Baby Name Guide: The Middle Name Dilemma

Carol Wilkins
Ask any parent and they'll probably tell you that naming a child is difficult at best, especially when you have two parents with different tastes trying to come up with the perfect name. Then add the middle name dilemma, and the complications multiply.

If you look at the different decades, say within the last 40 years, you will see an inevitable trend in middle names. Through my research I've discovered a few of the most popular "filler" middle names. I call them "filler" because they are names that sound good with most first names and tend to be very popular in that particular time period. For example, a popular middle name of the 1970's was Lynn. It does flow very nicely with most names and when push came to shove (almost literally for some couples!) it was a great fallback name. Other extremely popular middle names are: Grace, Lee/Leigh, Mae, Nicole, Renee, and the most popular from almost any decade, Marie. For boys, the popular names are not as easily identified as many fathers' first names become the son's middle name. However, here are some of the more common ones: Robert, Lee, James, William and the most popular from any decade, Joseph.

Here are my suggestions for the middle name. First, if you want to honor a parent, grandparent, relative, or friend, use the name as your child's middle name. It is a great way to use family name and will keep family gatherings from becoming too awkward. (Think of Joe, Joey, Joseph, little Joe, et cetera.)

Another idea is to find something unusual. I have always felt that the middle name is a great way for parents to show their interests. Rather than giving a child a laborious first name, save it for the middle. For example, I personally love Gaelic names and wanted to bestow one on my daughter. However, Americans have a much harder time pronouncing Gaelic names due to spelling and phonetic differences. So we gave her a more commonly heard and easy to spell first name and a very unusual Gaelic middle name.

A third suggestion is to find common ground. If you and the baby's other parent cannot come to a decision on a first name, have each parent take their favorite and give the baby those as the first and middle names. I have seen parents write out their favorites and swap lists, picking out the ones from their spouses' lists that they could live with.

Go to your family tree. If anyone in your family has done research, borrow it. You will find names of your ancestors that are unusual, fun, sometimes odd, but it is a great place to look.

Last, seek out help from others. There are many websites and books with hundreds of thousands of names. If that seems overwhelming, try a message board that deals with baby names. There are some baby name enthusiasts, like myself, that would love to help you find just the right middle name.

For More Help:

Feel free to send me a message via AC

http://www.behindthename.com

http://www.onomasticianedition.com

http://www.all-names.com

http://www.howmanyofme.com/

http://www.nymbler.com/nymbler/

Published by Carol Wilkins

I am a speech communications professor who dabbles in writing and research.  View profile

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Kassidy Emmerson11/3/2008

    Excellent topic!

  • mamalav2/18/2008

    I like your suggestions. When we named my son (he was the second child) I really wanted something routed in my Irish past. I did not want the typical Patrick or Sean, though. I was in the doctors office and there was a magazine that had ethic names. So I went to Celtic names, and found Evan. This was perfect since my fathers name was John, and Evan is Welsh for John. However, the middle name was the difficult one. I wanted something that was different and regal and something that he could use if he did not like his first name. We ended up with Hunter.

  • Mags2/14/2008

    I don't have a middle name so whenever they ask now I just put X. At my job they stated that I needed a middle name to log into the computer since then I have used it "X". Great article.

  • R. Elizabeth C. Kitchen2/6/2008

    I have 3 names =) and they all have a different meaning. I am curious though, what is your daughters middle name?

  • Jennine Thompson2/6/2008

    Our oldest daughter has three names besides her last name. It kept everyone happy.

  • AngelaC2/2/2008

    what a great article and great advice!!

  • Lauren Smith Janzen2/2/2008

    I like your take on middle names. Naming is always an interesting topic...

  • Hannah1/31/2008

    My Mom was a smart cookie, all us 4 girls have the same middle name which is Ann, That was a popular middle name in the 40's & 50's. Things are different now, my son chose Xavier for his son's middle name, attached to a good old Irish first name. Go figure!

  • Ryanick Paige1/30/2008

    Great article. My oldest son's middle name is his dads name. I didn't want a Jr so this was the easiest way to incorporate it. My youngest sons middle name was chosen by my oldest. He wanted a sister so bad we figured that he would be more accepting of him if he helped name him. He made a good choice.

  • Carol Wilkins1/30/2008

    Very true, Cathie! I considered dropping my middle name once I married.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.