Barry Bonds Deserves to Be in the Hall of Fame

D.S. Williamson
The answer to this question of whether or not Barry Bonds deserves to be in the Hall of Fame depends on whether or not you believe that Barry Bonds should be accountable for doing something that, at the time he did it, was not against the rules. First, a look at the numbers:

The numbers are staggering. Before allegations of steroid use began to surface, Barry Bonds had incredible seasons. In 1987, his second year in Major League Baseball, Barry Bonds hit 25 home runs. In his third year, he hit 24 home runs. In his fifth year, 1990, Barry Bonds hit 33 home runs, batted in 114 runs, and had a .304 average. In 1991, Barry Bonds hit 25 home runs with 116 runs batted in.

By his last year with the Pittsburgh Pirates, in 1992, after 7 seasons in the majors, Barry Bonds had amassed 176 home runs, 556 runs batted in, and 984 hits. He won five straight golden glove awards from 1990 through 1994. He has won seven National League MVP awards. Two of those MVP awards he won while with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

Now, let's take a look at the steroid issue. I do not believe that there is any question whether or not Barry Bonds used steroids. Although Barry Bonds has never admitted to knowingly taking steroids, there appears to be enough evidence to assume that Barry Bonds used steroids. However,the main question is when Barry Bonds used steroids for the simple fact that steroid use did not constitute breaking Major League Baseball rules until after 2002. By the end of the 2002 season, Barry Bonds had accumulated 613 home runs.

We are a nation who prides itself on fairness. In this case, fairness assumes that Barry Bonds belongs in the Hall of Fame unless proved that the stats he has accumulated were done by breaking a Major League Baseball rule. Even if Barry Bonds used steroids before the year 2002, and those steroids benefited Barry Bonds, it is not enough for the baseball writers throughout America to keep Barry Bonds out of the Hall of Fame. Before the year 2002, according to Major League Baseball's own rules, using steroids was not breaking the rules.

Therefore, we have to assume that Barry Bonds hit at least 613 home runs while not breaking Major League Baseball rules. This makes Barry Bonds a Hall of Fame player.

(Baseball stats taken from espn.com. Steroid information taken from cbssportsline.com

Published by D.S. Williamson

I live in Los Angeles and bet way too much money on horses. I am working on a novel when I'm not blowing my future retirement at the race track.  View profile

  • Major League Baseball had no steroid policy before 2002.
  • Barry Bonds has never admitted to knowingly using steroids.
  • Barry Bonds owns some of the most impressive stats of any baseball player in history.
Willie Mays, the former San Francisco Giant great, is the godfather to Barry Bonds.

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.