Circle Me Bert...right Into the Hall of Fame

Why Bert Byleven Should Be in the Hall of Fame

Ryan Lester
How long does Bert Blyleven have to wait until the Hall comes knocking on his door. He has 287 wins...287 wins. He pitched 22 seasons. Do the math and you see that if he won about .5 more wins per game in his career he would have the magical 300 wins and I wouldn't be typing this post. The fact that he pitched on some pretty bad teams should factor into the equation. I understand he never won the Cy Young awards, but neither did a lot of pitchers...including Nolan Ryan.

I'm not saying he's on the same level as Nolan Ryan, but they do have some similarities. They both pitched on some pretty bad teams and shared success despite that circumstance. The fact is Bert is the 5th all-time leading strikeout pitcher in the history of MLB. He was third when he retired, but has since been passed by The Rocket and The Big Unit. He is 9th on the all-time shutout list with 60. Most pitchers in today's generation won't have 60 complete games, yet alone shutouts. He won a World Series in 1987 so he's won the big one. Critics will say that he hung around to accumulate the stats, but he had some impressive single-season accomplishments as well.

He was twice named as an All-star. He finished 13th in 1989 in MVP voting. Not bad for a pitcher in the beginning of the Steroid Era. He finished third in Cy Young voting twice and fourth once so at least he was invited to that party. Ten times he was in the top ten in ERA. Six times for wins. Eleven times (including first in 1977) he was in the top ten in WHIP. Fifteen times (including first in 1985) he was in the top ten in strikeouts. Eleven times for innings pitched. Twelve times he was in the top ten in complete games (including a league high 24 in 1985). Ten times he led the league in shutouts (tops in '73, '85 and '89). I realize he lost a lot of games and gave up a ton of homers, but I think the numbers speak for themselves. After all, how many of todays coddled pitchers are going to even approach the 300 win total? Obviously, Clemens, Maddux, and Glavine are already there. Glavine could be the last one in a long time to reach that plateau. I'm not comparing him to Randy Johnson in dominance, but he only has 284 wins. David Wells...239 (which is more that I would have expected), Mussina...250, Kevin Brown...211, Pedro...209. There are thirty nine pitchers in the HOF with less wins than Bert (take a look for yourself - http://www.baseball-almanac.com/hof/hofstpi.shtml).

Currently Bert is a good broadcaster for the Twins. Fans bring "Circle Me Bert" signs to the game in hopes that he'll circle them on TV. He has almost a cult following. Given his past success and his continued involvement in baseball, I believe it's time to let him in. So let's go Hall of Famer voters. Circle Bert...right into the Hall of Fame.

Published by Ryan Lester

Just a guy who likes sports. Married with two wonderful sons. Love football, baseball, basketball, and fishing. Check out my site at LestersLegends.com  View profile

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  • jack Lee7/9/2011

    Oakley Sunglasses Outlet

  • Matt McLachlan - Coach Mac1/6/2010

    Agree on every part. Don't forget he won his first World Series with the Pirates of 1979.

    For those who say he stayed just to pad his stats consider this...Don Sutton has about 250 less strike outs and played a year longer than Bert!!!

    Just saw some of the ESPN Votes for 2010 class and some of the people they voted for (at Berts exclusion) are ridiculous...Edgar Martinez and Dave Parker...are you kidding me!!!

  • Ryan Lester8/21/2008

    Agree. You can be on bad teams and pitch well. ERA and WHIP are far more important.

  • JON HOPWOOD8/21/2008

    I mean BILL JAMES.

  • JON HOPWOOD8/21/2008

    You're absolutely right. Dick James says a pitcher's won-loss record is not the best measure of a pitcher's quality. He thinks strikeout to walk ratio is a better bellwether.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.