Disciplining Children With 1-2-3

Beyond Time Out, an Approach for Redirecting Behavior

Alice Langholt
Discipline for children is a difficult subject, as varied as the personalities of the children and parents themselves. Parents can find themselves frustrated from yelling, repeating themselves, and fighting with their children to get them to follow instructions or behave appropriately. Regardless of the differences in individual personalities and behaviors, there are a few tried and true techniques that can be helpful in getting through the difficult times, and establishing authority and boundaries that are necessary for a successful parent-child relationship. While no technique is the answer in itself, successful discipline can be achieved by combining several methods that work for your own family.

One method of discipline is called 1-2-3 magic. It is very simple, yet can be effective in setting boundaries, establishing authority, and allowing the child to be empowered to make the right choice. This method can be effective for teachers as well as parents, and work in the classroom for maintaining appropriate behavior from the students. Here's how this discipline method works.

When the parent gives the child an instruction, and the child refuses, the parent says, "That's one. Three will be a time-out" (or other consequence the parent decides on, which depends on the severity of the child's action and what makes sense.) The child then has a chance to make the correct choice. If he still refuses to follow the instruction, the parent says simply, "That's two." The parent may choose to repeat the instruction, or else wait another minute or two. If the child stops the inappropriate behavior and follows the instruction, then the problem has been solved. If not, the parent says, "That's three," and follows with the consequence stated at the start of the counting.

Please note that this method should not be used in the case of a child hitting or otherwise hurting another person, or if the child says something totally inappropriate that needs to be stopped immediately. In those cases, a consequence needs to happen immediately, as if the child has gone straight to "three."

This discipline method can most helpful for parents or adults who are tired of repeating themselves and yelling to get a child to follow directions. Simply counting can replace yelling.

It is important to follow through with the consequence, whether it is a time-out, or removing a privilege. The age of the child will dictate the appropriate consequence, whether it is loss of allowance, removal of television privileges, additional chores, early bedtime, or grounding, to name some. The more matter-of-fact and unemotional the parent can be when administering the consequence, and even when doing the counting itself, the more the discipline method can be effective. One of the things that encourages children to repeat their testing behavior is when the parent reacts emotionally to the child's behavior. If the parent stays calm, the child loses that feeling of power over the parent's emotional state.

Discipline can be a daunting task for parents and adults. This 1-2-3 method can be a tool for establishing authority in a way that preserves the adult's dignity and emotional state, and reduce frustration for all involved. Seek the advice of your child's pediatrician, and the book "1-2-3 Magic" for more information.

Published by Alice Langholt

Alice Langholt is a published card writer, musical playwright, Reiki Master, game developer and teacher. An all around creative person, Alice is also a mom of 4 adorable kids.  View profile

  • The book 1-2-3 Magic is a great resource for this method.
  • 1-2-3 is a simple, yet powerful way to redirect a child's behavior.
  • This method enables children to make better choices.
  • 1-2-3 can work in the classroom as well as at home.
1-2-3 can help parents communicate expectations better, and children understand that good behavior is their choice.

2 Comments

Post a Comment
  • sha1/23/2007

    meany head

  • Teresa McLeod2/27/2006

    I use counting in my 8th grade classroom....I do it verbally and/or silently with my hand raised and using my fingers to count. The students know that if I get past 3 they have more work to do. :-)

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.