Are We Too Critical of U.S. Government Policies?

We Don't Seem to See the Forest from the Trees when it Comes to Many Government Decisions

Bev Slomka
I may raise a lot of ire by putting my thoughts in print regarding our U.S. Government policies, and the media's reporting of these policies and their effects, especially with respect to the war on terror. I am not saying that I necessarily agree with the war in Iraq. War is terrible, but the world has never ceased to be in conflict since the beginning of time. What I want to discuss is the generally narrow view that many people have about our government's war on terror.

Being in the midst of the attack on the World Trade Center, I realized very quickly that our lives were to change dramatically. Not only did our sense of safety and security drastically alter, and in fact, disappear, but we, as a country, would have to change the we operated as a nation and within the larger world body. I think most of us expected a counter-attack, and weren't surprised when our troops attacked Afghanistan. The next step of going into Iraq was met with much more skepticism, and I understand that. What I do find annoying is that the media continually focuses on the negative, without giving voice to the positive steps taken in the war on terror, and in Iraq itself. We always hear what still needs improvement, the things we may have missed, and the constant civil conflict in Iraq. These are important things to hear, and our expressing these facts is an example of our freedom of speech. However, we are not hearing enough about the successes, both in the U.S. and abroad. Many things are in place to ensure our safety, or at least attempt to ensure our safety. Nothing can be foolproof because we have an open society, but for the most part, our local and federal governments are working hard at this.

President Bush asked for a global response in the war on terror right after 9/11. Very few countries joined us. Yet, thank God, we have uncovered and prevented some very serious threats since that time. In the meantime, while we complain about things here in the U.S., both Britain and France were trying to unravel dozens of threats during the past few weeks. We outwardly complain about our Country's policies, yet we are welcoming to people of all countries. We do not discriminate or prevent Muslims from practicing their traditions or wearing their traditional dress as do some other countries. We permit everyone, of every faith and tradition, to take advantage of the vast opportunities in our Country. Although we are grappling with the immigration issue, we do not have large immigrant groups sparking violent demonstrations as happened in France during this past year. Therefore, we must be doing something right.

This war on terror is unprecendented in our Country. Just a few days after 9/11, it became evident that this war would have to be waged on many different fronts and in many different ways, and that it would take years to accomplish our goal. We are an inpatient people. We want our troops home NOW. It is a natural desire to see the end of war and our troops coming home, but is it practical at this point? Are we really seeing everything that is happening in Iraq, and in other parts of the world where our troops are stationed? I don't think so.

About six months ago, a temporary worker joined my department. When I inquired whether or not he was a student, or was between full-time jobs, I learned that he had finished his tour of duty in the military. He had been in Iraq. When I asked him how it was, he stated that it was not as bad there as what the media reported. Yes, there were roadside bombings and loss of life, which is always a terrible tragedy, and a terrible price to pay. However, at the same time, the mainstream of life in many areas was moving on.

The challenge for our media and our government's political leaders is to give us a truly unbiased and non-partisan view of the real progress on the war on terror, including the war in Iraq. While many things we are doing are classified, I'm sure there is a different view of the situation that we can hear so that we have the best perspective on the situation. Partisan politics destroys our ability to see the forest for the trees. If we're democrat or republican, we usually hear and understand only one side. As a result, we complain heartily about what is or is not being done. We need to have a full picture of events, reasons, and results in order to understand and support the best actions of our government, both now and for our future welfare.

Published by Bev Slomka

Former Vice President /Business Manager in large financial services company. Authored book "Teens and the Job Game: Prepare Today - Win It Tomorrow" in 2007. Currently, a senior healthcare recruiter.  View profile

  • The media and partisan politics do not always help us see the forest for the trees in U.S. Government policies. We need to see the reasons, events and results of our policies in a unbiased, non-partisan view.

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Rob Matson3/5/2009

    Noliesradio did a piece where they interviewed a LOT of soldiers. Those soldiers reported how mere corporals were left in charge in many situations, used civilians as target practice and were, on occasion, ordered to level everything in a village. This was never in the mainstream media. Others reported that they did find the chemical weapons (WMD) but couldn't officially report it because of the Made In America sticker on the side. No, I am not America bashing - I am politician and media bashing. The forest you refer to is the forest of lies we are fed daily, the single tree is the truth. You are spot on when you say that partisan politics and bias media are a huge problem and that is exactly what I am challenging. FYI - I served 6 years myself so I know what I am talking about and I am certainly a patriot. Good article.

  • Vonnie Chestnut1/15/2007

    Good article Bev.

  • CAbruiser1/10/2007

    no amount of reporting on kittens being rescued from a tree, or an Iraqi girl who goes to school is going to reverse the situation. I am sure there are many acts of kindness and progess going on in Iraq, but overwhelming trend is a fast dcline into chaos. if we ignore that and focus on the propaganda items, the American people will be given a false sense of progress and allow the carnage of young brave americans to continue.

  • Bev Slomka1/10/2007

    Thank you for your comment, Paul. I certainly agree that one soldier's observations or comments does not tell the story. I also agree that the civil strife is horrible, and every day I shake my head in disgust when I hear about another roadside bombing, or more troops killed. Then, there is the overriding issue of what we should do next - withdraw the troops, or send more in. However, I believe there are other things happening in Iraq that are not readily reported, because they might not be exciting enough to get our attention. I just feel there could be more balance on the part of our media and our policians.

  • paul angelo1/10/2007

    Also Bev, one troops observations or opinions of what is going on in Iraq doesn't necessarily give you a clear picture of what is happening. Many factors contribute to the perspective of any given soldier including their job, where they are stationed, their rank etc. In any case, I guarantee that for every soldier who says, "oh, it's not so bad in Iraq", who will find 2 or 3 that say the opposite.

  • paul angelo1/10/2007

    Also Bev, one troops observations or opinions of what is going on in Iraq doesn't necessarily give you a clear picture of what is happening. Many factors contribute to the perspective of any given soldier including their job, where they are stationed, their rank etc. In any case, I guarantee that for every soldier who says, "oh, it's not so bad in Iraq", you will find 2 or 3 that say the opposite.

  • paul angelo1/10/2007

    Bev--There is no "partisan" reporting of what is happening in Iraq. There is across the board consensus that it is a horrible situation. Everyday there is massive death in Iraq with no end in sight--what is a bigger story or indicator than that? Do you think that everyone is just making this stuff up everyday? I disagree Bev, this has nothing to do with partisanship.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.