I really have to wonder at Disney's motives. Do they think they need, like affirmative action, to give equal time to each individual people group? If so, they may be in business forever. This movie, The Princess and the Frog has stirred up quite a bit of controversy. There have been some unsavory comments about the first "mixed race couple" in Disney history. To be completely honest, the major issue I have with this movie is that it promotes stereotyping. It takes place in New Orleans and has quite a "cajun zest" to it. That statement alone will most likely have brought up some sense memories (images, sounds, smells, tastes). Thanks to movies and television shows, stereotyping has become a major problem, even with more privileged groups. Take the movie and show Clueless for example. Though the idea of the "valley girl" had been around for a while, this show only promoted the stereotype for people who lived in the "valley". In the same way, Disney uses language and "common ideas" to promote a stereotype because people will be more familiar with it. Thus they are better able to connect with their audiences. Unfortunately for us, their target audience is generally small children. Disney has officially made stereotyping not only available, but commonplace in society.
Now the real question is, how does this movie promote stereotypes and how can you be sure if the movie isn't even out yet? Watch a preview of this movie, but pay attention to the things that you normally take for granted, like speech and humor. Though the movie is set in the 1920's, Disney, in an attempt to be politically correct, has been almost faithless to the historical accuracy. For instance, the Princess Tiana's language is a well-enunciated Creole English. No problems there, it does take place in New Orleans. It's the attitude of the princess that leads me to relate to a stereotype. It's the same attitude that is parodied in a skit on Saturday Night Live with the "4 snap, z snap".
Disney isn't the most generous of companies when it comes to their black princess. Instead having a transformation into something majestic and graceful (like the swan princess), they turn her into a frog. Quite a twist, eh?
Disney obviously felt guilty about not having a black princess, so they decided to make it up. Good for them, but could they have been more tasteful and less stereotypical about it, definitely. Perhaps setting it in the 1920's allows them to make excuses for their stereotyping. Whatever helps you sleep at night, Disney.
Published by Niki Tungren
An unwilling product of northern Minnesota, I rose from the snows and am currently traveling where ever I can. Currently trying to find my way around Austin, Texas and loving it. View profile
- Disney's First African American Princess Undergoes ChangesUnder the pressure of rising critiques of Disney's newest 2D film, "The Princess and the Frog," the animators have scrapped their original story board and are starting over.
- The Good, the Bad, the Ugly, and the Truth is Really Stranger Than FictionWhat can you say about the 2007 baseball season that hasn't been said already? Records were broken while playing under the foreboding clouds of a steroid controversy and the Rockies made it to .....
- WonderCon 2009: Disney's Return to 2D AnimationDisney shows off its 2D animation project "The Princess and the Frog" during WonderCon 2009.
Will the My Fair Lady Remake Give a New Shot in the Arm to Movie Musicals?The live-action movie musical may be on the cusp of a new golden era with the more sincere musical and the darker musical seeming to have their own successful niches. "My Fair L...
Fall 2009 Movies for Kids: Monsters, Ghosts, Aliens and FrogsChildren of all ages are anticipating a whole new season at the movies. Over 50 movies will be released this fall, including many for kids. Here are just a few future-classics...
- Disney's 2009 The Princess and the Frog as a Reminder of What New Orleans Lost
- Animated African-American Princess in Walt Disney's The Princess and the Frog
- Disney's First Black Princess - Tiana
- Meet Tiana, Disney's Newest Princess
- Advertising Avalanche Begins Early for Disney's "The Princess and the Frog"
- Printable Princess and the Frog Coloring Pages and Ways to Reuse Them
- Free Printable 'Princess and the Frog' Coloring Pages




3 Comments
Post a CommentTrue, it does not reflect a public belief, but it does create one. Disney's primary target is younger children, correct? oftentimes children have no impressions of different social groups and then they are fed this information through exaggeration and ridiculousness. So Disney may not be "buying into stereotypes" but they are creating them for the next generation
I agree with Yail Bloor. Slamming shut doors to discussion because a theme or setting upsets you is by far the most ridiculous part of the whole PC movement.
I just watched the preview as you suggested and I must say that you are perhaps being a little over-sensitive. So they used some cultural symbols of Louisiana Creole culture. This is not stereotyping. This is telling a story within a given setting. From wiki, a stereotype is a commonly held public belief about specific social groups, or types of individuals. The film is not saying (at least insofar as we can judge from the preview) that people in the real world are like this. Hence, it does not reflect a public belief about a social group.