Further contact between the two resulted in Griggs asking, "Well, it was on the internet. Didn't you want it published?" and then later adding, "Honestly, Monica, the web is considered 'public domain' and you should be happy we just didn't 'lift' your whole article and put someone else's name on it!" Judith Griggs goes on to claim that rather than make a donation in lieu of payment, she should have been paid for editing the article.
When Monica Gaudio wrote a Tale Of Two Tarts and posted it online in 2005, she clearly identified at the bottom of the page that her work was copyrighted. The article is clearly written with the Renaissance period in mind, including some old time spellings from old cookbooks.
Although this is certainly the case that got Judith Griggs of Cooks Source Magazine caught, it appears that her entire magazine has been filled with articles lifted off of the internet. It is also alleged she has lifted articles from NPR, Food Network, Martha Stewart and Weight Watchers to name a few of the big ones.
What should everyone learn from this? Just because it's on the internet doesn't make it free. We writers are trying to make a living too, and for many freelance writers this is our only job. Make a habit of stealing our work, and we will make sure everyone else on the internet knows that you are a thief. If you see an article you'd like to use, contact the author to ask for reprint rights. Writers want you to use our work, but we want to eat too.
Most online freelance writers deal with accidental (or otherwise) copyright issues at some point. The initial contact is to inform the infringing person or site that this is not acceptable. In most cases, the person doesn't realize what they have done is wrong. Feel free to link to my work, even include the first hundred words if you'd like, and make sure my byline is attached. If you want a full article, contact me, and I'd be glad to discuss rates.
For more information on the Judith Griggs and Cooks Source scandal, look in the resources section of the sidebar and the sources below.
Sources:
NPR- The Day The Internet Threw a Righteous Hissyfit http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=131091599&sc=fb&cc=fp
The Washington Post- Cooks Source Masters New Recipe-How to annoy the internet http://voices.washingtonpost.com/fasterforward/2010/11/cooks_source_masters_new_recip.html
Published by Katie Sharp-Dierks
Katie Sharp-Dierks has been writing ever since she could pick up a pen. A mother of two, she is devoted to both teaching and learning. Katie has a wide variety of interests which include all parenting issues... View profile
- 5 Tips for Freelance Writers to Get Approved for a LoanTips for freelance writers on how to overcome the challenges of getting approved for a loan
- Shvoong.com Is a Great Web Site and Resource for Readers and Freelance WritersShvoong.com provides summaries and abstracts of books, magazines, movies, web sites and newspapers, among other things. By providing this material, freelance writers can earn a little extra money.
- Trade Magazines: A Lucrative Niche for Freelance WritersTrade magazines offer many opportunities for freelance writers. Contrary to popular belief, you do not need to be an expert to write articles for the trades.
- Cooks Source and Judith Griggs Steals Online Article
- Cooks Source and Judith Griggs Saga Rattles Online Writing Community
- Copyright Law 101
- Five Pop Culture Super Heroes in the Public Domain
- How Can I Use Public Domain Works for My Business?
- Warning - Are You Breaking Copyright Law?
- Where to Find Freelance Writers





10 Comments
Post a CommentGriggs apparently isn't too smart. Thanks for exposing this.
Just went to the mag's FB page...they sure got online writers' attention! Amazing. Hope this sends a message to all of the crooks out there. :)
I wonder if someone made a video version of this story. ;)
This was an amazing thing to watch. Good reporting.
I was always led to believe that a recipe can only be copied and reprinted if you change it in some way from the original. But taking a whole article? That's stealing plain and simple!
Can anyone say 'class action lawsuit'?
Good reporting!
Wow! That is very scary and very crooked of Griggs. Important article and topic!
This is such a crazy story. Their "reasoning" for violating copyright (even if they DID improve on the original work) is ridiculous, and I hope something severe enough happens here to make people stop stealing writers' work.
I hope the owners are sued bankrupt. They knew exactly what they were doing and even if they really didn't, ignorance does not protect them from the consequences.