It's expected that the socially conscious (and government funded) PBS is going to be biased to the left. However, they go too far with the story of Chris and Cody. The film features a menagerie of toothless, lazy, backwoods country folk, feeding into every stereotype the world has for rural life. Sadly, the two boys in this film are depicted as the newest generation of this vicious poverty cycle. Although the film tries to end on a positive note, with the boys graduating high school, it is obvious that they will not go any farther than their parents before them.
Central to the story, other than the two boys themselves, is the government assistance everyone is living on. If anything, this film is an example of a welfare system gone very wrong. Chris' father, a sickly alcoholic, is slowly drinking himself to death. His family talks about it casually and his father receives a monthly Social Security check for his "disease" (the alcoholism!). How is being paid to drink an incentive to find help, get a job, and stop living on welfare? It isn't, of course. Never is there mention of a possible intervention for this man or any kind of government-implemented rehabilitation program. The monthly check might as well be a bullet in his head. (It is disclosed on the PBS site that Chris' father did die the following summer.)
Other characters in the film are living off of workman's compensation and spend the day smoking and drinking on their couch. They don't seem to be injured in any way and when it suits them, they get around fine. Chris, one of the lead young boys in the film, is also receiving a monthly check for what was vaguely described as a "behavioral problem". His mother, another chain-smoking couch potato, exploits her son for this monthly check and gives him the responsibility of paying bills at sixteen. As soon as he stops receiving the checks, the mother no longer encourages him to stay in school, as it no longer has any bearing on the monthly handout.
And that's what it is, isn't it? A handout. It is very clear in this film that no one is held accountable for their actions. When Chris' job becomes too strenuous, he quits. When school expects him to show up on time, he drops out. However, both places take him back after he begs and makes excuses. That isn't making a self-sufficient man out of him. I watched this film and found it to be a great example of the self-defeating "victim" mentality that many people in this country suffer from. If anything, it is a documentary that screams, "Welfare reform!" Obviously, PBS didn't see it that way at all.
On the Country Boys Official website, PBS features a column by author Cynthia Duncan, a supposed "expert" on rural poverty. She proceeds to explain that the poverty these boys are growing up in is due to the lack of investment and interest by the social elite. I'm sorry, what? A community of lazy people skimming money off the government exists because of the heartless bastards on Wall Street? No, she is probably referring to the evil conservatives in the White House. Bush is blamed for everything these days, isn't he? But there's a flaw in that argument because Bush is the one signing the checks!
Don't get me wrong, I really liked this documentary. It was gripping and addictive and David Sutherland was extremely objective in his documenting. However, PBS is heralding it for all the wrong reasons. I don't know if there was any agenda on Sutherland's part other than to show a human story, but the station that distributed it is distorting what I found to be an example of everything wrong with society. Instead of finger pointing at these phantom "social elite" ruining everyone's lives, why won't we stand up and start taking responsibility for ourselves? After all of their strife, these "country boys" still haven't learned this lesson.
Published by Dinah Laurel
Dinah Laurel is a freelance writer who specializes in online content development. View profile
- Sound in Film and Cinemathe different types of sound usage in film and t.v. and how is makes feature films better to the viewer
- Seabiscuit: A Fantastic Film for Any Type of Movie ViewerSeabiscuit is a fantastic film for any type of movie viewer
Making Movies for the 48 Hour Film FestivalThe 48 Hour Film Festival has grown from a competition between five guys in Los Angeles into an international sensation.- Movie Documentary Loose Change = Loose Screws? What Really Happened on 9/11?Is this documentary really investigative journalism? Is it even a good film? Here's a review.
- Documentary Review: Alex Gibney's Enron: The Smartest Guys in the RoomAfter watching Alex Gibney's new documentary Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, one feels the distinct urge to shower. But the grime of white-collar greed, shocking government complicity, and the inherent flaws in...
- Dangerous Man by Trace Adkins Country Music CD Review
- Country Music Sexiest Man in 2007
- Country Music for College Graduates
- Country Women Vs. City Girls: Who Would Be the Last One Standing?
- A Brief History of the Sundance Film Festival
- Visiting the Berlin Film Museum
- Camera Buffs: Why Are You Still Using Film? Go Digital With Rechargable Batteries
- PBS Online- www.pbs.org
- Country Boys, a three-part documentary by David Sutherland, is the newest special airing on PBS.
- The film features a menagerie of country folk, feeding into every stereotype of rural life.
- Sadly, the two boys in this film are depicted as the newest generation of this poverty cycle.




5 Comments
Post a Commenti second anti-ignorance's point. very well said good sir.
rude.
I just watched this documentary this last weekend. I really don't know what the point or agenda behind it is. All I saw were examples of how rampant alcoholism doesn't help anyone or their families. I saw how people could "live" off hand-outs which didn't seem to motivate them (especially when it's enough to get alcohol to drink all day). One of the boys did their best in spite of what life brought while the other seemed to always self-destruct at the last second even admitting to being "scared of success". What did I learn? Don't be an alcoholic if you are going to be a parent. Love your kids and invest in them. There are schools out there that actually care for the kids like the one shown in the school. I also saw the poorest of the poor and there are still opportunities - one took most of them and the other gave up. You can't do much for those who give up regardless of how many doors you open.
Such behavior is not uncommon in the inner-city ghettos as well. But PBS wouldn't dare do a documentary set there; that would be politically incorrect and racially divisive to boot. But it's OK to depict a bunch of fat, toothless hillbillies as sponging off the government.
anyone that has spent any time in rural appalachia or the ozarks knows that this is the real truth. i am a "yankee" with mountain roots, and this piece is written with a great lack of empathy or experience.
these country folks need opportunity. and just like a rural ghetto, the cycle of poverty, public assistance, substance abuse, and dysfunction will continue until those that can help, actually do it. to sit by and wallow in cynicism only perpetrates this depressed lifestyle. shut your cakehole and help your fellow man.