Authentic Italian Food Sayre, Pennsylvania

Here are the best Italian restaurants in our local area of Sayre, Pennsylvania.

Mangialardo's Restaurant
115 S. Thomas Ave. Sayre, Pa 18840 Phone: (570) 888-9944

This family owned and operated Italian restaurant is located in the East side of Sayre in a beautiful old home that was turned into a restaurant years ago. The portions are huge here and the food is great.

Seating is limited so for bigger groups call for reservations to make sure you have ample table space. We planned our parents' anniversary here, there were sixteen of us in the party, and since we had reservations, seating was not a problem in the main dining room.

With limited business hours, this is the perfect place for lunch or dinner, but they do not serve breakfast at all.

Original Italian Grill

718 N Lehigh Avenue Sayre, PA 18840-2200 (570) 888-3100

http://www.originalitaliangrille.com

Authentic Italian food is cooked here and the aromas will greet you at the front door. Reservations are recommended as this is the most popular restaurant in town. From the minute, you walk into the old trains station that has been converted into the best eatery in town you feel relaxed and at home.

There is a bar where you can sit and drink a beer while you catch the latest sporting event on the huge television. You can also order a drink to go with your meal and it is served at your table.

There is plenty of seating in the main dining room, but there is a second dining area for even more patrons. An old railway car has been converted to serve as a third dining room and is attached to the rear of the building.

Reservations are recommended for national holidays, because of the volume of people who gather.

Original Italian Pizza

205 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA‎ - (570) 888-9167‎

This is authentic Italian food and you will not find frozen sauce here. Try the stuffed shells or manicotti they are wonderful. Each dinner comes with a large tossed salad along with fresh from the oven bread. Stuffed shells, lasagna and other Italian favorites will tempt you and it is hard to chose what to order.

The pizza is great and is on hand tossed dough. You will not find frozen pizza shells here. All the dough is freshly tossed, as it is needed. You can get all the toppings you desire and your pie will be cooked to perfection every time.

You can sit in their comfortable dining room or you can get it to go. Telephone your to go order in before hand so it is ready once you get there. Delivery is available with $10 dollar order, be sure to tip your driver when he or she does arrive with your pie.