Billy Joel and the Good Eye

One Man's Perceptions Are Truly Right On

Lightwriter
One of my favorite artists of the last 3 decades has been Billy Joel. It's not really hard to say why, either. Billy always has a way of seeing things that always gets my attention.

It started with "Piano Man". Check out the lyrics:
Its nine o'clock on a Saturday, the regular crowd shuffles in,
There's an old man sittin next to me, makin love to his tonic and gin.
He said "son can you play me a memory, I'm not really sure how it goes,
But its sad and its sweet, and I knew it complete,
When I wore a younger man's clothes.

Oh the feeling there! This old guy had a life, or thought he did, but he feels like it's behind him, and its all memories now. He wants to connect to happier days in his life with this song he can barely remember. What a Baby Boomer's flashback! All of us kids, 78 miillion of us, we've gotten to our fifties, and where are we?

Get into the chorus with me:

Sing us a song; you're the Piano Man
Sing us a song tonight,
Well we're all in the mood for a melody,
And you've got us feeling all right!

Billy has a real talent for catching the exact idea of a situation in song. He gave us so much of a perception that really strikes a chord with so many people. He had a way of seeing and expressing things well. He did it so well I have always felt his lyrics as he sang them.

Some people didn't have the life they'd imagined they'd have in their earlier years, and they're wondering how they missed it. Maybe they haven't, they just think so, somehow. Billy Joel catches the sense of restlessness in the human soul better than most rock lyricists around. And he catches the exact spirit with music to match the lyrics.

His song, "everybody has a dream" has a good take on it:

While in these days of quiet desperation,
As I wander through the world in which I live
I search everywhere for some new inspiration
But its more than cold reality can give
If I need a cause for celebration
Or a comfort I can use to ease my mind
I rely on my imagination
And I dream of an imaginary time

Don't we ALL do that? Isn't imagination and creativity a good way to deal with what we endure called life, sometimes? Someplace to get lost in, some street we can walk down and think? Billy does an amazing job of speaking for us all.

But you know, some people don't' see this. They build lives like houses of cards, full of emptiness and vulnerable to the vagaries of life that they don't want to see. Take "Movin Out". It's a song about people that get jobs to do things they feel a need to do. They've got a deep sense of self that's wrapped up around emptiness. He wraps up the song with a line that hits it dead square:
"it seems such a waste of time, if that's what's its all about. If that's movin up, then I'm movin out!"

He can see right through people and situations like they were all glass, and he's willin to call it all for what it is. "Getting Closer" has another similar take:

I went searching for the truth, but in my innocence I found
All the con men and their acrobats, who stomped me in the ground
If I count up their percentages, I know they're getting rich,
But they haven't taken everything, those paybacks are a bitch.

There's always a group of people called the something for nothing crowd. They're after the get rich quick schemes, and they fly for a while, but they never seem to stay up. Billy sees em for what they are. And he always nails the whole idea for what happens in the end.

When it comes to calling some shots well, Billy Joel's got a good eye!

Published by Lightwriter

Developing baby boomer writer with lots of stories to tell of life, its pitfalls, downfalls, and its pleasures. Its about time I talked about all this stuff. I am a 59 year old with lots of experience in...  View profile

  • Piano Man showed an amazingly honest perception of the life some people live. He started a trend.
The lyrics of Billy Joel's music are some of the most perceptive in modern music. We heard it in Janis Ian's "17" the year after "Piano Man".

10 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Louisa3645/11/2008

    I've always loved Billy Joel! We're both from Long Island and more or less the same age lol...:) good piece here Lightwriter!

  • Shanelle Diaz5/9/2008

    I enjoy some of his lyrics as well- good job!

  • Carly Kullman5/8/2008

    I can't say that I have ever really been into Billy Joel. There were a few songs that I did like, but overall, I was never truly impressed. But, I can see why you do enjoy him and why he has been a favorite artist of yours. Excellent job.

  • Tyler Mills5/8/2008

    Billy Joel is a great lyricist and musician. Well done.

  • robsmom5/7/2008

    Very nice I like his songs and lyrics

  • Lightwriter5/6/2008

    I appreciate your comments very much. I always wonder how my stuff comes off. Doesn't everybody?

  • Lightwriter5/6/2008

    Its the honesty of Billy's lyrics that appeals to me, negative tho they are. They point out the pointlessness of some directions in life. I think Janis Ian did an even better job the year after "Piano Man" with "17". Some shams need showing up, sometimes. I appreciate the comments here. This is what I was hoping for. As to matching his lyrics with music that fits, there really are few better at it than Billy. He's heavy with the edgy sax, which denotes his faster work. Thanks.

  • Jack5/6/2008

    A very perceptive and well-written article. Having been a disk jockey for about 25 years (I got out of it about 35 years ago; I grew up and
    radio grew down), I also love well-written lyrics. I also love Lightwriter's work. Rather than feeling that Billy Joel's writing is dark and sad,
    I can literally see and hear his heart...it's like a friend who's been through a lot in life "spilling his guts" to another friend. Kinda like the
    great line from "Lean On Me"; we all need somebody to lean on.

  • Len Pederewsky5/5/2008

    I don't like Billy Joel. He's negative and moody. The quotations here are good examples. I mean, folks, this isn't really retrospection and introspection: It's different, it's mournfulness. And, if you just skip the lyrics, you come to the musical composition; what there is of it. Insipid and uninspiring, it begins to sound too much like the same song sung serially. There is something completely distasteful to me about his work. I have thrown away the only CD I had of his because it was just simply humdrum, stale, and frowzy. Do I repeat myself? Not nearly enough!

    That said, I really like this article and find it the very antithesis of Billy Joel's tawdry work. Lightwriter is always very interesting, with a great deal of energy and introspection. The writings move you along with an energy that reflects the writer's sincerity of feeling. You get something tangible that you can take away and "own" after you read each one, and each is a true gift, both the writer's and the

  • Greg5/5/2008

    Very nice. Billy Joel is one of the best.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.