Dr. Phil Breaches APA's Code of Conduct with Spears Family
Celebrity Doctors Need to Be Even More Careful About Confidentiality
According to Reuters, Dr. Phil visited Britney Spears at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center on Saturday January 5,2008-just 36 hours after being admitted for bizarre behavior. Afterwards, he made several public statements about Britney, breaching the confidentiality of Britney and her family.
The American Psychological Association's (APA's) Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct consist of an introduction, preamble, general principles, and Ethical Standards. Dr. Phil has breached just about every area and section in that code. However, for brevity and the obvious, he specifically breached Informed Consent to Therapy (section 4.02) and Confidentiality (section 5.01-5.11).
As a celebrity psychologist, Dr. Phil integrated entertainment with ethics, violating the rights of a patient in dire need of help. There is a special section on the Code of Conduct specifically titled, "APA statement on services by telephone, teleconferencing, and internet." This specifically includes any media that could harm another individual or breach their confidentiality.
Celebrity doctors are especially in a delicate position to adhere to the full term of confidentiality. For instance, a doctor may have a family intervention if a family seeks it. Then, according to the code of ethics, the doctor would be allowed to intervene with the family, because the family sought the help and wanted the therapy. However, unless a patient consents to the therapy or intervention, this breaches the rights of at least one family member. In addition, if the intervention also includes a neighbor, a friend, or a co-worker that doesn't want this information aired, then this could pose quite a bit of problem, especially since national television aired that private information. This is the celebrity doctor's loophole, because it will also be the family's responsibility-not just the doctor's.
Did Dr. Phil make sure to cover all areas of confidentiality in his shows, including the loopholes? It remains to be seen, but in Britney's case, the Spears family wanted the intervention, but Britney did not. Dr. Phil could have had a family meeting, outside of the hospital setting, to discuss the best way to get intervention for Britney. There was not an informed consent by Britney for any kind of help from Dr. Phil.
After leaving the medical center, Dr. Phil made several public statements about Britney and her condition. Any public statement about a patient's private matter is strictly in violation of the APA's code of conduct. This type of conduct from a doctor could embarrass a patient and inhibit their desire to get help.
Maybe a celebrity doctor who violates these ethical codes could at least abide by one: Preamble "consult with others concerning ethical problems." It is the code that could save face after the mistake he made.
Published by Cheryl Myers
**ON HIATUS** View profile
Is One Month Enough to Cure Britney Spears? The biggest talk of the town right now is that Britney Spears is out of Rehab. Considering the star's pre-Promises condition, one has to wonder if one month is long enough to c...
Britney Spears Meltdown Saga Continuesit was reported that Britney Spears had stopped by the house that her estranged husband Kevin Federline's is staying. After arguing with him, Federline reportedly told her that...
Britney Spears Files for Divorce from Kevin FederlineBritney Spears has filed for divorce Tuesday from Kevin Federline, official news organizations are reporting.
How to Be More like Britney SpearsThe youth of today has quite the role model in Britney Spears. Here are some pointers so we can all be more like
her.
VIP Speaker Dr. Kenny Davin Fine to Speak in TucsonDr. Fine has incorporated his passion and professional singing and songwriting musical skills into the public educational programs of the Intestinal Health Institute.
- Book Review: The Making of Dr. Phil an Intriguing Read With an Interesting Omission
- Should You Try to Get Your Problem Solved on The Dr. Phil Show?
- Little Known & Interesting Facts About Dr. Mehmet Oz, America's Doctor
- Raleigh, NC Plastic Surgeon Dr. Michael Law Introduces the No Lift Browlift.
- Oprah, Dr. Oz and Goji Berries
- Product Review: Dr. Oetker Mousse
- Review of Dr. Miller's Holy Tea
- APA has a Code of Conduct for psychologists to follow
- Most sections of the Code of Conduct was violated
- Celebrity doctors do not see the loopholes
3 Comments
Post a CommentI'd like to know what anyone who reads this and is rooting for Phil to crash and burn has done to try to help millions of people. You are jealous backbiters and should be ashamed of yourselves.
I would think Dr. Phil is a complete fool but he has made so much money. So I just think he is a money grubbing slob. Great article!
I watched him defend himself. The media followed his move into the hospital and out, and all he said was she was ill. Plus, he gave up his license a while back and was acting as a friend.