Book Review of Self-Made Man by Norah Vincent

One Woman's Journey into Manhood and Back Again

Ranee Wright
Self-Made Man, written by journalist, Norah Vincent, is an enthralling account of her undercover research into the world of men. The mystery Norah sets out to solve: do men really have it better than women? It's a well-known fact, in America, that most men make more money than women in the same field, with the same experience. Most women are now full-time employee, wife, mom, dishwasher, housekeeper, chef, and taxi. So, why wouldn't most women think men have it better? You may be in for a surprise.

Norah makes it clear that her motivation has nothing to do with any personal transgender tendencies. She chooses to become Ned for eighteen months to provide an insider account of life as a man. To pull it off, she employs the help of a makeup artist, a personal trainer, and a voice coach. Ned spends time with an all-male bowling league, an intense sales team, monks and a men's therapy group. He learns rites of passage, develops unlikely friendships, explores a strip club, and dates women. While trying to meet women, Ned experiences how harsh women and rejection can be. He reveals the determination, control and strength that is expected of men. While Norah shares her gender deception with some of her encounters, she fears discovery with many others.

What Norah uncovers in her riveting journey into a man's world is eye-opening for me and Norah. Extremely insightful, Norah delivers a very spellbinding, humorous, and illuminating journey. I recommend this book for anyone who enjoys stories similar to Black Like Me or wonders what it would be like to be a man. I guarantee you Norah will give you an intimate look of what it's really like to be a man in America.

Can you imagine living one day trying to pass as a man? Norah does it successfully for a year and a half! Self-Made Man was so inspiring to me; I dressed up as a cowboy for Halloween (even applied a realistic mustache) and played the role of a man for most of the day. Not nearly as intense as Norah's endeavor, it was interesting to experience different reactions from people that thought I was a man. I discovered men that were strangers are more abrasive to other men. I can tell you one thing men have in their favor: they age better. I looked 10 years younger as a man. I observed noticeable discomfortable from my male co-workers while the females (even my boss) were completely fine with my transformation. Is this man's animalism, homophobia, or indignation that a woman is invading their 'territory'? Are women not threatened because of some mystical power they possess over most men? I can tell you one thing men have in their favor: they age better. I looked 10 years younger as a man. Norah will uncover many of these mysteries in her book, Self-Made Man.

Published by Ranee Wright

Professional writer; movie and music connoisseur. Featured Movie Contributor on Associated Content. Featured computer and internet contributor on Xomba.  View profile

  • Is it easier to be a man?
  • Gender identity is heavily influenced by society.
  • Uncover insider view of what it's really like in man's land.
I have no transgender issues but found Norah's exploratory journey so enlightening, played cowboy for a day. My experience, obviously, would have been much more intense had I dressed as a man at any other time of year.

16 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Vanessa Stewart11/5/2009

    Sounds intriguing, I'll definitely read this book!

  • Julie Darleen11/2/2009

    Interesting concept: good review

  • Tricia Sabol11/2/2009

    This book sounds like it would be a very interesting read -- thanks for the review!

  • Lee Wright11/1/2009

    nice review

  • Victoria Rowden11/1/2009

    I think I may have to read this book; it sounds absolutely fascinating. I've always thought that a lot of tension between the genders could be eliminated if we were each forced to live life as the other for a few weeks. Thanks for the review!

  • Dave Schrader11/1/2009

    Sounds like an interesting book... :)

  • Betty Malone11/1/2009

    Ranee, clever book review to incorporate your own experience with the concept of the book. As the mother of 3 sons and the wife of one amazing man, I do think we women don't often consider the life our "men" have to live, any more than they consider our's Switching might me a good thing for all of us for a few days!

  • Sandy Rothra10/31/2009

    I want to read this.Thanks.

  • Sabrina Ricci10/31/2009

    great review; it's interesting how much more comfortable women seem to be with these things--I've noticed women are more comfortable around men dresses as women as well

  • Rebecca Caroll10/31/2009

    Great review...I think I would love this book!

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.