Carly Smithson Turns in Disappointing American Idol Performance

Tonight on American Idol when it was Carly Smithson's turn, I was excited. She has always been one of my favorites. She picked a Queen song. After a few minutes of her singing, I wanted her to stop. It was probably a really bad song choice. I was shocked. It was supposed to be an inspirational song and she looked and sounded like she was angry. I always liked how she sang in the past so I was pretty disappointed.

She has always been one of my favorites but after this performance, Carly Smithson might be out. I think that she was actually the worst one tonight. Even if she gets kicked off this week, I think she will have a career. It was pretty bad though. All the others decided to bring their game tonight but she went down. I really thought that she would be in the final two but after this American Idol, I don't know. If she does stay, she will really have to bring it on. It's getting close to the end so the others' will be trying really hard.

Carly Smithson is still one of my favorites but I have a few. I don't think she is going to make it to the final two though. I have an idea or two that are very good chances. I usually can pick the winner every year but this year has been really difficult for me. This year American Idol had the most talent. The show is finally getting better.

Do you think that she will be voted off of American Idol this week? If she stays, do you think that she can come back after that performance? Do you think that Carly Smithson deserves to stay in this competition? I am curious as to what you all think. There can only be one winner. I don't think that she will be that one but she will still have a career. We will see what happens on Wednesday.