Historian and tour guide Ian Campbell made the politically incorrect snafu during a class trip, when he selected black students to act as slaves during a demonstration on what life was like during the Civil War. Campbell, who is black, selected the black children from the group of black and white kids because he was "trying to be historically correct not politically correct." Indeed, Campbell's interpretation is correct-slaves during that time were predominantly black. Unfortunately, sensitive parents have taken offense to Campbell's accurate portrayal of our nation's history. These parents fear for their children's self-esteem, concerned that a lesson in history will somehow unravel their child's self-respect.
NAACP President Kojo Nantambu agrees.
"There is a lingering pain, a lingering bitterness, a lingering insecurity and a lingering sense of inhumanity since slavery. Because that's still there, you want to be more sensitive than politically correct or historically correct."
What lingering pain? These kids have never experienced slavery, segregation or Jim Crow.
So, instead of presenting history as it happened, we should omit those parts that others find offensive-in other words lie? How can we learn from history, if we're never exposed to the bad stuff? No one takes the time to consider how the discussion of slavery makes white kids feel. While blacks may not want to be reminded of the past, whites may not either. Parts of our nation's past are ugly for all parties involved. That doesn't mean we swipe it under the rug. We take it for what it is: the past. Then we move on.
Kids are not born insecure. Only parents instill that in them. Let's stop pretending that we're worried about offending the children. Unlike their sensitive parents, they can handle the facts.
Source:
Children's Slavery Lesson Upsets Charlotte NAACP Leader, November 6, 2009
Published by Nik Minor
Nik is a freelance writer, editor, law student, and small business owner. View profile
- A Politically Correct Nursery Rhyme #5Another in a series of making old nursery rhymes politically correct.
- Has Politically Correct Stepped on Its Own "Ism?"Have we gone underground in trying to use politically correct nomenclature? Or are we more determined then ever to set things straight?
- Top 10 Most Bizarre and Politically Correct College CoursesThe top 10 most bizarre and politically correct college courses as compiled by the Young America's Foundation.
Politically Correct European Union Bans Words Jihad, Islamic, and Funda...The lexicon of the politically correct? A new secret guidebook for EU government officials requires less emotive words about Islam.- Should Christmas Be Politically Correct?Trying to not offend anyone has turned Christmas into a "politically correct" firestorm. Who's right in this fight for "The Most Wonderful Time of the Year"?
- A Politically Correct Nursery Rhyme #7
- A Politically Correct Nursery Rhyme #4
- The Sad Effects of Being Politically Correct
- Politically Incorrect, Non-politically Correct, and Non-politically Incorrect Fluff
- Politically Correct Vs. Morally Correct
- How to Create Your Own Black History Lesson Plan
- A Politically Correct Nursery Rhyme #2




9 Comments
Post a CommentYou know what - this guy would not be able to win either way. He used black kids to accurately portray our nation's history, and people got mad... If he had used white kids, then some black parents would have complained that's not the way it really happened! Poor guy. And you are right. We can't speak about anything anymore for fear of the PC police. It's killing us.
Excellent, Shanika! We really do live in a Nation of Sissies, don't we? Grow the hell up, you PC wussies!
Bravo!
Thank you for saying this. It's about time we stopped extorting the facts with political correctness.
Good points. I agree. I think slavery was an ugly thing, but pretending it didn't happen is not going to help the kids of either race.
Wow. I wonder how the students themselves felt about it. Or, were the parents just grand-standing? I can't wait until folks get over the racial issue/non-issue. Race is a myth.
5 Stars--needless to say why.
You have so much common sense. Others can learn from you.
Excellent piece. It blows me away how immature most adults are. Sounds like this teacher is one of the few good teachers out there.