Dryel VS. Dry Cleaner's Secret: Battle of the Dry-Cleaning-At-Home Brands
I've used both products and, predictable, found pros and cons with each. The good news is that both Dryel and Dry Cleaner's Secret can help you reduce your dry cleaning bill significantly. More than that, both make it incredibly convenient to do some of your non-dry cleaning garments. Here's an honest assessment of both, broken down by consumer interest areas.
HOW THEY WORK: Both Dryel and Dry Cleaner's Secret bring one of the main tools of professional dry cleaners to your home: steam cleaning. Damp pads of cleaning solution are in sealed envelopes. Put your clothing in the dryer, add the pad and your dryer basically steam cleans your clothes. Both products leave your clothes clean with a fresh scent. No cigarette smokes or perfume remnants remain. Clothes almost always come out without needed ironing and ready-to-wear. Dryel requires 30 minutes in the dryer; Dry Cleaner's Secret only requires 20. For best results, remove the clothes just a few minutes before the timer goes off.
CONVENIENCE: By allowing you to do dry-cleaning at home, the convenience of either product can't be overstated. You can literally pull an outfit out of the hamper, wrinkled and dirty, and 20 minutes later...you've got a fresh outfit. The convenience factor is so great that I find myself cleaning some clothes this way that don't have to be dry-cleaned. It's that easy. Dry Cleaner's Secret gets the edge on this one. You don't have to worry about the bag.
PRICE: Both are very close in price. After the initial purchase, you can do 24 pieces of laundry for $9.99. The same number done at a professional dry cleaner will easily cost near $50 or more. Your first purchase of Dryel will be a little higher. The starter set, which includes a bag and a stain removal kit, allows you to do 16 garments for $9.99. Once that starter set is purchased, both Dryel and Dry Cleaner's Secret are $9.99. A good shopper can often find them on sale for $7.99 at CVS, Walgreen's and Rite Aid. Both call for dry cleaning four garments per load. In my experience, this has held true for both Dryel and Dry Cleaner's Secret if you're cleaning pants, jackets, sweaters and other heavy items. If you're dry-cleaning lighter items, you can often sneak in another item or two.
STAINS: Let's face it. Most professional dry cleaners have problems with many stains. The same is true with Dry Cleaner's Secret and Dryel. Both have instructions on stain removal, but the two products vary greatly. Dry Cleaner's Secret suggests you the damp rag on the stain. Dryel's stain-removal system is a little more advanced and has given me better results. It comes with a bottle of solution and an absorbing pad. You rub the solution on the stain with the pad located behind the stain. I've been able to get many tough stains out with this. In this category: I give Dryel the edge in this category.
WHEN THEY DON'T WORK: I don't use either product with lined suits or with linen. I think these fabrics should be dry-cleaned and could actually be damaged by these products. The packaging on both products suggests you test a small area of the fabric first. I think you should just use common sense. Rayon is a go; silk is not. A man's tie will do fine with either product. A sports coat? No. Leather? No.
In closing, it's hard for me to choose one. I have both in my laundry room now. I probably use Dry Cleaner's Secret more as I find it on sale more often. And it's just a tad easier to throw your clothes in there without the bag. And you don't have to worry about when the bag needs to be replaced. I do keep some Dryel on hand to take care of any stains.
Published by Amanda Cartwright
Amanda Cartwright lives in the South. She has written for newspapers and magazines for over 20 years. View profile
-
Reviewing the Cadie Dry Cleaning Pad
This article reviews a dry cleaning pad that claims to erase dirt like magic.
- Tips for Saving on Dry Cleaning Tips for when to take clothes to the cleaners, when to do it yourself and how to dry clean at home.
- Organic Dry Cleaning: Is it for REAL? A few weeks ago I saw something unusual to me in my town --- a dry cleaner that promotes itself as organic.
- Review of the Intex Dry Cleaning Sponge: Professional Spot & Dirt Remover A good cleaning product to use if you have smoke and fire damage.
- The $65 Million Dollar Dry Cleaning Question Roy Pearson, a DC administrative hearings judge has filed a lawsuit in the amount of $65 million against Custom Cleaners in Northeast Washington over a pair of pants.
- Home Dry Cleaning Kits: Save Time and Money
- Dry Cleaning Options in Syracuse, New York
- Skip the Dry Cleaners and Use Dryel
- Popular Dry Cleaners in the Ithaca, New York Area
- How to Save Money on Your Dry Cleaning Bills
- Relaxx Valet Eco-Friendly Dry Cleaning Solution
- Dry Cleaning Services in Lubbock, Texas
|
|
- 1. The good news: both products will replace many trips to the dry cleaners.
- 2. Both products cost about the same.
- 3. Both products are extremely convenient.
13 Comments
Post a CommentHello All,
I am very unhappy with dry cleaning/machine washing my dress shirts professionally. The ironing job is great but the cleaning and cost are not worth it for me. I have also had a few collars damaged over the years.
I want to clean my dress shirts at home. Which product would you recommend? I will not have stains (very rare) it is simply the collar and the cuffs that get dirty where it is in contact with my skin. That is it.
I wear a layer under always so nothing else gets dirty really. But the collars are usually white and very obvious.
What do you recommend?
Thank you kindly,
Moe
I am sorry that Dryel has stopped selling the liquid dry cleaning fluid. I have used this for so many years - since they began selling. I don,t like the pen. So hope they will soon bring back the liquid.
Here's the thing I've found about these products. I'm not sure either of them actually "clean" per se, but both do a decent enough job freshening your dry cleaning. I'm convinced that Dry Cleaners Secret actually does a better job, by virtue of the fact that lint and other small debris is pulled off of the fabric and found in the dryer vent filter, whereas with the Dryel product, everything remains in the bag and ends up being redeposited on the material. Only problem is, Dry Cleaners Secret smells like extremely strong baby lotion and the smell lingers indefinitely. Dryel on the other hand actually has a very mild, pleasant odor, which dissipates rather quickly. So there are your two choices, cleaner, but smelly or fresh and linty.
I wear suits everyday in my job as a banker. Dry cleaning is getting extremely expensive and it's not really healthy to be exposed to dry cleaning fluid residue. We tried Dryel to save on my dress slacks. I found it works best on 100% wool vs wool/polyester blends for dress slacks - as far as minor wrinkles. However, as long as you can hang the slacks full length on pants hanagers for a day, they tend to come out very well. I recommend, just make sure and pull they slacks and hang them immediately upon completing the dryer cycle.
There's another home dry cleaning option from Clorox called "Fresh Care": http://www.cloroxfreshcare.com/dryclean.html
im emialing about your prouct and i love it . i rather spend the money for it . thank you !
Great information. I look forward to trying this product.
Great review! I loved the overview of things you should and shouldn't use it on. I hadn't heard of Dry Cleaner's Secret before, but I love Dryel...."professional" dry cleaning is pretty affordable where I live and there is one pretty much in every shopping center, but I love the convenience factor and overall it is still cheaper than the real thing!
Great comparison!
Excellent comparison review! I have been using the Dryel for a long time and love it!!