There's a risk in choosing very popular songs. Everybody knows the original and no matter how good the performance is, it'll still be compared to it, especially when it happens to be one of the most famous pop-songs of all times, made famous by one of the best pop vocalists of all times. David has shown what he can do with his voice many times, so if anybody could pull this one off, it would most definitely be him. But did he pull it off?
Even while writing this, I got torn between answering yes and no all the time. Yes, he gave an absolutely flawless performance and topped it off with a small pitch show. He looked so natural behind his piano that it's hard to imagine him being anywhere but on a stage. Singing is in his nature, it's what he's supposed to do, it's his destiny. He slipped a little bit in a few performances but nailed this one, and made sure there's no doubt he's still the number one favorite, especially now other favorites are slipping in their performances. So why am I not convinced?
Basically, for exactly the same reason. He looks natural on stage as if he's never been anywhere else. So much so, that it almost becomes boring. It doesn't look like I'm watching AI, the contest, anymore. It looks like I'm watching DA perform on a chart show. And although his performance itself might be great ,it's not surprising or exciting, it doesn't make me want to hear more of him. I know he'll be on the show again next week, preforming another great song and show the world he's a great kid with an amazing voice. But would I buy his album or pay to see him play? I'm afraid not. And in the end, that might be why he won't win this competition after all...
Published by Porteno
Belgian born, worked as a roadie, programmer, barman and software engineer until 1999. Since then, I've been working in a beachclub 6 months a year and traveling the other 6. Current aim: move to Barcelona... View profile
- David Archuleta Signs with 19 Recordings/Jive RecordsDavid Archuleta signs with 19 Recordings/ Jive Records: a boon for this promising young artist.
- David Archuleta Stole the American Idol Crown from David CookDavid Archuleta seized the moment to prove to American Idol fans that he is equally as worthy of winning the title of American Idol. Will Archy's Angels come through?
- David Archuleta: What's All the Buzz About?What is it about David Archuleta that has the American Idol judges and viewers going ga-ga?
- David Archuleta Shares Funniest Fan Question During HomecomingIt's Official! David Archuleta will sing The Star Spangled Banner at the Utah Jazz and L.A. Lakers NBA Playoff game Friday.
- David Archuleta, Neil Diamond, and GodOn Neil Diamond night, David Archuleta brought the same things to the table that he always does.
- David Archuleta, Utah's American Idol Hopeful, Shares His Life Stories
- David Archuleta Moves Closer to Final Two with Think of Me Performance on American...
- American Idol: David Archuleta Performs "Angel"
- David Archuleta, American Idol Superstar Returns to Party in Utah
- American Idol's David Archuleta Takes on Mariah Carey: Can We "Believe" in Him?
- David Archuleta Shines on With You; Not so Much on And So It Goes
- David Archuleta Announces Tour Dates; American Idol Favorite Prepares to Tour Unit...

9 Comments
Post a Comment"He looks natural on stage as if he's never been anywhere else. So much so, that it almost becomes boring." -- what are you smoking? I guess I must have missed the message to society that humility and confidence on stage is a bad thing. *Shakes head*
You are just so jealous of David Archuleta!!! Negative article like yours should be erased!!! I hate someone like you who can't appreciate pure voice and wonderful personality like David Archuleta has. You have no right to put David Archuleta down. Next time you write about David Archuleta, you must be careful... Majority of American populations love David Archuleta!!!
No matter what you say before, now and the future, it's rubbish! Many, many, many people will buy David Archuleta's records. His voice is pure, enchanting and refreshing. Not like David A who is just groaning, shouting and screetching, like a worn tire. Didn't you heard or read in the news, that of all the AI songs this year, David A's songs are the most downloaded. Convert that to records, and it will just be the same. He tops. So stop saying RUBBISH, it just reflects on your personality.
5 words: "You speak only for yourself."
who ever heard of you writting this crap about David, you wish you had half the talent that david has. He is still the front runner still has the best voice in the competition and has a big fan base, so he will diffinitely win american idol.
Honestly, since when was perfection and talent wrong or bad?
Since when is pure talent a flaw on American Idol? I see David A selling LOTS of albums and gaining a wide audience because soulful music never gets old. You're entitled to your opinion, but I completely disagree with you.
Pfft, HOPEFULLY David wins. Or America's insane.
You are completely wrong and can't wait for the day when you eat your words!!! get a better job because obviously you have no eye for judging talent...who r u anyway..a worthless writer !!!! freak!