On the surface, this seems like a pretty good idea. An incentive to buy, stimulate the economy, and even help the environment by getting rid of old clunkers for more fuel-efficient cars. You better get Maaco baby, because the rusty truth is showing up big time.
Let's take a look at this government-induced boondoggle.
There had been a $1 billion budget for rebates for new car sales in the program. It went bankrupt after the first week. In addition to a failed government plan, the flawed economics is simply this, we are subsidizing taxpayers with taxpayer money. That is not going to help our (USA's) net worth.
OK, so what, it's our money, why should the fat cats benefit and not us? The simplicity and emotions behind that is what drove so many folks to the car dealer. I am not saying you should have stayed home. But don't candy-apple coat it folks, you are going down to get a piece of a new welfare program paid for by the taxpayer.
Additionally, there is something fundamentally wrong with destroying vehicles that are still viable while increasing more debt. This will not earn us any A-pluses in economics-101. Whatever, get while the getting is good.
As per the government, "the program requires the scrapping of your eligible trade-in vehicle, and that the dealer disclose to you an estimate of the scrap value of your trade-in."- CARS.gov
The Wall Street Journal summed it up this way, "By this logic, everyone should burn the sofa and dining room set and refurnish the homestead every couple of years."
This program very well may be a shot in the arm, almost like a hit on the ol' turbo boost, it will get you there fast, but in the long run it will cost you more money and make you run out of gas quicker; yeah I know, but the ride was fun.
Secondly, the bankruptcy of this program should sound off like an old-fashioned Mac truck air horn. How on God's green earth, pardon me, let me re-phrase that for my more PC readers; how on this spontaneously combusted green earth can you expect this government to run health care or crap & trade, when they can't even manage to run Cash for Clunkers?
Lastly, certainly not least, in fact the most important aspect of this failed policy is how the government is driving this program head on into Freedom. This Cash for Clunkers program has a dangerous stipulation when you or the car dealer logs onto the government's web site.
That stipulation was publicized by Glenn Beck and here is the video explaining it. I implore you to check it out and afterward reflect on all those complaints about the Patriot Act.
The feds tell us, "Consumers should expect that all information collected through the CARS Program will be kept confidential. Social Security numbers are not required for a CARS transaction." -CARS.gov. BUT, what they are not telling you is this:
"This application provides to the DoT CARS system. When logged on to the CARS system, YOUR COMPUTER is considered a FEDERAL COMPUTER SYSTEM AND IT IS PROPERTY OF THE United States Government, any and all uses of this system and ALL FILES on this system may be INTERCEPTED, MONITORED, RECORDED, COPIED, AUDITED, INSPECTED, and DISCLOSED to authorized CARS, DoT and law enforcement personnel, as well as authorized officials of other agencies, BOTH DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN." (emphasis my own)
The House just approved $2B more for Cash for Clunkers. Oh, I forgot it is the program formerly known as Cash for Clunkers. Yes, the Obamacracy as with many pop icons changed its name; it is now officially dubbed the Car Allowance Rebate System (CARS).
Resources:
WSJ
CARS.gov
www.americanangle.blogspot.com
Published by Tony Jingo
An American Patriot with an independent view on today's topics. Jingo (noun) One who vociferously supports one's country View profile
- Cash for Clunkers Qualifying Cars List: See If Your Car is QualifiedCash For Clunkers has been extended. If you are one of the millions of Americans thinking that getting a new car through the Cash For Clunkers Program 2009 (otherwise officially known as the Car Allowance Rebate Syst...
- Cash for Clunkers Program Extended Through Weekend According to the Washington Post, Congress acted swiftly and appropriated an extra $2 billion toward the Cash For Clunkers Program 2009 Friday, forestalling having the program suspended due to reaching its financial l...
Cash for Clunkers - the U.S. Government's New Car Scrappage SchemeThe Cash for Clunkers program may give you money to get that new car or new truck you have been waiting to buy.- Cash for Clunkers Suspended? Not According to White HouseDue to its overwhelming success, the cash for clunkers program is running out of money, and now legislators are trying to attain more funding for the wildly successful program.
- Cash for Clunkers, What a Great IdeaNews is not my thing, but I have to admit this Cash for Clunkers program did get my attention.
- Fake Cash for Clunkers Websites Stealing Identities
- Jeep Offering Incentives with Cash for Clunkers Program
- Cash for Clunkers Program 2009: Incentive for Some, Not so Much for Others
- Getting Cash for Clunkers
- Cash for Clunkers Suspended; Is it Really About the Funding?
- Cash for Clunkers Program 2009 Suspended? Not Yet, But...
- Ill-Timed Honda Airbag Recall in Midst of Cash for Clunkers Program



40 Comments
Post a CommentVery well written article. I agree destroying perfectly good cars is a really bad idea.
Let's not forget that destroying the vehicles decreases the number of used parts increasing the cost of repairing old cars. So people who do not take advantage of cash for clunkers still end up being pressured to buy a new car.
It also hurts the used car people as business is being diverted from them since they cannot participate in cash for clunkers.
I can't help but wonder which stockholder came up with this idea.
Sparkle and fizzle...it's becoming the American way...Scary.
Great job, Tony!!
The program has flaws and given we are in such a fiscal mess this probably wasn't a good idea, but at least Ford will actually turn a profit for the first time in a long while.
Another miserably failed program! There were so many damn glitches, the program only lasted about five days. I cannot wait to see if these cars dealers ever get paid by the government! Some here in Boston are pretty edgy about that part of this whacked out nonsense.
We looked into the Cash for Clunkers program but found it to be full of problems (for us) and I still find it confusing. I'm not sure how it is going to help the economy in the long term and...even with a rebate...people will be taking on car payments (unless they have the cash to buy a car outright, rebate included). I know plenty of people in both the Democratic and Republican parties who find the program troublesome.
I so agree with Charlotte 100%!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Damn Tony! Not only did you get my reference, but you then go into an in-depth philosophical statement on it. You one smart cat Tony! I knew I liked you for some reason.
Great info in a well written piece.TX