Employers and the Way You Talk

Do Employers Have the Right to Monitor Your Speech?

Rose Richmond
When my husband lost his job from Qualtek Mfg in Colorado Springs 5 months ago, we were upset as many people are when they lose a job. We were even more upset because he got fired, one day after he was asked to take a position as a designer in the company. He refused the position because he didn't feel he was qualified to do an adequate job. When he refused, he was fired. In the course of being fired, he was issued statements by the owner of Qualtek Mfg, Tony Fagnant, giving reasons for the firing.

Among those, were incompetence, lack of knowledge and ability and lack of effort. That was enough to start a war with them. I wrote articles, they got mad and threatened me with an attorney. They attempted to fight his unemployment, but backed out at the last minute, for lack of proof of the accusations. They put a Private Investigator on the case to scare us and try and destroy us. That didn't work either. Every avenue they took was a lie and so unprofessional. However, we got over it. We were determined to let it go and not think about all of the stupid stuff that happened while he was employed. The school house atmosphere, the erratic decisions, the hangovers and the unprofessional leadership that is still very active at Qualtek Mfg.

In talking about various events that happened in the 5 years he worked at Qualtek, we happened upon the conversation about the way we talk. I am from NC originally and he is from Texas. Anybody who knows those parts of the country, also knows that it comes with a particular kind of speech. "Y'all" is a staple word in the South. It comes with the territory.

While working at Qualtek, Tony Fagnant implemented a rule that if in the course of conversation or in meetings, you used words like "Y'all", you had to contribute a $1 to a fund especially for that purpose. My husband told me he had donated over $12 to this crazy rule and always had to be on his guard, when talking. He said anytime Tony was present, when he was leaving to go home or whatever the occasion was, if he said, "I will see y'all later", he was penalized and had to contribute to the wrong word fund.

I decided I could not just let this story pass on by. I am wondering how many employers have stupid ass rules like this? Is this a communist country or what? Do employers have the legal right to fine you for the way you talk?

I have applied for several jobs while living in Colorado. I made the comment once, that I got my foot in the door on many interviews, but when I opened my mouth and this Southern Drawl came spilling out, I lost all hope of getting the job. Tony Fagnant told my husband when he said that out loud, I was wrong. He said there are many people from the South in Colorado. I felt stupid for making the comment. I thought, OK, this man who is from Wyoming and Illinois says my accent shouldn't make any difference here. I will believe that. OK!

Now, after my husband no longer works there, I am finding out that he was just a liar. He too, discriminates against his employees because of speech. 90% of his workforce is from Colorado or further north. He has made numerous comments about Texans and really appears not to like them very much.

Are there other businesses that treat their employees in such a manner? I hope not. I think it would be possible to sue someone based on being required to pay because of your usage of the English language. Don't you? Can an employer force you to talk the way he thinks you should? Can they take your money because you don't?

I am appalled at this companies way of doing business. The more time that goes by, the more crazy things I am finding out. My husband wouldn't tell me while he was working there because of the reaction, he knew I would have. Qualtek Mfg. and it's owner are on a crash course with reality. They treat their employees like yesterday's trash and then throw them away. They have lied, cheated and abused their powers as employers.

The biggest lie of all is Tony's Fagnant's attempt at proper English. He criticized my husband for saying "Y'all", but in a letter about the Southern Delivery System in Colorado, he couldn't even write a paragraph properly. What?
Yes, it is posted on the Internet for the world to see. The same man collecting fines for bad speech made a complete fool of himself in his improper writing of a letter. He continues to walk around flaunting his supposed "degree" and how that makes him better than other people. Education doesn't really matter if you didn't retain it and use it.

Isn't the world full of phoniness? This business owner who looks down his nose at everyone, but came from humble beginnings, lucked out in marriage and now runs a manufacturing business, is charging people for what HE deems as "bad speech". Give me a break here. Where do these people come from? How did they come to own a business? How can anyone do business with them?

