Book Review - The Earth, My Butt, and Other Big Round Things by Carolyn Mackler

Rachel L.
This book begins with a guy named Froggy going up the main characters shirt. Don't get the wrong idea. I don't usually do that in the first paragraph, but in this book of teenage angst and self discovery, it works.

Virginia Shreves believes she was switched at birth because there is no way she came from her family of skinny over achievers. Her mom is a celebrated adolescent psychologist with a serious obsession with exercise. Her dad is the classic golfing all-American sports fan. She has two picture perfect siblings. Anaïs is beautiful and slender and living in Africa working with the Peach Corps before she goes to medical school.

Her brother Byron is good looking and charismatic and no one has anything bad to say about him. Virginia, on the other hand, is fat. "Not fat, fat. More like chubby fat." She loves to surf the internet, watch T.V., and eat. She has a best friend too but through a cruel twist of fate, Shannon has been whisked across the country so that her dad can do research on onions for his next book.

Virginia lives by the "Fat Girl Code of Conduct." One of the rules insists that she makes out with Froggy (yes, that is his real name), in private but not subject him to being seen with her in public. She avoids the cafeteria at all cost because she doesn't really have any friends to sit with. Spending the lunch hour huddled in a bathroom stall and inhaling Twinkies has become normal for her and she prefers it to facing certain humiliation.

The school cliques are a bit stereotypical but as Virginia finds, not everyone is as perfect as they appear. Even her perfect family has its secrets. Virginia is pretty content to live life the way she always have, letting people walk all over her and blending into the background, until one of her perfect family members falls from grace and turns her world upside down. She has to face the fact that not everything is the way she thought it was and decide whether she has the courage to break out of the mold that has been created for her.

This book does focus on weight loss as Virginia struggles to loose weight to please her mother and fit in at school, but several characters do their part to teach her that body image is not all about what you weight. It is exciting to watch as Virginia grows and becomes her own person, confident and healthy. She learns to develop new friendships and hobbies and overcome her own personal challenges along the way.

In the end, nothing is the way Virginia expected it would be but that's okay because life really is what you make of it. You can't spend your whole life worrying about what other people think of you. It is what you think of yourself that really matters.

The Earth, My Butt, and other Big Round Things was named "Best Book for young Adults" by the American Library Association and is the winner of a Michael L. Printz Honor for Excellence in young Adult Literature.

Published by Rachel L.

Rachel is the mother of three very active little boys and a freelance writer with a B.A. in English. Rachel is the owner of BusyMommy.us, a site geared towards helping moms survive motherhood, one mess at a...  View profile

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jess8/8/2010

    It's a good book and i'm 16...it's not really suggest it to younger kids...but it does show how a teenager does think time to time...i do kinda relate to it bit...but some people have to admit that some kids actully think about that

  • Amber G.5/10/2010

    The book The Earth, My Butt, and other Big, Round Things is a super good book and I recommend it, just not to young kids.

  • Sydny Hough5/4/2009

    love this book.....i wish there was a quiz on it!

  • SAMANTHA MARIE VILLARREAL3/6/2009

    THIS BOOK IS AMAZING I LOVE THIS BOOK

  • BA mom2/25/2009

    Could not believe this book was in my daughters school library. There was excessive sexual content as well as profane language. Not appropriate for young teens. I have taken steps to remove this book and others like it from our school libraries.

  • rawrBang.(:11/22/2008

    Nice boookk(:
    I enjoyed it!~

  • mystique10/21/2008

    OMG this book was in my school library and what it talks about is................. OMG no a school book but i like it it is my fav. book in the world.....

  • Lucy Bleechmore5/18/2007

    The Earth, My Butt and Other Big, Round Things is a book that i can really relate to and the prottagonist in this book particularily reminds me of one of my best friends. I really enjoyed this book and recommend it to anyone who is looking for a funny and exciting read. x0x0x0x

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.