Our country was founded on the belief that we should be a free people. Those who drafted our Constitution had fought to free this country from what they considered to be a tyrannical rule. While they neither wanted nor created a state of anarchy, we have far more freedoms than do people in most of the rest of those. In fact, the First Amendment to the Constitution specifies freedom of speech. Well, as the old adage goes, actions speak louder than words.
I fear for the trend these days to legislate more and more restrictions on people's lives. I will go along with most of the laws that govern crimes; sure, if someone plots about assassination, arrest them. Likewise, if someone wishes to grow illegal substances in his yard, he is committing a crime. But fining someone because he was showing off four inches of boxer shorts? To me, this is beyond ridiculous. We have real crimes going on every day. There are murders, assaults, rapes, theft, and vandalism, among others. Why should we further overburden our police force by making it a crime to show off a few inches of boxer-shorts?
After all, what harm is it really doing? Sure, first impressions are important, and people may view someone with baggy pants as a hoodlum or worse, but this would only harm the person in the pants, not other people. Likewise, I may not enjoy looking at someone's boxers, but anyone who has been potty-trained looks at underwear every day anyway. Anyone who goes to the beach in summer is almost guaranteed to see people's rear ends clad in far less material, yet they still go in droves. Without any sign that this fashion trend is causing harm to other people, what right have we to ban it?
It is probably true that the people who are encouraging the passing of such laws are parents. It's also likely that they don't want their children influenced by seeing baggy pants, and deciding to follow that trend. However, I think it's irresponsible parenting to ask that a law be passed to ban it. One of a parent's primary jobs is to be a role model, and to encourage the values and morals he or she holds dear, thus instilling them in the children. If you don't wish your children to wear baggy pants, do not buy them. Don't let your children outside wearing them, and most of all, do sit down with your children and discuss why you think they're inappropriate.
I don't think that anyone who is in favor of this law is likely to break it, but if this is passed, it sets up a slippery slope which could open the door to all sorts of future restrictions. What if people next decide that shirts which display a belly button or bra strap are indecent, and seek to ban them? Or short shorts? Mini skirts? Like gateway drugs, once you make one uncontested law of this sort, others can follow much more easily. How long will it be before we reach an Orwellian state if we continue down this path? I, for one, don't want to find out. As much as I hate the sight of baggy pants with underwear prominently displayed peeking out over them, I will support other people's right to wear them. After all, tomorrow, someone might be trying to outlaw my choice of clothing.
Published by Treena P
Treena is a mother of three young children. She is also a sometime student, and enjoys writing in her spare time. View profile
- Making Connections with the Bill of Rights: Lesson Plan for Middle School Social S...This lesson plan can be used in any class that is teaching the Bill of Rights. This lesson helps bring the Bill of Rights into reality for middle school students. With scenarios that could happen to us today, it's a...
- The Bill of RightsOur rights guaranteed in the Bill of Rights are important to know and understand. What this document gives us is a guarantee the government can't violate or meddle with the rights listed in the Bill of Rights.
- Comparing the Constitution and Bill of Rights to Today's SocietyThe ideas and values under which the Constitution and the Bill of Rights were created no longer apply to today's society. Values have changed, especially in regards to women. Did our founding fathers ever think that...
- The Bill of Rights and Individual RightsThis paper takes a look at the Bill of Rights and analyzes it to see just what rights it guarantees in relation to the criminal law system. Also looks at cases and examples that established or reestablished certain ri...
- Interpreting the Freedom of Expression - First AmendmentInterpreting the intents of the First Amendment. Examining whether or not the Freedom of Expression is an inherent human right or a government privilege.
- Has Saggin' Gone Too Far? the Baggy Pants Debate
- The Ban of the Baggy Pants
- Are Baggy Pants Really Indecent Exposure?
- Sagging/Baggy Pants: Is it Really that Serious?
- Underwear: A Brief History 1900 to 2000
- Bill of Rights- U.S. Constitution
- Bill of Rights

3 Comments
Post a CommentI agree too, is this the USA or 1920's Russia. This is supposed to be free country. When someone exposes their underwear clad buns, they still have 90 percent more clothes on that what you see at the beach. What are going to do arrest all plumbers with plumber's crack too?
I'd much rather see saggy pants, than most of the ugly fat asses you see in the USA exposing their disgusting sight of blubber flesh
I agree. While I think people who wear their pants around their knees look ridiculous, that doesn't compare to how ridiculous this kind of law is. In fact, it's kind of scary.
I agree. While I think people who wear their pants around their knees look ridiculous, that doesn't compare to how ridiculous this kind of law is. In fact, it's kind of scary.