Bottled Water Versus Tap Water: Which is Better?

Christine Cadena
In the United States, and across many developed countries, bottled water has long been considered a healthier and safer way to consume water. This, of course, is the thought process of mainstream America. In an effort to promote health, Americans work to consume the required amount of water the body needs with most of this water consumption in the form of bottled water.

But, is bottled water really safer that filtered or tap water from your sink? While most Americans would agree that the argument for consuming bottled water is simply based on taste, there are those who are adamant that bottled water provides a more safe way in which to consume the required amount of water each day. In reality, surveys have shown bottled water, in the United States, is not any healthier than tap or filtered water and, in fact, we simply choose to use bottled water out of convenience.

Beyond convenience and taste, many Americans are surprised to learn the bottled water they so love and cherish is actually pulled from public water supply and, in many cases, there is little regulation over the safety of bottled water when compared to that of tap water. Because bottled water is classified as a food product, the production and distribution of bottled water is overseen by the Food and Drug Administration, unlike tap water.

For those bottled water supplies that do not come from public water sources, there is a market for bottled water that is supplied from wells and springs and, as a general rule, are considered safe as they are not impacted by surface water contamination.

Furthermore, in areas outside of the United States, bottled water is essential especially when health alerts indicate there is regional concern over the safety of water in that country. For this reason, many Americans also choose to carry their own bottled water into other countries when traveling; such as into Mexico.

If you are an American consumer who frequently consumes bottled water, even when bottled water may not truly be necessary, consider switching to tap water in an effort to save costs. Only when your tap water is unpleasant in odor or taste, there is a public alert of contamination or your home is equipped with lead pipes, should you consider bottled water on a regular basis. Also remember that bottle waters do carry expiration dates so, when purchasing and consuming bottled water, only consume those bottled waters that are well before the expiration date and always refrigerate water as water that is left in warmer temperatures is more apt to grow bacteria.

As with any food product, following some simple guidelines will ensure you maintain optimal health. While tap water is strictly controlled by the EPA, many Americans continue to feel bottled water is a better health choice. While this may not necessarily be true, if you choose to continue to purchase bottled water, remember, as a food product, the bottled water will carry its own health and safety concerns.

Published by Christine Cadena

Working on a graduate degree in psychology, Christine has both professional and educational background in health, wellness, insurance, and health finance. Finance expands to all facets of health and insuran...  View profile

  • Bottled water products are controlled by the FDA
  • EPA oversees the safety of public water supply and tap water
  • Nearly one-third of the bottled water we consume comes from public water supplies
Only when your tap water is unpleasant in odor or taste, there is a public alert of contamination or your home is equipped with lead pipes, should you consider bottled water on a regular basis

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Dr Jack12/5/2007

    Tap water is polluted, don't believe this lie. Chlorine in the water is as dumb as iodine in yur salt... whatever happened to think for yur self? QUESTION AUTHORITY?

    Second: To say "bottled water is" anything is ridiculous, because many are so different in source and quality. We have a countertop water purifier by EQUINOX (look on ebay, range $20 to $45 bucks).
    You only know its pure when you purify it yourself.
    Think about that for a moment.

  • snallville10/2/2007

    listen and do not cry. this is not tue and dont waste your time writing lies

  • big moma10/1/2007

    if your reading this your wasting your time and you should play some games and stop being a dorkas

  • butthead10/1/2007

    you are wrong and a liar

  • poopy10/1/2007

    i am glad you can list this info and the csi isnt coming after you for listing this classified information. it is a lot of help for projects and research. bless you!!!!!

    p.s. i am an under cover csi agent and we have located you and are coming to get you...

  • N2510/1/2007

    I like bottled water but i luv tap!!!!

  • Amy Brantley7/5/2007

    I have well water and actually like the taste a lot, but after rain it can have a lot of iron in the water.

  • Laura Brady7/5/2007

    I usually buy a bottle of water for the gym and refill it myself from the tap. It's so expensive! I'd rather spend my money on food and wine, lol. Great advice!

  • Dahloan Hembree7/3/2007

    Hmm, I like bottled water myself. Good info

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.