cure. We don't like each other. Lay the blame on Christian Fundamentalism, and PC on the opposite side of the same coin. I had hoped the Obama victory signaled real change, not merely political but cultural. Nothing has changed, and at this point I think it unlikely anything will. Real community is impossible today. Nearly all communication is virtual. Most people can barely tolerate the idea of conversing face-to-face with a stranger. Dating is no longer part of growing up. Thus a significant number of Americans now young will grow old without having been married or intimately connected with someone on an unmarried basis, longterm. Humans are the only animals with the power to choose, yet respecting how we interact with one another, we Americans seem quite incapable of making choices healthy for us as individuals or our civilization. I have a horrible feeling the majority of us like things as they are. I

  • Laura Brady 3/6/2007

    Pretty soon every individual in society will have to have their own lawsuit insurance because of this rampant PC virus. There is an article on AC that exemplifies this mentality. It's about a Doctor who is suing a young girl. Apparently she was in-line skating on a sidewalk when he yelled out that he was passing on the left. She jerked to the left and he fell off his bike and broke his collarbone. The poor big bully metaphorically and financially beating up on the defenseless young girl. This is what we're breeding with this litigious mindset. Here is the link. http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/168753/what_makes_a_doctor_sue_an_11year_old.html

  • Paula Neal Mooney 2/17/2007

    Yes, I think the answer is a big resounding yes.

  • Candida Bohnne-Eittreim 2/16/2007

    Firoze it IS ludicrous. Many men and women are now afraid to comment on a nice dress or suit, to smile, ask a colleague out to lunch or even phone someone because they may be targetted as somehow being offensive. When did we lose the capacity to just be kind and caring of one another? Is it because we have become such a litiginous world? How sad this is. Very thought provoking article and so timely my friend.

  • Daniel Doyle 2/15/2007

    Repear after me, Firoze, "ACLU"...we have some who actually believe the "congress shall make no law" thing only applies if they like it...it grows up and out from there.

  • Lindsey Russell 2/15/2007

    I agree with you completely.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.