12

Critical Thinking May Be More Important Than We 'think' when it Comes to Schools in American Society

In a Democratic Society, Skills Such as Independent and Critical Thinking, Creativity, the Forming of Opinions, and the Ability to Interact Socially, Are All Necessary in Order to Engage in the Community Adequately and Effectively

Penelope

Why is a democratic style of learning important? How do we implement this style into our classrooms each day? These questions and more are considered in the following article analysis, as well as suggestions on how to make critical thinking part of the every day class.

Meredith, K. Policy Matters: Freedom, Responsibility and Democratic Schools.
Thinking Classroom, A Journal of Reading, Writing, and Critical Reflection.

This article brought to life the idea of what schools should look like in a democratic society. The author noted various reforms in education around the world. The topic of Critical Literacy was mentioned and noted as "the capacity to engage in community as a capable individual." This type of literacy may depend on the type of the community the learners are a part of. In this particular article, the type of community involves democracy.

In order for learners to engage in the community of a democratic society, several elements of education are required. For example, students need not only to be able to emit verbatim, they are also expected to fulfill basic societal expectations of democratic citizens. In a democratic society, skills such as independent and critical thinking, creativity, the forming of opinions, and the ability to interact socially, are all necessary in order to engage in the community adequately and effectively.

This topic is frequently discussed in education classes, however, rarely from the viewpoint of a formerly communistic society. It was interesting to note the importance of reform in such newly democratic societies. It was also encouraging to see the success of implementing such reforms. Naturally, it is a lengthy process; however several encouraging statements from teachers in newly democratic education systems were mentioned. The teachers seemed to be excited about using engaging activities, group work, collaboration, and student input.

The newfound freedom of many formerly communistic societies is not to be taken lightly, as noted in the article. Freedom goes hand in hand with responsibility. From several courses, I have learned that in the world of education, there needs to be accountability in order to foster responsibility. In other words, educators have a huge responsibility to create and foster a learning environment in which students are able to feel safe and secure, and get an adequate and meaningful education.
I found this article to be informative and encouraging. It seems that education reforms are being implemented successfully. Naturally, there will always be critics when it comes to change. However, it seems that schools in newly democratic societies are attempting to make changes that will ultimately improve the education system. Also, through these reforms, students should be better able to adapt to the changing society around them.

In order to implement this style of democratic learning, there are several things teachers can do, without adding too much stress to their already chaotic schedules. One thing they can do is have students elect a student council. Each student should submit a 1-2 page report on why they are running for student council, 2-3 changes they would like to see, and why their fellow peers should vote for them. Each student should also get at least 3 adult recommendations. This type of activity promotes leadership and encourages democratic thinking.

Another way to implement critical thinking into the classroom is to have students right reviews or editorials on current news events. Each student should be able to pick from a list of 3-4 events. They should then form several opinions on the event. For example, they may write about an annual art show. Their job is to go to the art show, and answer pre-selected questions about the art show. They then turn their questions into a written assignment and share it with the class. This activity allows students to not only experience the society around them, it also allows them to formulate opinions and model creative and critical thinking.

These are just two easy ways to incorporate critical thinking into the classroom. There are also several activities that can easily become group activities. Group activities should always different roles, such as leader, recorder, researcher, artist, etc. That way, students are learning to think and work together, while each having an independent and equally important role, just like in a democracy!

Published by Penelope

I love the Lord and am thankful and amazed at His provision and redemption in my life through Christ alone.  View profile

  • Teachers will gain ideas on how to implement critical thinking into the classroom
  • Students who develop critical thinking skills will be able to contribute more fully to a democracy
  • Democratic societies require citizens who think for themselves and do not accept everything
Critical thinking is built through group work, student discussions, and student led activities.

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Robert O. Adair10/23/2009

    Judging from college students I have talked to and their writings, some "Critical Thinking" courses must be more like training in Sophism or just plain bitching. Universities once stressed good, sound logical thinking, terra incognita to many college graduates, especially from Liberal dominated schools. Dorothy Sayers classic essay on "The Lost Tools of Learning" sparked a revival of teaching logic in schools.

  • K. Hall10/7/2006

    I don't know that those skills are innately required by math and science, a lot depends on how it is taught. For example, students may do math problems straight from the textbook and have no need to collaborate or think beyond what the text requires them to. Science may also be taught in a mundane and boring way. Group work, debates, projects, labs, all of those methods require critical thinking and reasoning skills. The article was in no way promoting the elimination of math and science, it was simply promoting the idea of implementing more democratic teaching methods into an already existing curriculum.

  • T. Rawat10/5/2006

    The great thing about democracy is that we can decide not to implement nonsense like this. Pushing for increased focus in maths and sciences will have the same desired effect as "critical thinking skills and creativity in the classroom" because math and science innately require such skills.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.