You'll notice that even though Humpty Dumpty is an egg to most of us, it never says that in the rhyme. Originally the rhyme was just about a short clumsy person and at the time "humpty dumpty" was slang for a short clumsy person.
There are a few different theories on what Humpty Dumpty is about. One theory is that Humpty Dumpty was a powerful cannon during the English Civil War. It was mounted on top of a tower defending the city of Colchester. The enemy attacked for 11 weeks before they finally hit the tower holding the cannon and Humpty Dumpty fell to the ground and broke. The King's horses and the King's men in the rhyme represent the cavalry and infantry who tried to repair him.
Another rumor very similar to that one is that Humpty Dumpty was a sniper nicknamed One-Eyed Thompson. This theory was exactly the same as the cannon theory. Same battle, same tower and everything, just that there was a sniper, not a cannon.
Others believe that Humpty Dumpty referred to King Richard III of England. Shakespeare depicts Richard III of England as a little hunchbacked man in his play which is why people would call Richard III of England a short, clumsy person. Falling off the wall and falling to pieces represents Richard III of England falling off his horse and being hacked into pieces during the battle of Bosworth Field. However, despite Shakespeare's depiction the real King Richard III of England was not a hunchback.
So if any of these are the origin of Humpty Dumpty then why is Humpty Dumpty an egg in the rhyme? Originally Humpty Dumpty was not meant as a story but a riddle. Even though the last line of the rhyme isn't a question it's meant to be a riddle that has an answer. The answer to the riddle is that Humpty Dumpty is actually an egg, his clumsy round proportion is why he fell and it also explains why the king's men and horses couldn't put Humpty Dumpty back together again.
One more thing you might not know about Humpty Dumpty. There is a conspiracy that Humpty Dumpty, the egg version in the nursery rhyme, was actually pushed off the wall. There was a poem written by, allegedly, the same author in which a policeman inspects all of the fairy tale characters to see if they had seen anything. They all claim to have an alibi. There alibis are what these character are known for doing in their own tales. For example when Jack and Jill are enquired they claim to be getting water at the time. In the end Bo peep admits she saw the cow that jumped over the moon push Humpty Dumpty. Humpty Dumpty was actually the thing that the cow used as a propulsion device to get over the moon.
Published by Lee Andrew Henderson
I was born, I wrote, I died. View profile
- Celebrating the Holidays in Eaton, OhioThe following is a guide to fun family activities to celebrate the holidays.
- Rock Icon Grace Slick Put Down the Microphone and Picked Up a Paint BrushGrace Slick was a strong presence in the 60s and 70s era of hippies, peace rallies, and free love. Although she no longer expresses herself through music, she continues to pursue creative efforts as an artist.
- Bio of Inventor George Crum Who Invented Potato Chips by AccidentRead this informative article and find out how America's most favorite snack got its start. You might be amazed at how a gruff cook, trying to get even with a complaining customer, made the discovery of his life!
- Meet the Man Who Inspired Star Wars, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, and Juras...Willis O'Brien founded the art of stop-motion animation, and his claims to fame are The Lost World, King Kong, and Ray Harryhausen. O'Brient was Ray Harryhausen's mentor.
- Through the Looking GlassA look at Through the Looking Glass by Lewis Carrol not as a children's story but as a piece of complex satirical literature.
- Humpty Dumpty: You're No Nursery Rhyme
- Humpty Dumpty: What's All the Hoopla About This Egghead?
- Review of "Cracked": Dr. Drew Pinsky's Book About Addiction, Recovery and Relapse
- The Top 6 Nursery Rhymes to Sing to Your Newborn
- Humpty Dumpty Retrospective
- Objective Politics
- Nursery Book Characters in the News
- There were many theories about what Humpty Dumpty represented including a cannon and sniper.
- Humpty Dumpty is a riddle not a story.
- In a sequel to the rhyme Humpty Dumpty was pushed off the wall by the cow that jumped over the moon.





15 Comments
Post a CommentRichard III sounds good. I'm inclined to think thought that it was a riddle and the king's horses and men were like the toast, when you dip them into a boiled egg, we call them Soldiers. You have to smash the top off with a spoon to eat it.
If we look at the rhyme symbolically is appears to potentially be part of an early creation myth likely from a now usurped culture. Humpty dumpty when thought of as an egg denotes potential, the unmanifest world etc. the kings horses are "the one whom we are speaking of i.e. the king, our own self or the one in charge) is animalistic servants (his sub and unconscious mind) and all the kings men (his more advanced or conscious mind) can not put humpty dumpty back together. as a mystical story it suggests one needs something above and beyond the sub and conscious mind (creative insight perhaps? an ah ha? intuition? etc) to move humpty dumpty back together.
such is the symbology, though the history appears probably.
What country did this come from?
Funny and slightly disturbing. I loved it!
I was waiting for the part where Dubya knew about Humpty's "accident" in advance and shot him off the wall with a cruise missile.
What a great topic. I always loved that rhyme.
THIS was a weird topic. Interesting, good, but weird. Thanks.
Please. It's common knowledge that humpty dumpty is really a shape-shifting 7 ft. tall repilian alien hellbent on world domination, along with pres. bush and the royal family.
Very funny
Nice. Now where did I put my saber?