I sat nursing her, stroking her still-soft head yesterday and wondered how I could ever have imagined that a baby would be ready to stop breast-feeding by a year.
When I was pregnant with my first child, I knew I would breast feed. Why not? My mom had breastfed most of her children, so I grew up thinking it was normal. But my mom also believed, along with a great deal of the United States, that "they don't need to nurse once they can eat" and "if they can ask for it, they need to wean." So I assumed that is how breast feeding was done.
But when my first child grew closer and closer to a year old, I realized it was hard to tell when she had begun asking to nurse. Was it when at 5 months old she could pluck at my shirt? Or was it at 3 months old, when she cried to let me know that other comfort measures weren't working and she wanted to nurse? Or did it begin at 9 months old when she could try to lift my shirt to find her beloved nursies? So, I just kept nursing her.
There is plenty of evidence out there that extended breastfeeding is beneficial to both mother and toddler. The World Health Organization has recommended breastfeeding for "up to two years of age or beyond." UNICEF states to "continue to breastfeed for two years or more with age appropriate, responsive complementary feeding." The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends ""that breastfeeding continue for at least 12 months, and thereafter for as long as mutually desired."
Some studies have even shown that children breastfed past infancy have fewer incidences of diabetes; have more normal jaw formation, eliminating perhaps a need for braces; are less prone to viral illnesses; and that these breastfed children have a healthy self-image and are socially well-adjusted. Other studies indicate a benefit to moms too, including a lower risk of breast cancer.
I knew all that. But nursing an infant who cannot eat or even hold her head up is almost demanded. Nursing a toddler who can walk over to her mom holding a book and ask to be read to is another thing all together. So this article will explore a few emotional benefits and reasons for breastfeeding a toddler.
The first thing to consider about extended breastfeeding is that you didn't pick up a walking, talking toddler and begin nursing her. You started out nursing a helpless baby. Day by day your baby grew and you nursed her. She grew some more, and you still nursed her. By now, it was part of your day (and night). By now, it was as natural and sweet to breastfeed her as it was to pick her up and cuddle her even after she could walk and ask to watch Barney.
For those of you nursing an infant and reading this article, breastfeeding a toddler is not the attention-demanding, exhausting, constant job that nursing a baby is. Parenting a toddler is attention-demanding, exhausting and constant, though, and extended breastfeeding is a powerful tool to help both of you through that time.
Few things are easier and sweeter than nursing your toddler down for his or her nap. By now, the two of you have an established routine of nursing and the toddler is primed to fall asleep during breastfeeding. That fact alone is enough to recommend extended breastfeeding.
Tantrums? My baby, the one about to become a toddler, already throws her head back and screams when she can't reach something or is frustrated. In a few months, she will continue to express her displeasure at the world and my directions. Extended breastfeeding eases the gap between the toddler's expectation and the reality of his world. Nursing allows him to regroup, feel connected and to recharge his coping batteries.
The inevitable bumps, bruises and hurt feelings of a toddler learning to explore her world are easily soothed and comforted by nursing. I think in this way, extended breastfeeding allows us to foster empathy and help in our young children. Not to mention, it calms the atmosphere of the home like nothing else.
I know there are still people out there who are thinking extended breastfeeding is gross, wrong, downright peculiar and unnecessary. And that's okay. I thought that, too, the first time I saw a toddler walk over to his mom and nurse.
Breastfeeding your toddler does not mean, however, that you must cater to every demand of these little would-be tyrants. It is appropriate for both the child and you to begin setting some limits on lots of things, including extended nursing. Many mothers choose to begin nursing at only nap and bedtimes for instance. Or some mothers may limit breastfeeding session's length during this second year. Most mothers will ask their child to wait to nurse until after shopping, for instance, or until they have finished a household chore.
My oldest daughter is four. I know how quickly the time goes now. By the way, she hasn't nursed at all since she was 2 ½. Gradually, and without any prompting on my part, we began nursing only at nap and nighttime. The nap session was the last to go. Most toddlers, like mine, would prefer not to nap, and breastfeeding her helped us to avoid a power struggle over napping. She doesn't even remember breastfeeding anymore. But I do, and will always treasure the memories.
