DVD Cases and Other Things Designed Not to Work

Will Wright
Have you ever noticed that some things in life just don't work like they should? While I'm not much one for conspiracy theories, I can't help but think that this is by design - that certain things are designed simply not to work. They are purposely designed to be inefficient, non-user friendly, or just plain difficult to operate. With this in mind, here are a few things that have been designed not work.

Magazines

You ever tried to find a page number in a magazine, or even the table of contents for that matter? It's next to impossible. You can't even open a magazine without stuff falling out. What kind of design is this?

Well, the answer, of course, is simple. You aren't supposed to find anything in a magazine - except the ads. Magazines are designed in a similar fashion to commercial television. The only reason either exists is to deliver ads. TV does it by trying to come up with programs you'd like to watch to sandwich between the ads. Magazines operate much the same way, except that they work hard to make it impossible to find what it is you actually wanted to read in the magazine. Obviously there are some exceptions, but try thumbing through an issue of virtually any magazine and not see an ad.

Government

The United States Federal Government is a perfect example of a system that's designed not to work. This is not necessarily a bad thing. The system of checks and balances is beautifully inefficient, and I'm thankful for it most of the time. Because the government doesn't work very well, it can't muck things up too much. The Founding Fathers were wise to design such a wonderfully inept governmental system. Unless you need something from the government, the system is about as close to imperfect as perfection can get. The government is at its most efficient when it's doing nothing at all.

Squeezable Mustard Bottles

This might be a personal pet peeve, but have you ever tried to refill a squeezable mustard bottle? Once you screw off the cap, you'll find a larger opening that I'm convinced is designed just a hair too small to fit a spoon into. So when I go to refill a squeezable mustard bottle from a cheaper jar of mustard I can't do so without making a mess. To me this is by design. If the opening was just a bit wider, I could refill it with no problems. It seems as though the opening is designed to make refilling such a pain that you say, forget it, and just buy another more expensive bottle of squeezable mustard.

Toothpaste Tubes

Every time I brush my teeth I can't help but marvel at the 19th-century design of the toothpaste tube. No matter how hard I try, I can never get all of the toothpaste out of the tube, which means that I have to buy toothpaste more often.

Instead of having the number of ounces of toothpaste on the label, I think they should put the number of ounces you can get out of the tube.

DVD Cases

I got to thinking about this one after one of my daughter's favorite movies developed a crack.

I love DVD's. I do not love DVD cases. I understand the need to make them difficult to get into. That slows shoplifters down by a few seconds. But what I don't like are those little tabs that you have to push down to get the DVD out of the case. These things never seem to work well - which leads me to wonder why.

The only thing I can figure is that DVD's are not designed to wear out from play. That's one of their biggest selling points. No magnetic heads touch them as in the older VHS tapes. This means that once you buy a DVD, theoretically you should never need to replace it - unless it breaks. This is where the cases come in. I think the reason those tab things are so difficult is that they are designed to eventually crack the inner circle of the DVD, forcing you to buy a replacement. Why else would these things be so oddly designed?

So there you have it. Five things designed not to work, or at least when they do work, they don't work well. Some things, like government, can be broken down into a myriad of agencies and programs designed not to work. Others operate more like insurance companies. They're great at one thing (collecting money) but somehow remarkably inefficient when it comes to others (paying you money).

I'm sure there are other things out there that aren't designed to work. Please feel free to add to the list in the comments section below.

Published by Will Wright

I'm a film industry veteran with over a hundred professional credits.  View profile

  • Toothpaste tubes are a marvel of 19th-Century technology.
  • Squeezable mustard bottles are just a bit too small for the average spoon.
  • Why do DVD cases have such poorly designed holders?
Finding a page number in a magazine is designed to be difficult.

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Krista1/13/2009

    Don't even get me started on those DVD tab things...

  • Stephanie Armstrong12/5/2008

    Haha I love this article.

  • Picasso1/14/2008

    Yes, you are absolutely right: these things are purely sold to annoy us.Have you ever tried opening the plasic wrapping around 24 toilet-rolls? They"ll be all over the floor before you know it. Coffee-refills is another one, you cut the package open and it goes all over the kitchen-bench. Now you got me going, I can think of hundreds!! Perhaps it's all meant to keep us busy? Picasso

  • Bobby Russell1/13/2008

    (( DVD Case/ with dvds,Video Games,CDs. )) When you go to bye them, Shake them, IF you hear a ratting sound. Don't bye them! Their may be damage to them, and Thay may not work rite

  • Genie Walker1/8/2008

    Great article! Interesting observation on DVD cases, it wouldn't surprise me if you were right about their motives for making the DVD near impossible to get out without breaking the DVD.

  • Branwen661/5/2008

    LOL! Once again, spot-on...

  • jcorn1/4/2008

    I actually decided to buy a Kindle bookreader because of so many problems with magazines, including allergies to perfume ads and the frustration of having all those blow-ins fall into the bathtub while trying to read a magazine in the tub, on a special magazine holder. The trade-off? A lack of graphics but plenty of text. I expect future versions to address this problem and provide graphics.
    Funny and interesting article!

  • cathiesbloggs1/4/2008

    Excellent work with this!!!...haha..funny how these are all things that we have problems with daily!..those darn DVD cases!!!

  • theBarefoot1/4/2008

    Better Homes and Gardens magazine is the worst offender. I can never find an article in the blasted thing and the blow-ins litter my bathroom floor.

  • Angela La Fon1/3/2008

    Juice boxes. Intended for little kid's that can not get the flimsy straw into the too hard to punch hole; I am guessing there's a 75% straw/box destruction rate followed by a 45% kid melt down rate. Also, if they do get the straw in and grab it to pick it up, the juice squirts everywhere. As a preschool teacher, I used to constantly think that the engineers of this design had only tested it themselves and never with little kids; certainly not with 12 kids at a time. As far as conspiracy theories go, maybe these were produced by the makers of baby wipes or paper towels because you need when serving juice boxes to kids.

    I bought zippable CD holders to store all of our DVDs and tossed the cases because I am with you on those things. I get 30 DVDs in one case and cleared out two shelves in the entertainment center.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.