But if the Decemberists are his metaphorical master's thesis in the rock industry, then a little known band out of Missoula, Mont., was his undergraduate course of study.
Meloy, along with guitarist Gibson Hartwell, bass player Louis Stein, drummer Brian Collins and pedal steel player Kevin Suggs, formed Tarkio in 1996. The band, named for an obscure city in Western Montana, gained a small following due to its blend of indie pop and alt-country.
Placing Tarkio's two album discography (I Guess I was Hoping for Something More and Sea Songs for Landlocked Sailors) next to the Decemberists' growing body of work paints an interesting picture of Meloy's progression through the music industry. Tarkio's songwriting style is very direct, with many songs stating the literal singer's thoughts and feelings.
"Weight of the World," an upbeat, existential piece about living week to week, has a contemporary feel uncommon to the band's successor. "And as the weekend's ending / With the weekdays pending / Having trouble comprehending / how I'll make it through," Meloy sings during the bridge.
The approach, though not without its charms, seems a little dry. At the time, Meloy still seemed to be finding his voice. And although the wit and song craft the artist is now famous for does peak through during songs like "Tristan and Iseult" (And as the credits role/Tristan turned to Iseult/said, 'What did ya think?'/'It was okay, I guess/That story's pretty old'), his true talent wouldn't be heard until the Decemberists' debut release Castaways and Cutouts.
Musically, Tarkio is perhaps more initially accessible than Meloy's current endeavor. The instrumental arrangements, many featuring banjo; fiddle; horns and so on, are sweet and catchy. "Caroline Avenue" is the perfect marriage of traditional folk instrumentals with indie songwriting, while "Keeping Me Awake" opens with a meshing of banjo and mandolin that could make any Sufjan Stevens fan smile.
The traditional feel of these two albums is strikingly different than the grandiose arrangements employed in many Decemberists' works, such as "The Mariner's Revenge Song." This song is ear candy for any avid listener, but its epic scope and dark, European influenced score is unlikely to draw in new fans the way a catchy, alt-country number can.
While the band may not be as dynamic as its founder's later projects, Tarkio is still worth noting as a stepping stone to greater things. Apparently, enough curiosity was shown by the public for record label Kill Rock Stars to re-release the band's two albums on a compilation called Omnibus.
So for those who consider themselves true members of the Decemberists' "Youth and Beauty Brigade," Tarkio provides an interesting look at the budding talent of one of alternative rock's more notable contemporaries.
Published by Nick Schurk
I have been writing for various publications since 2003. In college I wrote for Saint Norbert's SNC Times and became the music editor at the UWM Leader. I have written freelance stories for the Green Bay Pre... View profile
- Ryan Adams: Alt-Country God Here is a short look at the works or Mr. David Ryan Adams.
- Kasey Anderson: a Little Bit Country, a Little Bit Rock-n-roll. All Musician. A...Currently on tour in Europe, Kasey Anderson takes a few minutes out of his non-stop show schedule to answer a few questions for me.
- Essential Film Crew Positions and How to Avoid Them when Making an Indie FilmEvery year tens of thousands of artists embark upon the task of making an indie film -- most do it wrong from the start.
- Choose the Wedding Song That's Right for Youwhen choosing your music, the song on which you should place the most importance is your wedding song. This is the song you and your partner will first dance to as a married couple.
- Review of Colin Meloy at the Rio in Santa Cruz, California
- The Decemberists: The Crane Wife
- The Decemberists Hit New High Point with The Crane Wife
- Nick Schurk's Top Ten Albums of 2006
- 100 Indie/Alternative Love Songs
- Introduction to the Alt-country Genre
- Bobby Bare, Jr.'s The Longest Meow Delights and Amuses in Alt-Country Genre
