Does American Idol Have One Too Many Judges?

One has to wonder why Paula is the only one speaking up about the tedious draw on the show adding another voice adds. Besides the fact her statements are never original. Face it, Kara may be great at many things, but as a judge on American Idol she is frankly boring and unnecessary. What does she really add to the process? There is an old saying that goes something like "if it ain't broken don't fix it."

Unfortunately, people are always trying to make what is working, work harder and then they just, in effect, ruin it. American Idol is a bit lame but it offers so much too so many, in regards to the contestants who get the chance at stardom and whether we admit it or not it really is all those characters who audition that makes it worth watching for the audience. I really hope those running the show, don't run it in the ground.

Well, last night, Idol was missing in action due to the Presidential speech. Were you disappointed? I know I was! But their back tonight with group number 2, singing for that coveted spot in the top 12. Regardless of the judges and their nit picking ultimately America gets to vote.

If you have a favorite don't let them down by not picking up the phone. And even though we have to put up with the judges and their nonsense, we really don't need them to tell us what we like. Maybe American Idol should let America vote on which judge will stay and which one will have to go. Do you think anyone would vote Simon out or is he our guilty pleasure that we love to hate?