1 2

Chris Brown Sentence Too Lenient?

No Jail Time for Chris Brown Leaves Many Wondering Why Not?

Saul Relative
Chris Brown, ex-boyfriend of pop star Rihanna, appeared in a Los Angeles courtroom Friday and pleaded guilty to the felony assault charges lodged against him after he assaulted Rihanna in his rented Lamborghini in the early morning hours of February 8. A last-minute plea deal was entered on Chris Brown's behalf by his lawyer, Mark Geragos, CNN reported.

Judge Patricia M. Schnegg sentenced Chris Brown to 180 days (around 1,400 hours) of community service, which could be served in his home state of Virginia. In addition, Brown was ordered to attend a domestic-abuse class for a year. He was also ordered to stay away from Rihanna for five years (which is the amount of time he is on probation), to remain at least 50 yards from Rihanna at all times, except at functions like awards shows, where he would stay at least 10 yards away. And the R&B artist must check in with a probation officer every three months.

But no jail time.

Rihanna was in the courtroom, ready to testify, but that was not to be. The plea deal obviated the necessity for her testimony.

As soon as the plea deal was entered and became a matter of public record, the question was immediately raised: Was the sentence too lenient? And another: Did he receive star treatment?

Some are saying no. Legal expert Peter T. Haven told MTV.com that Chris Brown may have gotten more than he bargained for. Brown was given the choice of jail time or community labor. Doing the jail time, Haven explained, would have been a simple in-and-out, with Brown most likely getting some of the jail time suspended. Being on the outside, doing the labor over a period of time, gives Brown time to make a mistake. Haven said that if that were to occur, Brown would serve more than the 180 days.

Sandi Gibbons, spokeswoman for the Los Angeles County District Attorney's office, said,
"His sentence is not based on what he's available to do. His sentence is what he's going to do, or he's going to go to state prison for four years."

But there are many who believe that Chris Brown's sentence was too light, that he should have at least received some jail time for what he did to Rihanna, the results of which became apparent to all when a photo of the pop star was "leaked" to the internet. And many of those believe he should have received the jail time in addition to the sentence Judge Schnegg handed down.

One legal analyst on HLN's "Showbiz Tonight" said that the sentence definitely was not light, that Chris Brown would forever be known as a felon, that from this day forward the R&B star would have to fill out applications and answer formal questions in the affirmative if asked if he had a criminal record.

Filling out applications? Questions about his criminal record? Chris Brown is a fairly wealthy individual. It is doubtful he will be filling out applications or answering questions about his status as an upstanding citizen.

All in all, Chris Brown's sentencing was somewhat stiff, but how stiff remains to be seen. Chris Brown will be formally sentenced on August 5. Some legal experts believe that his sentence may be reduced on that date.

As to the sentence, what of seeing a probation officer every three months? Taking a domestic abuse class? Community service that will more than likely be reduced?

The sentence seems to lose its stiffness with each passing word...

What will those who say that his sentence is too lenient say if the sentence is reduced? What about those who say the sentence was fairly harsh?

But more importantly, what does a sentence that allows Chris Brown to completely avoid jail time for a savage criminal assault signal to the general populace?

******

Sources:

CNN.com

MTV.com

"Showbiz Tonight," HLN Television

Published by Saul Relative

WVU graduate, with degrees in History, English, Secondary Education, Computer Programming, and Psychology (and nearly a degree in Political Science). Originally from West Virginia, with stints in Virginia,...   View profile

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  • JUSTME 7/21/2009

    I know what it's like to experience abuse. I know that if you are capable of battering someone once... you are capable of doing it again. I was in an abusive relationship for 14 years. This man memorized a speech and said he was sorry. There was no remorse or regret in his voice. I believe his speech was merely an attempt to gain the support of his fans back. Whatever happened between Rihanna and Chris should not have resulted in battery. Should Chris Brown have jail time... do you really have to think about that answer???

  • ANNE 7/21/2009

    I THINK CHRIS BROWN IS SORRY BUT THEY ALL ARE ONCE THEY KNOW THAT THEY ARE NOT GETTING AWAY WITH IT AND IS UP AGAINST JAIL TIME..IN MOST CASES ON A FIRST OFFENSE HE WOULD NOT GET JAIL TIME AND IF HE DID IT WOULD BE MINIMAL ..THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR WHAT HE DID AND THE SAME IF A RIHANNA WOULD OF DONE THIS TO HIM..CHRIS NEEDS HELP MORE THEN ANYTING ..HE NEEDS TO BREAK THAT CYCLY OF VIOLENCE..WHAT HE WAS EXPOSED TO AS A CHILD CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE ON HOW HE TREATS A WOMAN WHEN HE GETS OLDER...DO I THINK HE IS SORRY ABSOLUTELY ..HE IS SORRY THAT HE GOT CAUGHT AND IT IS AFFECTING HIS ENTIRE LIVELY HOOD...HE NEEDS TO DO HIS SENTENCE AND NEVER REPEAT HIS ACTIONS ...HE NEEDS TO STAY IN TREATMENT FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE OR HE WILL REPEAT THE CYCLE..BEING A ONE TIME VICTIM OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE HE WILL REPEAT THE CYCLE UNLESS HE IS REMINDED ON A DAILY BASIS THAT HE IS AN ABUSER AND HE SHOULD MAKE NO EXUSES FOR HIS ACTIONS ..RIHANNA IS NO DIFFERENT THEN ANY OTHER VICTIM ..SHE NEEDS AS MUCH COUSELI

  • novakg 7/20/2009

    I think he deserves jail time. Let him learn a real lesson. Beating a defenseless woman is the most horrible thing a man can do. It shows him to be nothing but a coward. Now he's making public apologies only because this is tarnishing his reputation and his career. But you made your bed pal, now sleep in it.

  • Scruffy Puffy 6/24/2009

    Brown is nothing but PIG VOMIT and he'll be taught a lesson realllll soon!

  • Charlene Collins 6/23/2009

    I think he should be treated like any other criminal that batters a woman nearly to death. If it were someone not in the limelight, they would be paying a stiff penalty.

  • Greenhill 6/23/2009

    to answer your question - yes

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.