My baby is almost one. But that doesn't mean I quit meeting her needs. And her needs right now include extended breastfeeding.
I hope many of you out there who are considering extended breastfeeding will also know the joy and comfort to be found for both child and mom in nursing your toddler.
Published by Marsha Raasch
I am a 44 year old mother of two girls. I am recently divorced and dealing with single parenting, being a working mom, and sending the girls to public school for the first time. View profile
- The Ups and Downs (and Backbends) of Extended BreastfeedingHighlights the pros and cons of deciding whether or not to breastfeed beyond the first year of life.
- Stop Feeling Guilty For Breastfeeding Your ToddlerIf you've found yourself practicing extended breastfeeding though you planned on weaning your little one at 12 months or even 6 months, you are not alone. Stop feeling guilty for following your instincts.
- More Women Breastfeeding Babies, but Not Long EnoughNew CDC study finds that more new mothers are breastfeeding their infants, but a significant number still do not nurse for the recommended time period.
- Breastfeeding in PublicBreastfeeding in public can be a controversial subject. Most mothers won't even discuss the subject between themselves. This article takes an in depth look at the prejudices facing mothers who choose to breastfeed in...
- Breastfeeding Basics: Nursing Guide for New and Expecting MothersIf you decide to breastfeed, there are some basics you should know to give you the best possible start and help you continue for at least the recommended six months.
- When to Stop Breastfeeding Your Child
- Breastfeeding Advice in a Nutshell
- Finding Breastfeeding Information on the Web
- The Prejudice Against Extended Nursing
- August is Breastfeeding Awareness Month and August 1-7 is World Breastfeeding Week
- The Ups and Downs (and Backbends) of Extended Breastfeeding
- Happy and Healthy Baby: Benefits of Extended Breastfeeding
- The WHO and AAP both recommend nursing past one year.
- Extended breastfeeding does not need to create a more demanding toddler.
- Extended breastfeeding can reduce the need for braces in your child's future.




7 Comments
Post a CommentHi,
Great article! I agree that breastfeeding should continue as long as you are both comfortable with it. I made a commitment to breastfeed for at least a year because my baby deserves the best nutrition I can give him. He is beginning to get teeth now so I pump during the day and he nurses at night when he is sleepy and less likely to bite. This is his preference too as he hit a nursing strike at 6 mos and will only take the breast when he is half asleep. I plan to keep giving him breast milk as long as he will take it, even if it is in a sippy cup when he's 2.
Thank you. As a matter of fact, she will be 3 in August and we still nurse a couple of times a day.
Great article.
Why should nursing stop just because they "can ask for it"? They ask to be held... should that stop? They ask to be fed... should that?
When they can say "mama" and "dada", does that mean they don't need you anymore?
Pure silliness.
bottle's comment didn't even make sense within itself. If you don't believe in giving a baby milk that is produced from it's human mother, why would you give it a milk supplement from an animal instead of human milk. And why anything in a bottle? Why not just go to the cup if you don't believe in babies having their milk. And kids do not need bottles.
Babies aren't old enough to eat cereal and jarred food until they are 6-9 months old, and it is incredibly dangerous to introduce solids before then. Breastfeeding continues to have health benefits for the duration of the nursing relationship. It remains the ideal food and has many immunological benefits even for toddlers. The AAP recommends nursing to age one, and the WHO recommends nursing until age 2. The worldwide average age of weaning is 4 1/2. Why should a baby be given formula or cow milk when free breastmilk with antibodies in it is available?
Don't listen to the other commentor. Some mothers take things to far when breastfeeding. I really don't think babies older than 3 months should ever ever be breastfed. Why should babies who are old enough to eat cereal and jarred food be able to breadfeed. Give the kid a bottle.
That you aren't comfortable with your memories because of the oversexualization of breasts in your mind doesn't mean that everyone is. I know plenty of people that do remember breastfeeding moments from their childhood with much fondness. It is sad that society has made you feel ashamed about having been breastfed by your mother, especially considering the immense immunological benefits that come with nursing. Your problem has nothing to do with extended breastfeeding but with your own problem in seeing boobs as dirty. You should seek psychological help and refrain from giving advice, as you are clearly not the person to give breastfeeding advice because of your hangups.