No wonder manufacturing is going to other countries. We have companies with potential in the U.S., who are more concerned with someone's speech than producing a reasonably priced, quality product. No need to wonder anymore. We know why now.

If you have an employer who is trying to control the way you talk or treats you differently because of the way you talk, then call an attorney right away. Call the Labor Board. This isn't legal. You can't do this. It is just a shame I didn't know about it while he was employed by Qualtek Mfg.

Published by Rose Richmond

Journalism, Freelance Writing.  View profile

  • Can employers control the way you talk?
  • Can employers fine you for saying "Ya'll"?
Tony Fagnant wrote a letter that is so incorrect it is silly and is posted on internet to the Southern Delivery System. Yet he criticizes others for their speech..

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Jaipi Sixbear6/10/2011

    work for myself now. What I asked for was actually a change of departments. I was in the biggest department, with the largest work load, plus I was an assistant manager. I asked to be transferred to the next largest department. I also specifically told my boss I did not want a demotion and did not want part time and that if a transfer was not possible, I'd stay put. He made sure to tell me my requested demotion went through in front of others too. I was in such shock, I had no response, therefore when I tried to tell people what went down later, it looked like I was the liar, instead of my boss. Anyhow, you are not alone in being discriminated against at work here. It's the norm for bosses to act like high-schoolers in Colorado.

  • Jaipi Sixbear6/10/2011

    It's hard to find a job in Colorado where this isn't the norm, unless you are lucky enough to work for a Mom and Pop type place. The company I most recently worked for was like high school. If you didn't have your nose up the bosses **** you didn't get anywhere. The people who sat in the break-room all day shmoozing and gossiping were held in high regard, while the ones doing all the work out on the floor caught hell. Meanwhile, the owner of the company, which is based in Oklahoma City has no idea of the nasty politics in his Colorado stores. He's the nicest guy you would ever want to meet. I worked at this place for ten years, kept hoping things would change but they really had the wool pulled over this guys eyes. Worked my butt off too. I was no slacker and kept a smile on my face and a positive attitude, despite the crap. The final straw was when the boss lied to corporate, telling them I wanted a demotion (which I got, along with a decrease in hours) So glad I w

  • Sheri Fresonke Harper9/5/2009

    How awful :)

  • Justice Lives Not8/13/2009

    Chomsky put it best when he said Corporations are but mini fascist regimes. Doesn't surprise me at all. And I am glad you fought these bastards; they're SCUM!

  • Rose Richmond8/13/2009

    It is amazing the abuse we are willing to take in order to keep a job. This place was a nightmare job. My husband has never hated a job so much in 35 years.

  • ShawnTe Pierce8/13/2009

    It's a shame your husband did not document this when it first happened. Although I probably would have written checks with the reason in the memo. Great piece of evidence to have should you need it. I would say best practice for anyone would be to refuse unethical and illegal requests. Keep copies of all of your performance evaluations, time sheets, and any awards your received on your job. This way if your employer fires you and lies about your performance you can fight it in court because you have documented proof that they lied about the reason you were fired. I still have my evaluations and awards from my last employer and I quit. lol. Keep the faith!

  • Rose Richmond8/13/2009

    Clarification: In paragraph stating when speech monitored, should read during conversations in meetings.

  • J. E. Davidson8/13/2009

    I live in an area where many people have southern drawls, and I just love it. It's especially cute when the little kids speak with a drawl. Sounds like you're both better off not being in that environment anyway.

  • Hally Z.8/13/2009

    Unless one is a press agent or some other public person for a company, there should be no mention of how one is supposed to speak. I work with a lot of international folks, and not everyone here can even speak English!

  • Rose Richmond8/13/2009

    My husband was a tool and die maker. No need for reflection on company for saying Ya'll. He was not a communicator, supervisor or leader in the company. Just a manufacturing employee. His speech did not matter. Speech he was fined for was in personal conversations not representing company in any way.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.