Cloth Diaper Covers: Bummis Super Whisper Wrap VS. Proraps Classic

I have been using cloth diapers for my daughter for 6 months, and recently purchased two different diaper covers: the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap and the Proraps Classic. My daughter is a petite 10-month-old weighing about 19 pounds, so I purchased the medium size of both covers. I found that both diaper covers worked well, with some slight disadvantages and benefits to each. Both diaper covers were used with both prefolds and contour diapers, during the day and overnight.

Product specifications

The Bummis Super Whisper Wrap is made of polyurethane laminate (PUL), a soft, breathable waterproof fabric. It features fully-enclosed elastic at the legs and waist. This diaper cover fastens with crossover Velcro tabs and for maximum adjustability. The Super Whisper Wrap also features "laundry-safe tabs" to secure the Velcro while in the wash. The Bummis Super Whisper Wrap retails for around $9.50.

The Proraps Classic is also made of PUL, but it is laminated on the inside, creating a shiny and less breathable surface. It has fully-enclosed elastic at legs and waist, and features a "double-barrier gusset" for added leak protection and comfort. The Proraps Classic retails for around $6.50.

Care

Both the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap and the Proraps Classic are washing-machine safe and can be laundered at any temperature. The Velcro tabs on the Proraps Classic have a tendency to snag on other items in the wash unless the cover is completely fastened. The laundry-safe tabs on the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap are more convenient - simply fasten the hook tabs to the small loop patches inside the cover, and toss into the wash.

The Bummis Super Whisper Wrap boasts that it is safe to tumble dry at any temperature, and I have found this to be true. I wash and dry my diapers on high heat, and have had no problems with the Super Whisper Wrap in the laundry. Because of the laminated inside of the Proraps Classic, however, I have been hesitant to toss it into the dryer for fear that the laminate may melt. But the Proraps Classic covers air-dry quickly, and drying in the sun is even faster.

Fit and comfort

The Bummis Super Whisper Wrap is cut more generously than the Proraps Classic, and will be better suited for chunkier babies. The crossover tabs on the Super Whisper Wrap make this cover more adjustable than the Proraps Classic, extending the size range of the cover. The double gussets of the Proraps Classic create a more snug fit at the legs than the Super Whisper Wrap, which will be more suitable for baby of slim or average build. The enclosed elastic of both diaper covers prevent chafing, redness, and pinching of the skin, and my daughter is able to move freely and comfortably in both covers.

Leak protection

Since using the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap, I have had only one leak issue due to the large size of the leg openings. Adjusting the cover more tightly at the waist eliminated this problem. I have had two leaks with the Proraps Classic - the first time, my daughter had over-soaked her diaper, and the wetness had nowhere to go but out. This would have been prevented by using a more absorbent diaper. The second time, the elastic at the leg opening had rolled inward, allowing the outer fabric to wick wetness to the outside of the diaper cover. This leak would have been prevented by ensuring that the elastic was rolled out properly. I have used both the Proraps Classic and the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap overnight, with no leak problems.

Bottom line

Both the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap and the Proraps Classic are excellent diaper covers, and I will gladly purchase more in larger sizes for the future. For slimmer babies, I would recommend the Proraps Classic, but for heftier babies, the Super Whisper Wrap would be a better choice. Both diaper covers are of terrific quality, and I would recommend them to anyone needing a high-quality, inexpensive diaper cover.